4 ms·
The polls showed that Biden would win Florida by 2.2%, and in fact he lost by 3.3%. Is 5% within the normal error margin? There is no reason that polls would b
by tsimionescu 6y ago
The polls showed that Biden would win Florida by 2.2%, and in fact he lost by 3.3%. Is 5% within the normal error margin?
There is no reason that polls would be significantly different from the final vote results in most circumstances, if they are competently run.
https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/florida/ https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/florida/
- srtjstjsj 6y agoWhat does "competent" mean if none is competent? Are engineers incompetent because they can't put a person on Mars?
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, if some engineers told you "we are putting this person on Mars with a 99.9 probability", and the rocket in fact reaches Venus, the engineers are incompetent. Also, polling in most European countries doesn't go this far wrong, on almost all polls. So it's not like "accurate polling is impossible", it's just the polls in the US that seem to have some problem (though there have been some spectacular failures in other countries as well, which itself may lead to some thoughts on the value of polls in general).
- evgen 6y ago> polling in most European countries doesn't go this far wrong, on almost all polls. Brexit and UK elections would like to have a word with you... Polling everywhere sucks. Pick a country and chances are it either has no polling to speak of or else it has the same problems.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoYouGov are pretty good, mostly because they grew up in the Internet Age. But I agree with your general point.
- gpm 6y ago> There is no reason that polls would be significantly different from the final vote results in most circumstances, if they are competently run. There is lots of reason. If you could wave your magic wand and get a representative sample of voters in your poll you would be right, but you can't. Instead you do something like call people on a telephone, get a sample of people who both answer the telephone and who give answers you think indicate they are likely to vote. That sample isn't going to be at all representative of the voting population, so you take your best guess at what the actual voting population looks like, and how representative each of the people in your sample is of the voting population, and weight it accordingly. Your best guess at the actual voting population is probably wrong. Your best guess at how representative each person in your sample is of the actual voting population is wrong. Your doing things like assuming that every <race> person with <education level> votes similarly regardless of whether or not they answer the telephone and respond to pollsters because you really just don't have a better option.
- jonhohle 6y agoThen why are they repeated ad nauseam? Polling is hard and the result are likely non-representative. Great! Then don’t display them to the public and have pollsters in interviews acting as if their insight is in any way valuable to most people. They’re either incompetently wrong or, worse, intentionally manipulative. Just because something exists doesn’t mean it has value in the wrong context.
- gpm 6y agoJust because something isn't perfect doesn't mean it has no value. Polls communicate experts best guess at how the vote is going to turn out based on the data they have collected. It's likely to be a lot more accurate than a non-experts guess, or even the guess of an expert without any data. It's also not even possible to share the raw data because of privacy concerns. The forecasts you see on sites like 538 and the economist are even better, because it doesn't just communicate experts best guess (democrats win by +7), but experts best guess at how accurate that guess is too (something like democrats win by +7 +- 6, except in a lot more detail and nuance). On HN the catchphrase for this is basically "don't let perfect be the enemy of good". Note: I made up the numbers in this post.
- evgen 6y agoYou obviously have no understanding of either polling or statistics. This is like saying that if computer programmers were not incompetent we would not have bugs in programs, but since they all obviously do not know what they are doing we have a modern society held together with chewing gum and string because programmers are too dumb to get it right.
- onei 6y agoI think it's clear that people being polled are not representative of those who are voting. Trump has eother managed to appeal to people resistant to being polled or has managed to disengage people that are being polled. Whatever your views on the man, it's remarkable. What's more surprising to me is that he can do it consistently and that no one has seemingly appealed to these people before. Given that these are almost election winning demographics, it's odd that no one has spent more time on understanding these people.
- ummonk 6y agoIt's not within the normal margin of how off polling averages tend to be. (Though every once in a while you'll get an abnormal miss) But it is definitely within the margin of error for many individual polls, which often have a MoE > 2.5%.