4 ms·
Of course the law isn't ridiculous at face value, it's extending it to corner cases without looking at intent that can be. That's the point, the same thing is t
by zamadatix 6y ago
Of course the law isn't ridiculous at face value, it's extending it to corner cases without looking at intent that can be. That's the point, the same thing is true of any law. It's impossible to cover all corner cases, at some point you need intent when you try to take it too far from what it was written to cover.
- Dylan16807 6y agoYes, that's your point. But you're arguing a different point than treve. Treve was saying that anything becomes ridiculous when inspected closely enough. Even the core components. You are saying that the extension to corner cases becomes ridiculous. The extension can be ridiculous without the original core being ridiculous. So you're saying a correct thing, but it's not relevant to the conversation that existed before your comment.
- zamadatix 6y agoI understand what you're trying to say but "core components" and "corner cases" are part of the same concept. You can't say "I have concept <x> which is made of core components <y> and corner cases <z>" in one breath and then in the next say "<x> is unambiguous without looking at <z>" and unless you have a concept that depends on nothing else for it's construction this applies recursively as well. E.g. "murder is always illegal" is not true and a bad law/take on the concept. Expanding the law to include "murder is always illegal except when... <other laws>" is only unambiguous if <other laws> are unambiguous. I don't think I need to take it further to explain justifiable homicide isn't unambiguously black and white or always possible to rule on without looking at intent of the various laws and what happened. Bringing that back to the original thing this is true of any concept or law, including reviewing some remote apps and not others based on what they are for not that they are remote. I'm not saying I agree the way Apple regulates these is good I'm just saying I agree the fact some remote apps are regulated and others aren't isn't proof alone the regulation is contradictory.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> I understand what you're trying to say but "core components" and "corner cases" are part of the same concept. Sure! And if you look at the overall concept, it does not become meaningless. To get to meaninglessness requires you separate the two. "Unambiguous" is a much much higher bar that we don't need to worry about. Something can be 5% ambiguous but still very meaningful. > Bringing that back to the original thing this is true of any concept or law, including reviewing some remote apps and not others based on what they are for not that they are remote. I'm not saying I agree the way Apple regulates these is good I'm just saying I agree the fact some remote apps are regulated and others aren't isn't proof alone the regulation is contradictory. It's not proof by itself, but if you can show that there's no good reason for the distinction then it's a strong mark against Apple.