4 ms·
The easiest way to go about this would be to give up the requirement that votes are private. This would make the need for cryptography drop away completely, and
by mindslight 6y ago
The easiest way to go about this would be to give up the requirement that votes are private. This would make the need for cryptography drop away completely, and trusted third parties mostly. Individual voters could verify that their votes were counted correctly, and everyone could verify that eg dead people didn't vote.
I'm not saying this is a good policy, just a hard technical tradeoff of what would be required for verifiable voting without cryptography.
It's an all or nothing proposition too. A hybrid system (opt in to make your vote public so it can be publicly verified) would create additional vote pools that would differ based on ideological preferences and thereby attract calls to disenfranchise, as we've seen for mail in voting.
- arrosenberg 6y agoIt's a universally bad policy. Public votes mean those with money will purchase them, as they have the ability to validate their investment. We have examples of for the general electorate pre-1885 and in Congress post-Watergate.
- moritonal 6y agoIt worries me that you don't see how fundamentally that undermines the point of democracy. It's illegal to take a photo of your ballot to prove who you voted for, think about why. Because if you could then the local crime-ring would force every person they can intimidate to go vote for their boss and take a photo to prove it or the thugs will hurt their kids. Or maybe think about the pressure some people surrounded by family and friends of the opposite party feel. Sure they will wave the right coloured flag and throw dirt at the TV with their friends at the "wrong" guy, but when safe and sound in the voters box they can do what they like. Imagine if all your friends "opted" into revealing their vote and you didn't.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWow. I mean, I'm very sympathetic that people should get private votes, but your description of someone faking their opinion and throwing dirt makes me sort of hate the person in your example. Mark Twain comes to mind. What an interesting way to garner sympathy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- antepodius 6y agoMore of your friends than you think hide their true thoughts and opinions from you, because they (often correctly) expect social censure if they reveal them.
- moritonal 6y agoWhat about a mother who doesn't want her kids in the army to go to war but the whole house supports a war-monger? Or doctor who has a single opinion about a practice they want legalised, but doesn't want to admit it to anyone. A gay teen surrounded by homophobic people who wants to legalise their sexuality but has to fake it and shout at rallies because otherwise people might question what's up. Those weren't hard to come up with...
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhat about them? Their valid reasons do not make their actions palatable.
- lsb 6y agoIt's legal in lots of places https://www.vox.com/21523858/ballot-selfies-state-rules https://www.vox.com/21523858/ballot-selfies-state-rules
- moritonal 6y agoNeat, and in the same article it talks about how it's a bad thing due to voter intimidation, with examples of it happening.
- yandie 6y agoBut then social pressure might overwhelm individual choices. It's gonna be harder for people to disagree with the mass, because they then can be punished easily. Given how our current society operates, I can't see this work anywhere at all.
- eyeball 6y agoSeems like a bad idea when political leaders are calling for compiling enemies lists and punishing opposition supporters. https://nypost.com/2020/11/06/aoc-facing-heat-for-wanting-to-archive-posts-by-trump-sycophants/ https://nypost.com/2020/11/06/aoc-facing-heat-for-wanting-to...
- opheliate 6y agoHey, could you point me to where the political leader you're referring to has actually called for punishing opposition supporters? The tweets she actually wrote only explicitly ask for archiving things people have posted publicly, not for punishing anyone. It's obviously possible to read what she wrote as a plan to compile a list of enemies for future consequences, but just to give an alternate perspective, I read what was said as a simple call for accountability of public figures (i.e: politicians within the Republican party who have supported Trump, but now are disavowing him), rather than being intended as some sort of mass-surveillance programme targetted at anyone who disagreed with her.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoOf course they can’t do that; they’re deliberately misrepresenting a statement in order to stir up more of this nonsense.
- eyeball 6y ago>It's obviously possible to read what she wrote as a plan to compile a list of enemies for future consequences Yes, yes it is. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/washington-secrets/first-aocs-list-now-cnn-warns-of-blacklisting-trump-team https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/washington-secrets/first-...
- opheliate 6y agoThis doesn't provide any more evidence for AOC having called for punishing opposition supporters, does it? Tapper doesn't appear to be directing employers to do anything here: he's stating how employers judge candidates, and noting how considering one's actions in that frame might cause one to act differently. There's not a threat here, it's an acknowledgement of how society works. My point is that these aren't reasonable interpretations of what these figures have said. Like I said, it's certainly possible to read into their words as much as you want, but it requires far fewer assumptions about the unknowable mental states of others to simply take their words at face value. Divorced of the spin placed onto what's been said by the press, these statements are entirely innocuous.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ericbarrett 6y agoI think public voting is untenable due to the massively increased risk of voter intimidation[0]. Any voting process that requires it is going to be a non-starter unless you can change human behavior. [0] A recent example: https://news.yahoo.com/mystery-blue-dots-painted-near-225645157.html https://news.yahoo.com/mystery-blue-dots-painted-near-225645...