3 ms·
What's the political statement made by wearing a poppy? Did Whole Foods make a political statement when they enacted the poppy ban?
by criddell 6y ago
What's the political statement made by wearing a poppy? Did Whole Foods make a political statement when they enacted the poppy ban?
- maxk42 6y agoIt's not political. It's done to remember those who died in combat. Many people have a relative or loved one who died in combat.
- robertfw 6y agoI would argue that focusing solely on the nobility of those who died in combat while ignoring what led to them being forced into combat in the first place, is political. I think the poppy, and Remembrance Day in general, spends far too little time examining _why_ these people were sent to die.
- bigbubba 6y agoSounds like you're saying it's political for being insufficiently political.
- Spivak 6y agoI’m not about to wade into Canadian culture because I know just enough to be very wrong so I hope it’s fine to use a US parallel. If Memorial Day was “celebrate the individual personal lives and accomplishments of all these people who died at war” then it’s apolitical. But that isn’t really how it goes unfortunately — I wish it did. Instead it’s about celebrating and glorifying our troops and our military which is super political.
- goatinaboat 6y agoInstead it’s about celebrating and glorifying our troops and our military which is super political. How is it political - what party do you think it supports?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> How is it political - what party do you think it supports? Partisan != political. (Though everything is in my opinion political.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 6y agoI think the general cultural consensus is WWI is the fault of Europe's leaders, particularly but not completely that of Germany. And was characterized by a callous disregard for soldiers lives on all sides.
- vkou 6y agoThat's not the impression I get from the Canadian Remembrance day posts I see on Facebook ever year. Without fail, all of them describe WWI as a stalwart selfless sacrifice for freedom and the motherland. Then I ask 'exactly what freedoms were at risk', and the authors of those posts start hemming and hawing and tut-tutting. I wouldn't go as far as to claim that wearing a poppy is a statement for any of the possible interpretations of Remembrance day in particular, though.
- drewcoo 6y agoWar is the continuation of politics by other means. - Carl von Clausewitz
- lopmotr 6y agoIt is political. It glorifies war and being the aggressor in war. I my country, it's mainly used to represent the time we tried to invade what is now Turkey and killed a bunch of the locals defending their territory. Anti-war people don't like it.
- criddell 6y agoThat's not at all what the poppy campaign or the Canadian Legion is all about.
- monkeycantype 6y agoI believe lompotor is from Australia, and is referring in particular to the landing at Gallipoli, in which the British empire was attempting to land in what is now Turkey with support of forces from Commonwealth countries, this certainly included people from Newfoundland. Over the last 25 years, conservative politicians in Australia have have politicised the remembrance of this battle.
- reaperducer 6y agoIt glorifies war. So putting a photo of my dead wife on my desk at work glorifies car crashes? Got it.
- pueblito 6y agoI am sorry for your loss
- DubiousPusher 6y agoThat analogy doesn't map by my logic. It would be more like putting up a plaque that says, "I'm proud of my brother for engaging in risk taking behavior until it caused him to crash his car and die." Also, victims of car crashes aren't generally used in national pageantry aimed at causing more car crashes.
- chrisseaton 6y ago
- tclancy 6y agoPerhaps in Canada, but James McLean may feel differently about the poppy being political. https://deadspin.com/james-mccleans-refusal-to-wear-the-poppy-has-made-him-t-1830233186 https://deadspin.com/james-mccleans-refusal-to-wear-the-popp...
- redis_mlc 6y agoFrom the article: "I was basically told … if they allowed this one particular cause, then it would open up the door so that they would have to allow or consider allowing other causes," said the employee.
- NikolaNovak 6y ago>>What's the political statement made by wearing a poppy? I haven't the foggiest. But it's a fund-raising campaign run by a non-governmental entity. I don't think it's political or controversial. But most non-governmental fund-raising campaigns will also claim they are non-controversial and non-political, so why can't they get a uniform-code exception supported by provincial and federal prime minister? >>Did Whole Foods make a political statement when they enacted the poppy ban? I think Whole Foods have a uniform policy that says "wear no insignia other than these things", and as such it's as a-political as things can get these days. In principle, making an exception for this one cause is formally the political statement. As I said, I think it's a case of damned if you do damned if you don't. I happen to agree with this particular cause and am glad it's receiving support, but I don't necessarily know what objective differentiator we can write down, agree and use that would fit the poppy campaign but not million others.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> But it's a fund-raising campaign run by a non-governmental entity. No a poppy is not inherently part of a any fund-raising. It's a symbol of remembrance. You can buy poppies from anywhere, or make your own, and still be using it to remember.
- theabsurdman 6y agoThis is incorrect. The poppy is actually trademarked in Canada: https://www.legion.ca/remembrance/the-poppy/the-poppy-trademark https://www.legion.ca/remembrance/the-poppy/the-poppy-tradem...
- chrisseaton 6y agoThat doesn't stop people making their own, or wearing an old one.
- Kranar 6y agoIn Canada, the poppy is a legally protected symbol that can only be used under permission by the Royal Canadian Legion. It enjoys not only trademark status but additional special legislation that protects the symbol from being used for any purpose other than remembrance and places the symbol under the exclusive care of the Royal Canadian Legion.
- maerF0x0 6y agoAsk these folks: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscientious_objector#Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscientious_objector#Canada
- criddell 6y agoI don't think conscientious objectors are opposed to support services for veterans and the families of veterans.
- maerF0x0 6y agoThis one is against the glorification of war though. I do actually support helping any person for humanitarian reasons though.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoYeah, I'm basically in agreement. I don't care if people wear them because I don't mind people expressing their opinions which disagree with mine. But I see the veins of martialism spread throughout western society. They are taken for granted because they are the status quo. They had a profound effect on me as a kid to see war as noble and worthwhile. If one may wear a pin to honor war dead, may one wear a pin for those that refused to fight?
- tomjen3 6y agoIt was an attempt to paint those who were killed in WWI (on the British side only) as not pointlessly and deliberately slaughtered, or at lest it seems so to me.
- youngNed 6y agoNot related to this particular set of countries, but the wearing of a poppy is very very political for those from Northern Ireland: https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/why-james-mcclean-doesn-t-wear-poppy-west-brom-remembrance-poppy-appeal-a8037391.html https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/...