7 ms·
How active noise cancellation for automotive works
- penneyd 6y agoVery impressive
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mellosouls 6y agoActual title of this marketing piece with no actual detailed technical information on "How active noise cancellation for automotive works": Advanced, broad-band active noise cancellation now available in cars
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI think I just found my next RPi project. Our sprinter van is great and the thinsulate insulation I added cut down on noise a lot, but the road and wind noise on long 70mph multi-day trips gets a bit much. [ EDIT: it seems that the cancellation signal plays out of the same speakers used for in-car audio. I wonder what implications that has ]
- vosper 6y agoI’m not sure if thinsulate is the same thing, but you might also want to look at Mass Loaded Vinyl with a closed-cell foam underlay (can be bought together as one sheet). It took me quite some reading up on road noise to realise that MLV, and not the butyl/Dynamat kind of sound deadener, is the key to reducing road noise, and is what luxury car manufacturers use. I’m planning to do the floor of my RAV4 in the next few weeks. never taken the seats out of a car before, should be interesting.
- the_pwner224 6y agoI just did a bunch of research for this on a new car I'm getting. From what I was able to learn, the CCF and MLV block road & tire noise, but the butyl sound deadener products are still important to stop the sheet metal from vibrating and to stop resonance in the door cavity & trunk. 25-50% coverage with butyl directly on the sheet metal is enough, since it doesn't block sound, just absorbs vibrations. If you tap your doors or trunk lid, or if you swing the door shut, the sheet metal will have a tinny hollow sound, but after butyl all of those become more of a solid 'thunk.' Overall, the butyl stops the sheet metal from making its own noise and from amplifying the tire vibrations; then the entire surface needs to get 100% unbroken coverage of the CCF/MLV to block all types of noise from entering. Demonstration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ur_Rhi5js8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ur_Rhi5js8
- vosper 6y agoI think the affect of the butyl dampener on actual internal vehicle noise is minimal. I've done that part, and my doors close thunkily now (not that I ever cared) but the car is just as loud as ever inside. I think that unless you're going for high-performance audio, there's really not a whole lot of value in the sound deadener. > 25-50% coverage with butyl directly on the sheet metal is enough This is true, you see in a lot of the professional installer videos that they will cover the whole surface in the deadener, but it's not necessary.
- robocat 6y agoReasonable MLV article (advert but OK): https://www.secondskinaudio.com/sound-blocking/ https://www.secondskinaudio.com/sound-blocking/ And another article aimed at home usage: https://www.snoringsource.com/mass-loaded-vinyl-alternatives/ https://www.snoringsource.com/mass-loaded-vinyl-alternatives...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoSorry for the delay in responding ... been on the road in our van :) MLV is an entirely different material and is used for an entirely different purpose than thinsulate. It is not useful for stopping road/wind noise, but does help to dampen vibrations and resonance in the metal body of a vehicle. It is a dampener, and will not cut down much on the type of noise we have left in our vehicle. MLV has a problem when used for automotive uses. To be maximally effect, it requires an air gap on both sides and must not be rigidly mounted. Apply MLV to the surface of a vehicle body will do approximately zero for noise. MLV is widely used for sound reduction in buildings, where it is much easier to mount it in ways that allow it to significantly dampen sound transmission. High end cars use thinsulate as well as dampeners. Most Mercedes and Lexus' (at least) are lined to the gills with automative thinsulate, along with dampeners applied in critical locations.
- kev009 6y agoThe RAM heavy duty pickups have a system like this, where it's a lot harder to prevent or cut down noise of a big diesel engine, HD transmission, tcase, and tires. It really works well in practice.
- jeffbee 6y agoMeanwhile those of us not inside the vehicle get to enjoy the full force of these irritating sounds.
- joshfraser 6y agoI've been waiting to see active noise-canceling technology applied to more than just headphones. Imagine living next to a busy highway, near an airport, or above a bar, and being able to dampen the noise through an array of active noise canceling devices.
- kilburn 6y agoThat is a much harder problem. Your headphones can record and generate cancelling noise because they don't move relative to your ear (and are so close that they receive the same noise that has to be cancelled). Once you are moving out and about around a room, a system such as this one would have to account for all the sounds coming in from all different directions, then track your position to figure out how all those will be reaching you, have a good model of how sounds bounce in your space and finally beam the cancelling sound straight to you (because cancelling noise is still noise, and if it starts bouncing around it will worsen the problem instead of helping it). That's why the best you can hope for (today and for many years to come) is just soundproofing. We can do amazing things already in this front.
- patrickk 6y agoIt would be amazing if even if we’re possible for a bedroom. The positions of the occupants are predictable. Cancelling out road vehicles, trains, planes (loud drunken voices?) would be a huge boost to countless people across the world.
