5 ms·
> people who want a curated store This is a straw man. Support allowing users to add alternate stores on iOS devices. Having one choice is not freedom. And i
by ethbr0 6y ago
> people who want a curated store
This is a straw man.
Support allowing users to add alternate stores on iOS devices.
Having one choice is not freedom. And it has nothing to do with curration. If Apple's model is superior, then their app store will win against fair competition.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s not a straw man. I don’t want my non-technical family members being persuaded to install other stores. It is absolutely a feature, and a beneficial one at that, which many people want. As for Apple allowing people to install other stores - why should they? Why not just buy an Android phone if you want that feature.
- hda2 6y ago> I don’t want my non-technical family members being persuaded to install other stores. Frankly, that's not your decision to make. If they own the device, they get to decide. If they don't or are too young, then you can use various controls (i.e parental controls) to lock your devices down the way you want. This is a straw man.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s absolutely my decision by to make if they ask me to recommend something to them. Especially if they have been having problems with malware and that’s why they are asking. If they own the device they get to use it as it was designed to be used. They also have the legal right to change it themselves (at least in the US). What you don’t have is any basis for forcing Apple to design software the way you want, or to force my family members not to be able to follow my recommendation to choose iOS as Apple wants to offer it to them. That’s between them and Apple and me. What right do have to dictate how any of these three parties choose to interact? There is no straw man.
- echelon 6y agoYou can't make that decision for me and millions of others. You're voting to make our industry inequitable and running software some Orwellian dystopia. I wouldn't be surprised if Apple one day mandated that we hand them the copyright to the code we write. We're one step away from that now: we already have to write against a strict spec, fit all the rules, and are subject to arbitrary dismissal. They take 30% and leave us the crumbs. The appeals process is unfair. If Apple likes what you've got, they can just clone your app. One step away. We're in prison and you're rationalizing about your parents.
- ksec 6y ago2020, the new battle ground is now on how to define the term Straw man. I am sorry this is completely off topic. But it is quite funny I notice the word suddenly gained usage, ( especially in any political debate ) and it is now sort of misused and misapplied all over the place. ( Not suggesting your or your GP are right or wrong in using the term )
- strken 6y agoThere's a pretty clear reason for passing legislation to force Apple to allow third party stores, and I think it has been explained well in the parent comments: some people believe users should control their devices. There are also pretty clear reasons for not doing so: other people believe Apple should control its devices. Politicians can legislate things. They already get to dictate how parties interact. I'm not sure how rights come into it, since they wouldn't be breaching any of your rights that I can think of.
- nemothekid 6y agoThis isn't straw man. It's been used twice in this thread incorrectly. Frankly, it's also my families decision to use Facebook, and they have the freedom to use it, but that doesn't mean I won't continue to discourage them from using the platform. Just because that's their decision doesn't mean they are properly informed about their technical decisions or understand the impact. If absolute distribution freedom was a major concern for them I'd tell them to buy Androids.
- ethbr0 6y agoEase of technical support for your family doesn't merit enslaving iOS users and developers.
- zepto 6y agoNeither Apple’s users, nor developers for iOS are forced to do anything. Comparing buying a phone to being enslaved is quite bizarre.
- ethbr0 6y agoThis is exactly the perspective we disagree over: in my opinion, Apple users and developers are absolutely forced to do something. There is a thing. They may or may not prefer different ways of handling that thing. Apple makes a choice for them, and prevents them from making their own choice. Call it what you will, but in my book, lacking the freedom to make your own choices is the definition of slavery.
- zepto 6y agoCan you explain how anybody is forced to either buy an iPhone, or develop for it? I am not aware of Apple using force to make people do either of these things.
- xncl 6y agoReminds me of the browser wars, and how Microsoft handled the threat of euro antitrust fines: https://phys.org/news/2009-07-eu-microsoft-unbundle-explorer-windows.html https://phys.org/news/2009-07-eu-microsoft-unbundle-explorer... Not sure how that affected elsewhere and IE is still bundled where I live but nevertheless reminiscent.
- burnte 6y ago> I don’t want my non-technical family members being persuaded to install other stores. On Android this isn't an issue, you leave sideloading disabled. Apple could use the same method. Apple could even make you use XCode to unlock the ability. But locking it entirely is obnoxious.
- echelon 6y agoBingo! This option doesn't open a black hole that suddenly swallows your grandparents. Where are all the people begging for Google to close this?
- zepto 6y agoThey bought iPhones.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoNobody bought an iPhone because of this retriction. Most people buy iPhones for fashion. There are very few people who have been duped into buying iPhones because of the security and privacy marketing that doesn't hold up to the barest scrutiny — most iPhone users simply don't care about that aspect of Apple's marketing.
- Xixi 6y agoiPhones, I don't know, but offering iPads to parents/grandparents because of this restriction? Yes, I know many...
- Shared404 6y ago> Apple could even make you use XCode to unlock the ability. But locking it entirely is obnoxious. Wow. That is actually a really elegant solution to that problem. Well done. The only way I would change it would be to walk it a little away from Xcode, and have it be through an official tool for Mac/Linux/Windows, and possibly open source it so it could be ported to BSD/whatever else by the community. That has it's own issues though, and I don't know that it would actually be better, it's just where I would draw the line.
- sam0x17 6y agoI disagree that this is a straw man. Apple has been consistent for _years_ on this issue -- they clearly believe that choosing the Apple ecosystem is synonymous with choosing to only be able to run code that has been reviewed (theoretically) by the app store team. If it quacks like a duck and looks like a duck then it is a duck.