14 ms·
There’s a simple consistent principle in operation. If an app is simply a neutral front end to a distributed set of independent back end services that are not m
by simonh 6y ago
There’s a simple consistent principle in operation. If an app is simply a neutral front end to a distributed set of independent back end services that are not managed by the owner of the app, then the app owner is not responsible for the content. Web browsers clearly match this description as the browser developer isn’t responsible for all the web sites you could visit. But it also applies to email clients, Mastodon clients, arguably even podcast clients and many more.
If the client app is only used to access content also owned, curated or managed by the client app vendor, then the client app vendor is on the hook for that content. Audible falls in this category, even though it’s superficially similar to a podcast app, because the app client vendor also owns or curates all the content. Sure there are some odd edge cases, but games streaming services pretty clearly fall into this category, and not the same category as web browsers.
- simion314 6y agoSo what if somehow you implement the gaming service to work inside a browser? What is your opinion?
- the_other 6y agoI’d use a browser.
- musicale 6y ago> So what if somehow you implement the gaming service to work inside a browser? What is your opinion? You mean like Amazon's Luna game streaming service, which will run in Safari as Apple worked with them to provide the necessary support in webkit?
- bilbo0s 6y agoThe owner of the gaming service is still curating the content available through that service. It's not like simply running the service through the browser allows any and every game to be on the service. Game devs for instance, would still need to negotiate with the owners of the game service in order to have their game available on the service. Might even need to pay the game service?
- simion314 6y agoSo why should Apple allow a web browser based service but block the same one (XBOX) if it uses a native application? let's be honest, Apple dopes it for money not for users, blocking XBOX will not protect anyone , Apple wants a big cut or even better they want to sell their own gaming service in future.
- simonh 6y agoThe Amazon service won’t appear in the App Store and won’t be sold by Apple. With the Microsoft client it would be sold by Apple in the App Store. If Apple sells you something they want a degree of say in what gets sold. Yes of course this is about money.
- Dylan16807 6y agoThat could be a principle, but they've mucked around with Mastodon and podcast clients that such a rule would say are fine.
- simonh 6y agoAnd all of those issues were resolved, because they complied with the App Store rules which implement these principles.
- wilde 6y agoA closer analogy would be “what’s next? Apple approving all movies in Netflix?” The simple and consistent principle Apple applies is “how much negotiating leverage does this app developer have?”
- simonh 6y agoIf Netflix started putting porn in their portfolio, how long do you think their app would stay in the store?
- rStar 6y ago“There’s a simple consistent principle in operation:” protect our monopoly power over gaming on IOS via the app store by any means necessary.