5 ms·
No. You just need to not buy an Apple product. Apple is a friend of people who want a curated store. There are other options for those who don’t.
by zepto 6y ago
No. You just need to not buy an Apple product.
Apple is a friend of people who want a curated store.
There are other options for those who don’t.
- echelon 6y ago> You just need to not buy an Apple product. Consumer behavior won't change Apple. We need the strong arm of the DOJ to tell Apple not to do this. > Apple is a friend Apple is not a friend of anybody. They're a for-profit company.
- zepto 6y agoI’m not suggesting consumer behavior should change Apple. I’m suggesting that consumers should buy a product that that suits their needs. If you need alternate stores - buy Android. There is no reason at all for Apple to be forced to do anything.
- echelon 6y ago> There is no reason at all for Apple to be forced to do anything. Apple impacts businesses, consumers, engineers - multiple industries - with their bad behavior. Apple has an illegal platform and it must be regulated. They've captured 50% of the United States computing market and illegally inserted themselves as middleman into every transaction, every software install. They punish everyone trying to do business and make engineers dance through flaming hoops. Apple has become their own banana republic. Anticompetitive and illegal.
- ratww 6y ago> Apple impacts businesses, consumers, engineers - multiple industries - with their bad behavior Unfortunately the alternative is letting businesses and engineers impact the life of their own customers negatively. Developers had way too much power to screw up users for years, and they did: spying and tracking behind our backs. Mandatory rootkits [1]. Piracy Protection and DRM that did way more than advertised and caused nuisance for paying customers. Rootkits on music albums. Apple has fixed or is trying to fix most of those. If government wants to step up to regulate developers, small or big, maybe it's fine. But until then then Apple has provided the best solution to toxic developers. Sure you can say "you can't just not install the app from the toxic developer", but then why isn't it ok to use the "you can just not buy an iPhone" argument? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25030660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25030660
- zepto 6y agoI agree with you except that I believe that there is a third alternative. All the safety issues that are solved by Apple’s approach could be solved by some combination of open source and or open source development, in an open way that does away with the single gatekeeper. That would be better than either Apple or the Government controlling software distribution.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- echelon 6y agoThis is such a red herring! It's just as easy to firewall your platform and prevent trackers. Open installation and privacy are not mutually exclusive. The browser is a firewalled platform. Look at what Mozilla can do for privacy on their shoestring budget. Apple likes it the way they have it. You cannot tell me the DOJ can't force them to open their platform and suddenly every Apple user is stuck on 90's era Windows. This is not how it works.
- ratww 6y agoA firewall partially "fixes" part of the spying/tracking, but doesn't solve any of the other issues I pointed, especially concerning forced installation of software that screws up with my machine. Also, the fact I use a firewall doesn't excuse developers from being assholes and spying/tracking me behind my back. It's my computer, it's a developer's sacred right to have any kind of code that acts against my interests. Please read the linked reply. It was a real issue, not an hypothetical. Installing software required by my bank REALLY screwed up my computer in the past, and I didn't really have a choice.
- echelon 6y agoTo copy the argument used by Apple supporters, you can choose another bank. > It's my computer, it's a developer's sacred right to have any kind of code that acts against my interests. Apple has created an exclusionary economic zone and put 50% of Americans in it. This is unprecedented. > Also, the fact I use a firewall doesn't excuse developers from being assholes and spying/tracking me behind my back. A sandbox will protect you from everything you claim to be worried about.
- nemothekid 6y ago>They've become their own banana republic. It's insane that you would compare selling a superior product on a largely free market, to a CIA-backed coup of a foreign independent nation. Can you please point to me to the people Apple murdered to capture their market? This is some incredible anti-Apple rhetoric. Meanwhile, in our currently implemented "open" platform you have engineers running amok with the personal data of millions of Americans.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- echelon 6y ago> incredible anti-Apple rhetoric And it's crazy you think that's wrong! Stop worshipping the device in your pocket and protect our industry! Apple is a foe. Living in their ecosystem is like living in a Communist dictatorship. Say or do the wrong thing and they take your app own to the gallows and kill it. Do. Not. Worship. This.
- zepto 6y agoDo you own an Apple device? Have you ever lived in a communist dictatorship or even visited one? I have
- echelon 6y ago> Do you own an Apple device? Yes. > Have you ever lived in a communist dictatorship or even visited one? Yes. I spent a year studying Chinese in Shanghai. My partner is from Vietnam. What's your point? I stand behind my analogy. Apple is a horrible company and is ruining our industry.
- zepto 6y agoWhy do you own an Apple device?
- 6y ago
- zepto 6y agoApple doesn’t impact anyone who doesn’t choose to be impacted. Nobody is forced to interact with them, either as a customer or a supplier.
- echelon 6y agoI've got a video streaming service. What the hell else am I going to do? I don't want to deal with Apple and their draconian rules. They translate to "you're small peanuts not worth our time" or "you're not paying us enough". Apple does not deserve to control all economic activity reaching 50% of Americans. Only the government gets to do that. Last I checked, Tim Cook is not in the Treasury department. This is the company that cares more about dollars than the lives of Belarusian protestors. I do not want to deal with these thugs. It's insulting, degrading, and costs people their livelihoods.