- jwr 6y agoThe test movie looks/sounds impressive until you notice "with headphones" in the corner. I can get noise cancellation with headphones today, and it's very good.
- Closi 6y agoI think this means "wear headphones while watching this video to get the full experience of what it is actually like"
- S_A_P 6y agoOne thing to keep in mind is that you may not be able to modify the car stereo in the vehicle with this technology.(without some other help) My Jeep has this technology, and I added a more powerful subwoofer which resulted in a random intervals of 50-60hz coming out of the sub to cancel out the engine noise. It drove me nuts until I found a PAC audio interface that would give me a clean signal and bypassed the ANR.
- vosper 6y agoWhat's your opinion of the ANR system in your Jeep? Was it effective?
- S_A_P 6y agoI think the main intent was to reduce the volume of the cylinder deactivation cycle(it does drone a bit in 4 cyl mode) but it rarely activates that mode unless I put it in "Eco mode". I would use that if it didnt also remap the throttle response to be so lazy. It adds what feels a few seconds latency to the pedal response. I can say without a doubt that having bypassed it completely has had little to no audible effect. My Jeep came from the factory with a loud exhaust(is a Grand Cherokee SRT- so no off road intent in this vehicle) and I kind of like the way it sounds(though it isnt really that loud tbh)
- bfieidhbrjr 6y ago> it does drone a bit in 4 cyl mode sounds like a 4-banger subaru outback...?
- transistor-man 6y agoInteresting! Just curious, what model jeep has this as an option? Would be interesting to see how retrofit-able this is into older, very noisy Jeeps.
- S_A_P 6y agoIve a Grand Cherokee SRT- I suspect it would likely be a hard problem, and may require a somewhat sizable car audio system (If you were referring to something like a CJ-7 or the like)
- pastrami_panda 6y agoI've been an avid ANC headphone user for some 6 years or so. The current gen ANC is remarkably good. The issue I had with previous generations was that a carrier wave (for lack for better word) was always audible, which admittedly wasn't as bad as the noise it was cancelling, but it could be annoying for home use when you just wanted to cancel the fridge, AC or similar room tone humming. With current gen ANC from the good brands this sound is very quiet, in some cases bordering on inaudible. Stuff just goes quiet. It's very impressive.
- datlife 6y agoThanks for your comment. I am shopping for a new ANC headphone lately. May I ask what headphone you are using?
- KptMarchewa 6y agoNot OP, but new Sony WH-1000XM4 are amazing.
- IndrekR 6y agoUsing Sony WH-1000XM3 myself. RTings has tested most ANC headphones on the market and published their measurement (not gut feeling) results: https://www.rtings.com/headphones/tests/isolation/noise-isolation-cancellation-passive-active https://www.rtings.com/headphones/tests/isolation/noise-isol... Probably would get Sony WH-1000XM4 myself this time (they pause automatically when taken off). Have not personally used Bose ones since QC35, but some people like QC35 II better for long term use. Also Sony XM3 microphone is not very good for phone calls. I have heard XM4 has fixed this, but can not confirm.
- JosephRedfern 6y agoI love my WH-1000XM3s and was probably responsible for at least 3 of my friends getting pairs... but yes, agreed, the call quality is pretty poor. Fantastic noise cancelling headphones, though.
- jsinai 6y ago
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoHow can this possibly work and not also disrupt the music you’re trying to listen to. Can’t wait to go deaf when this malfunctions and instead doubles the volume of all the audio in the cabin in a way that can’t be avoided for the remainder of the lifetime of the car because your mindless enthusiasm for new garbage for the sake of new garbage resulted in this cancer being installed in 100% of all new cars with no way to disable it and the diversity hires at the dealership pretend not to notice the problem when you bring it in. Fuck you retards, you ruin everything.
- some1else 6y agoIs this really a good idea in traffic?
- filoleg 6y agoDoesn't seem bad, because ANC doesn't cancel out sharp sudden noises, it only cancels out repetitive semi-constant noises (like AC or engine sound). So all the essential sounds on the road, like sirens or horns or impact or sudden tire burn, will be heard perfectly fine, while all the annoying constant noises (like the road or engine) will go away. Try it next time with ANC headphones: ask someone to play a siren sound on speakers. I can guarantee that you won't hear the siren any less than usual. In fact, you will hear it better, because it won't be overlapping with all the other random background noises. Similar, but to a lesser degree, with speech. I was able to have full-on conversations with people while wearing headphones with ANC turned on (in the office), zero issues. Which is kind of a scenario that ANC cannot currently handle when it comes to using them in an office, since it won't cancel out the sound of someone randomly kicking their desk or slamming something on it.
- gnicholas 6y agoIn the youtube videos on the page, it shows a big microphone mounted next to the passenger's left ear. My first question is: is this for measuring the sound waves for the purpose of the video, or is it part of their ANC system? If it is part of their system, how much worse does the system perform with a less well-placed and conspicuous mic?
