8 ms·
Just more evidence that large platform and device owners will try to gate-keep and landgrab as much as they can and try to destroy the open web and force compet
by Barrin92 6y ago
Just more evidence that large platform and device owners will try to gate-keep and landgrab as much as they can and try to destroy the open web and force competitors into financial agreements to collect economic rent.
There finally needs to be regulation on this. No banning of end user services as long as they're legal, I don't want a phone maker controlling what I do on the internet. It's ridiculous. Microsoft in the 90s doesn't even compare to this, it's on an entirely different level. If competition regulation would actually still exist we'd tear apple a new one.
- jMyles 6y ago> There finally needs to be regulation on this. No banning of end user services as long as they're legal I was with you up until this moment. Doesn't this just shift the power to a less accountable authority in the state? What about content that isn't legal but which is, you know, not child abuse or similar? Does that deserve a platform also? I think that being able to view content on a phone regardless of its approval by the state is essential to a free society. And, as always, the question is: legal where? Healthier is for people to find and enact workarounds to this censorship, and to cause Apple to be unable to profitably proceed.
- danielheath 6y agoThe state already bans illegal content. The question is whether we also want a second party banning it.
- jMyles 6y agoIt seems to me that society desperately needs parties working to subvert such bans. Requiring that private companies instead actively participate in it seems like exactly the opposite.
- HashThis 6y agoApple is a crony capitalist company looking to collect rents from other people's work. We need to aggressively call out Apple for being a crony capitalist company rigging the economy. Crony capitalist companies break competition to rig the economy. That is what Apple is doing by working to collect rents from other people's work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- avalys 6y agoThat’s rich. One might argue that the guy arguing the government should force Apple to let him sell his service through the platform Apple invented, built and operates is the crony capitalist.
- echelon 6y agoIt's time for the DOJ to break up Apple. Together with Google, they're destroying the Internet and open computing. Soon, it'll be all information that is locked down and controlled. Computers didn't use to be like this. Apple has land grabbed their way here and is now clamping down harder than ever before. If we don't revolt, we're going to wind up in a terrible place where Apple and Google make all the movies and games and we rent everything and own nothing. Call your representative and ask them to put an end to this. Demand open computing. You own the computer, you get to run whatever software you want. (Side note: iPhones are the only computers a large segment of Americans own!)
- judge2020 6y agoBreak up how? Apple's main argument against Epic is that the iPhone (and related devices) wouldn't be successful without the app store and the app store wouldn't be a thing without the iPhone, thus they're both a part of the same product (the Apple ecosystem). It's hard to argue against that, so there's not many more places where it would make sense for an Apple break-up.
- dice1-6 6y agoApple could be forced to allow alternative stores and browsers. They get money for iPhone there is really no reason for restrict the store. So phone and app store could be naturally cut like for android ecosystem.
- enos_feedler 6y agoI still don't understand what enabling multiple browsers, from an engine standpoint, would achieve. Is it competition? Don't all browsers just implement the same set of standards? What is the lack of competition holding back?
- jtbayly 6y agoTrue PWA's, for example, including push notifications.
- sneak 6y agoWhy do you think regulation (forcing Apple to compromise their editorial decisions) the answer? Nobody is forced into buying an iPhone. Customers willingly opt-in to these platforms.
- manigandham 6y agoDo you support any regulations for corporations? If so, what's the difference? Why should trillion-dollar megacorps that run our lives with little competition or escape be allowed such freedom?
- icebraining 6y agoI think there's a difference between regulations controlling externalities, or protecting the dispossessed, and protecting people from phones that don't have certain games. Do you not?
- manigandham 6y agoNo, because the regulation isn't protecting people from phones that don't have certain games. That would be silly. Allowing over a billion users the freedom to install and use software on their smartphone (a critical computing device and the only one for many) without corporate approval can indeed control externalities, protect the dispossessed and even save lives.
- Zanni 6y agoWhy shouldn't they? The burden to demonstrate a compelling argument should always be on those who want to restrict freedom, not on those who want to enjoy (or retain) freedom.
- manigandham 6y agoWe're talking about restricting the freedom of a corporation to increase the freedom of people. So, as you stated, why should the status quo exist and restrict the freedom of consumers?
- superkuh 6y agoI am not being glib when I say: just don't use Apple. Yes, what they do is bad. But it isn't force. It isn't coercion. It's people coming to them and wanting to use their services. Just don't use their services. Just because you feel powerless in making individual choices doesn't mean advocating for the use of force against the company is moral.
- Pfhreak 6y agoIndividual action can be important. Regulation is also a valuable tool. When we discover behaviors that are dangerous, regulating them is absolutely reasonable and moral.
- SllX 6y agoNah, most of the regulations that people want is just reactionary BS to something or another, in this case, Apple is keeping a certain class of toys out of the App Store. I mean, that's not to say it isn't scummy, but scummy to the level that it ought to be illegal and Apple should be treated like I dunno, PG&E or Old Ma Bell? Not even close.
- dralley 6y agoA duopoly is not meaningfully better than a monopoly if both participants are doing equally amoral things.
- superkuh 6y agoI chose not to use a smart phone for this reason (among many others).
- ShroudedNight 6y agoBundling absolutely is coercion. Apple makes some of, if not the best mobile hardware in the world. It would definitely be reasonable to purchase Apple hardware and run third-party software on it, just like on Macintosh. It would also be reasonable to run iOS on alternative hardware. Neither of those scenarios is possible today because Apple uses the compelling nature of individual aspects to force consumers to accept the entirety of their ecosystem.