- zepto 6y agoApple doesn’t control ‘all economic activity reaching 50% of Americans’. You might change your view if you had correct facts. This is wrong on two counts. Firstly the amount of economic activity through the App Store is a tiny fraction of what you claim, and secondly Apple doesn’t control it because there are alternatives. There are many avenues for delivering your streaming service. You can deliver it via the desktop. You can deliver it via the web. You can sell cheap streaming boxes based on raspberry pi grade hardware. You can create a storefront on Android. You can deliver individual titles as apps through the App Store store. There are plenty of options.
- LionBlack8 6y agoWe've got Netflix, HBO, Amazon Prime, etc... All great with plenty of content, but if we want something where there is some older content, I use https://torrentsites.com/ https://torrentsites.com/
- Osiris 6y ago> If you need alternate stores - buy Android. And when Google decides to stop allowing that, then what? There's a duopoly and history suggests that when one can get away with rent seeking the other will follow. If we continue to allow this behavior now then we guarantee it'll continue on the future. This is exactly what happened with the 30%. Google did it because Apple had set the standard. They didn't do it because they did the math and came the exact same conclusion as Apple ina vacuum.
- zepto 6y agoIf Google decides to do that, then you might have an argument. Google has a great incentive not to do it, which is that if they do it there would be a real argument for software distribution. to be regulated by the government. But until they do, there isn’t.
- sooheon 6y agoCan you explain how this is an example of rent seeking? I can see how it is of profit seeking, but how is offering a product, services, and platform rent seeking?
- saagarjha 6y agoIt'd be rent seeking if Apple wasn't making the platform better for developers.
- zepto 6y agoWhich they obviously are. Some developers may disagree with Apple’s strategy, but it’s obvious that they are investing in technologies that support developers, and continue to reach more customers - which also makes the platform better for developers.
- RonanTheGrey 6y ago> I’m suggesting that consumers should buy a product that that suits their needs. It's cute you think this is why people buy things. Also, you're completely missing the point here. Developers have no choice but to developer for Apple and that means that whatever Apple says, Apple gets. That's called bullying, at the very least, and I'm not alone in asserting that it extends into behavior that should at least be regulated. Mind you, the only reason I think so is that their user base exceeds 1 billion users. There's a public interest in things when numbers are that big. If we were talking about some company with only a million users, the case would be much weaker.
- sooheon 6y ago> Developers have no choice but to developer for Apple and that means that whatever Apple says, Apple gets. Developers absolutely have a choice. They have one choice if they want access to Apple's customers.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoI think it's widely recognized that Sophie's Choice is not a choice.
- zepto 6y agoSure, but this has nothing to do with Nazi’s or concentration camps. This just has to do with wanting to sell your apps to more people from the developer side, or wishing Google would use better materials to make their phones from the user side. Let’s be honest here.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoIt has to do with needing, not wanting, access to a sufficiently large market to have even a remote chance of success. Can you imagine anyone who wanted to make an app now, without publishing on either the Google Play Store or the App Store "in protest"? That's the option you're giving them. "Ask for more gruel or fail" and you're calling that a choice. Lets be honest here, indeed. You know perfectly well what I meant and refused to touch the point.
- ethbr0 6y ago> people who want a curated store This is a straw man. Support allowing users to add alternate stores on iOS devices. Having one choice is not freedom. And it has nothing to do with curration. If Apple's model is superior, then their app store will win against fair competition.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s not a straw man. I don’t want my non-technical family members being persuaded to install other stores. It is absolutely a feature, and a beneficial one at that, which many people want. As for Apple allowing people to install other stores - why should they? Why not just buy an Android phone if you want that feature.
- hda2 6y ago> I don’t want my non-technical family members being persuaded to install other stores. Frankly, that's not your decision to make. If they own the device, they get to decide. If they don't or are too young, then you can use various controls (i.e parental controls) to lock your devices down the way you want. This is a straw man.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s absolutely my decision by to make if they ask me to recommend something to them. Especially if they have been having problems with malware and that’s why they are asking. If they own the device they get to use it as it was designed to be used. They also have the legal right to change it themselves (at least in the US). What you don’t have is any basis for forcing Apple to design software the way you want, or to force my family members not to be able to follow my recommendation to choose iOS as Apple wants to offer it to them. That’s between them and Apple and me. What right do have to dictate how any of these three parties choose to interact? There is no straw man.
- echelon 6y agoYou can't make that decision for me and millions of others. You're voting to make our industry inequitable and running software some Orwellian dystopia. I wouldn't be surprised if Apple one day mandated that we hand them the copyright to the code we write. We're one step away from that now: we already have to write against a strict spec, fit all the rules, and are subject to arbitrary dismissal. They take 30% and leave us the crumbs. The appeals process is unfair. If Apple likes what you've got, they can just clone your app. One step away. We're in prison and you're rationalizing about your parents.
- shard972 6y agoYou can't buy an apple product, you can only rent it. The recent development in rights to self repair makes this even clearer.