- Reason077 6y agoI'm pretty sure the mic is part of the test/measurement rig, not part of the ANC system itself.
- rtb 6y ago> The pressure waves from both the unwanted exterior noise and manufactured anti-noise reach occupants’ eardrums at exactly the same time and cancel each other out. What happens if your ears are not exactly where the system thinks they should be? If you are taller or shorter than they expect? If you are not sitting in the drivers seat? If you lean over? My guess would be that the system makes things worse more often than it makes things better, if it relies on your ears being in the correct position. The wavelength of middle C is something like 2 feet, so if your ears move by 1 foot will you be getting double noise, rather than zero noise?
- sokoloff 6y agoNote: The wavelength of C4 is ~1.3 meters or about 4 feet 3 inches. C5 is half of that, or around 2 feet.
- Reason077 6y agoI could really use this technology in my bedroom, to cancel out the hum from a noisy rooftop ventilation fan.
- vermilingua 6y agoSomething I’ve always wondered about ANC and never been able to find an answer to. I have Airpods Pro, with ANC, and since iOS 14 my phone displays a safe heating indicator with the dB hitting my ears from the pods. This level does not change when ANC is activated, but intuitively I’d assumed that it produces extra noise. Does ANC actually cause destructive interference, meaning no noise is in fact reaching my ears?
- resoluteteeth 6y agoYes, destructive interference is the whole point of ANC.
- closeparen 6y agoANC interferes destructively with what was happening some milliseconds ago. If the noise is irregular (like speech) the ANC signal will “miss” and become net new sound.
- renewiltord 6y agoWoah, the video is the first time I learned that Volvo was bought by that Chinese car company Geely (who also make the Lynk & Co car used in the test).
- x87678r 6y agoAlso note a lot of luxury performance cars have the opposite - the engine noise is amplified by the stereo system. It makes sense as sounds is so dampened now but you want to hear that sweet engine note when you hit the gas.
- hammock 6y agoFord Mustang does this too, except it's not amplification of the engine, it's actually pre-recordings of engine noise pumped into the sound system when you step on the gas.
- p1necone 6y agoThis seems so... American.
- CamperBob2 6y agoYou'd think so, but BMW did it first, as far as I'm aware. Anyone know of an earlier system?
- detaro 6y agoVW also did it quite early in the Golf GTI, but I think that is around the same time (2011?), although not with recordings but actual engine noise, or so they claimed.
- p1necone 6y agoYou could argue that being able to hear the actual engine noise more clearly does have some practical benefits especially with a manual transmission, although only really if you're driving it around a track (or if it would be totally silent inside otherwise).
- raxxorrax 6y agoI know the E-Golf does generate sound to warn pedestrians. Most modern upper class cars have noise cancelation by now. It is ridiculously silent in some of them.
- vr46 6y agoThis spells good news for electric cars, which seem to have far less sound-deadening material, and indeed far less of any material in the cockpit in order to keep a low weight. I’ve been in two Teslas and the noise is awful compared to my 14-year old Audi, which is a delight over long distances. This could really be a game-changer for those of us who covet comfort. That said, cars are probably not the future here in the EU, but still. If I want to enjoy engine noise, there’s motorbikes.
- kylegordon 6y agoI've only ever test driven a Model S, and seen multiple Youtube videos (usually of owners showing off a new barely contained beta feature), and that explains all the road noise. I thought it was just my imagination, or the awareness of other noise given the lack of drivetrain noise. My 7 year old Volvo S60 seems quieter than the Tesla at speed, and it's a diesel. I'll keep daily driving my classic cars. Who needs a music system when you have them :-)
- userbinator 6y agoI wonder how many others easily get motion sickness in a car or other vehicle with a lot of noise dampening and otherwise "isolation" from the outside. I've been in some of these newer cars and rolling down a window, thus increasing the sense of noise, was one way to avoid it. On the other hand, I didn't experience the same in cars far noisier and with less dampening.
- chris_st 6y agoJust curious whether using noise-cancelling headphones gives you the same reaction? Or would you only notice it if you were moving?
- userbinator 6y agoOr would you only notice it if you were moving? Exactly. Noise-cancelling on its own doesn't provoke the same feeling of nausea, since I'm not moving.
- anchpop 6y agoI often use my airpods pro while driving with ANC turned on and get absolutely no nausea. Since they cancel predictable noise, I also feel my driving is actually safer (a noise like a siren would sound relatively louder than before).
- spyder 6y agoHmm... The second demonstration video at the bottom of the page seems misleading, because to show how it works with music they didn't show the actual recording with music playing in the car, they're just putting music on top of the recorded noise in post-editing.