- SllX 6y agoI look at it like this, without a horse in this race: some enterprising mofos are trying to create additional value for Apple's platforms, pay Apple's fees if they have to (or at least Microsoft was willing to, from what I hear they didn't expect to be shot down entirely), and Apple is saying no. No. I mean what they're offering, at least in theory, is pretty neat, pretty compelling. Play Xbox Series whatever games, but on your iPhone or iPad. Apple just says No. Well, if Apple wants to reject the value that these enterprising mofos is trying to bring to their platforms, who is the government to tell them that they can't shoot themselves in the foot? If it causes a few people to switch to Android such as Mike over at Penny Arcade, and maybe discover that they don't need an Apple-branded phone after all, that's Apple's loss. There's been no shortage of compelling Apps and services to be had in the App Store, no shortage of money to be made there if you have something that people 1. want and 2. are willing to pay for. Companies like Uber, Lyft, Doordash, Facebook, even Google have been making bank in the last 10 years off the back of iPhone users, built up a good portion of their business around iPhone and iPad users. Apple can keep the good times flowing through their platform, tighten up on the squeeze and get out of their own way, or they can lose out on opportunities that are literally sitting right in front of them, practically begging for Apple to pick them. The people that care, that really care, are either going to switch to Android, or purchase an extra device just for this, or iPhone users are going to not give that much of a damn and just live life as they always have: without being able to stream games. Life is tough like that. Markets always sort crap like this out in the long run though. Give it a few years, we'll come back to this and see if it actually matters.
- enos_feedler 6y agoI am not so sure Android's policy won't evolve to better match what Apple does. At the end of the day both of these platforms serve to defend their core ecosystems. It is clear that the app /container concept is the one thing Apple holds dearly. Streaming services represent a leak/wedge into another app/container ecosystem. That alternative ecosystem has its own business models, review process, developer relationship, etc). It will never fly in it's current form, for any of these streamers (geforce now, stadia, xbox, etc). I don't think we are stuck though. Both major mobiles would love to have a way to make this work from both a product and business standpoint. The platform just needs to evolve to support them properly and we aren't there yet. For Apple, I could see a path where upon pairing your existing Xbox console with Apple, it unlocks an Xbox branded app store across your devices. Apple would be fed meta-data for that entire store so they would have some levers of control over the experience. The key thing here would be no onboarding flow to the xbox store. You are a clear xbox platform user and you want to extend that experience onto your Apple devices through a pairing flow originating on your purchased xbox. Same could work for any hardware console.
- otterley 6y agoDestroying the open web? What are you talking about? Apple has a fantastic track record of making Safari a world class web browser for iOS. If Microsoft, Google, and others made these gaming offerings web apps, they’d likely work just fine.
- hu3 6y ago> Apple has a fantastic track record of making Safari a world class web browser From a quick glance it looks behind Firefox and Chrome on HTML/CSS/JS feature support. https://caniuse.com/?compare=firefox+84,chrome+89,safari+14&compareCats=all https://caniuse.com/?compare=firefox+84,chrome+89,safari+14&... And then there's Safari's broken autocomplete: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23646158 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23646158
- ewindal 6y agoThat’s literally only because Amazon worked with them to introduce the needed features so they could launch Luna. Controller support was shoddy before iOS14, for example, so the web app approach wasn’t viable for xCloud or Stadia.
- Anon1096 6y agoI'm not sure how iOS can be considered a bastion for the web when it doesn't even have WebM support, which has been used across the web for years.
- otterley 6y agoAnd yet video streaming in Safari seems to work fine for users, and better still, it leverages the native hardware decoding capabilities to minimize battery usage.
- hu3 6y agoWebM is widespread, royalty free media format that's hardware accelerated with zero cost license. The reason non-WebM stream services might work on Safari is because said service engineers implemented alternatives to it.
- d3nj4l 6y ago> to destroy the open web Except this rule doesn't prohibit anybody from putting anything on the internet. TFA is only about putting a streaming service on the App Store. Not to say that's not problematic, but Apple's not holding the web back in any way with this rule.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> Apple's not holding the web back in any way with this rule. Yeah, not with this rule. They are holding the web back by refusing to run 3rd party browsers or modernize their one.
- actuator 6y agoThey are. MS could have shipped their browser with features that can support game streaming but they can't. Open Web on mobile is being held hostage on iOS side. At least on Android I was asked to choose my default browser and other browsers are allowed to have their engines.
- mjgs 6y agoIn many ways I echo your sentiment. One thing I can’t stop thinking about though is how utterly hopeless we are at creating good regulations. The regulations seem to have good intentions but end up doing more harm than good, often ending up giving even more of an advantage to the big tech companies. Look at GDPR, it’s resulted in a tidal wave of horrible pop ups across the entire web that create the worst user experience ever. Apple probably loves this, it makes their Apple News product look amazing because in comparison it’s so slick and smooth, but it’s not at all web-like since you can’t link to articles. So the open web takes a massive hit. Same with content filters, only the big guys can afford to have them, so they gain a massive advantage. There doesn’t appear to be a way to make good regulation, so why bother at all?
- GarrisonPrime 6y agoPretty good regulation already in place. Don't like it? Don't buy it.
- dwighttk 6y agoIf you’re pro open-web, don’t you want these game streaming services to operate on the open web, i.e. in the browser, i.e. can’t be gate-kept by Apple (or Google)?
- aabbcc1241 6y agoYet some people still choose to use iPhone (as if it's their most reasonable choice)