9 ms·
Sounds like business will be booming for temp agencies as well as janitorial and facilities maintenance contractors. Whatever the net positive here is wholly n
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Sounds like business will be booming for temp agencies as well as janitorial and facilities maintenance contractors.
Whatever the net positive here is wholly negated by the number of stable long term jobs that are going to go away and be replaced by whoever the body shop chooses to send that day. Working for these middle men really sucks compared to working for whoever the service is being provided for (and I say that from experience).
- umeshunni 6y agoMore likely, this will just result in businesses continuing to leave San Francisco. The pandemic has given most companies a good reason to do so already and my bet is on most of them not returning to their overpriced San Francisco headquarters when this is eventually over.
- rm_-rf_slash 6y agoOr just move it to a smaller office somewhere else in the Bay Area.
- bluGill 6y agoMaybe, but is the rest of the Bay area enough better that they can trust they won't end up the same way in the near future.
- shreyansj 6y agoDamn! Pretty sure that the rest of the Bay Area isn’t a dumpster fire either.
- clhodapp 6y agoContra Costa is full of open space and I believe that many of the cities from Walnut Creek out would bend over backwards to pull in these types of jobs.
- umeshunni 6y agoThere's a mini-silicon valley shaping up in the East Bay along the 580/680 corridor - towns like Dublin, Pleasanton etc are growing rapidly with existing companies and new ones - Oracle, Workday, Snowflake etc are all there. It helps that they are also much more new housing friendly than SF and SV.
- clhodapp 6y agoRight! I wasn't thinking about stuff like Bishop Ranch being down there. Yeah, it really does seem like most of the freeway/transit-connected East Bay towns beyond the hills would be very amendable to this type of growth. It really seems like the only exception would be the arc from Orinda to Danville.
- newhkusers1 6y agoYes, they are better. Also, this isn't the only silly tax law that SF has.
- ashtonkem 6y agoIt’s hard to determine what’ll happen due to pandemic + remote work, but historically nearby counties with lower taxes have always been the biggest risk for high tax municipalities. Think less “I’m leaving NYC to go to Michigan” and more “I’ll move to New Jersey and commute into NYC”. But again, the pandemic and rise of remote work makes this hard to predict.
- cobookman 6y agoThey said SF, not SF Bay area. I'm certain the city of SF will be seeing a loss of jobs as they move to Oakland, East Bay, Peninsula and South Bay.
- LinuxBender 6y agoA law firm I use has been in SF for over 20 years. They just moved to a rough part of Oakland. The move was challenging for them and I know they would not have done it if they didn't have to.
- RangerScience 6y agoWhy did they have to move? This new law, or something else?
- LinuxBender 6y agoThis was in the middle of Covid, around the time many businesses and renters were leaving SF. They would not give me specifics, but I assume it no longer made financial sense to be in that expensive high-rise, as all the parking was locked down, forcing all the customers to take BART. I am not sure what affect this new law will have for those that remain.
- TuringNYC 6y agoAnother reason SF companies are leaving: restrictions mandating lower maximum elevator occupancy (e.g. 4 persons) is causing long lines at some high-rises, making it hard to get in and out of the building -- esp for quick breaks, food pickups, lunch, etc.
- LinuxBender 6y agoI noticed that as well. The building had really tiny elevators, but many of them. You could fit maybe 3 people in them. I had never seen anything like that in my life.
- TuringNYC 6y agoMuch worse since COVID since every elevator has to have minimal separation for passengers, no more squeezing in like sardines.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI doubt it. The purported reasons to leave were already on the table before the pandemic hit, but they were not enough to do so when compared to the reasons for staying. The pandemic is relatively temporary, and once it is over, those reasons for staying will still be on the table.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> The pandemic is relatively temporary Until the next ones comes. That could be in 1 year or 100 years. No one knows. Reminds me of the repeated hurricanes that drive people out of coastal areas.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Reminds me of the repeated hurricanes that drive people out of coastal areas. People still live in coastal areas, and rich people continue to build lavish vacation homes on the coast despite the fact that they're washed away by storms every couple of decades. Part of being rich is not having to worry about money, which is why many rich people live in cities, states and countries that tax them more: the benefits of doing so outweigh the costs. I think you can draw parallels between that and companies choosing to remain in cities for similar reasons despite some drawbacks existing.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoSorry you focused on my comment about coasts. I was really just trying to point out that another pandemic can happen and can happen soon.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI didn't focus on it because I agree with you.
- tlogan 6y agoMaybe but outsourcing is much easier solution than relocating. Think about hedge funds, bond traders, etc. For example, they will be all firing desk support people and replacing them with RobertHalf.
- kmtrowbr 6y agoI have lived in San Francisco since 2005. Over the time I've lived here, we've had the opposite problem: lots of highly paid tech firms moving into SF. This has changed the nature of San Francisco in a way that many dislike, including me. I was initially attracted to San Francisco because, it was chill, it was beautiful, and it had a lot of eccentric, really interesting people. Many of our good friends had to leave over the years as SF has becoming more unlivable because rents have gone up so much, and also it's just not as fun, it's crowded and stressed. I am aware that I am a part of the problem: my wife and I are white, yuppie, dink tech workers. :) These issues are complex. I voted yes on Proposition L: the tax is quite small and I think the tech firms are unlikely to leave, meanwhile SF can get more taxes from them (many of them were historically given tax breaks, like Twitter, to move into the mid-market area). If they do leave, I don't see that as a bad thing. Meanwhile socioeconomic disparity is an oozing sore in San Francisco, we have billionaires rubbing elbows with homeless people every day. Nationally, we've had round after round of tax cuts for the wealthiest, if SF wants to tax excessive income disparity, I say, fair enough.
- drak0n1c 6y agoTaxes tend to increase price levels, not reduce them. Costs are passed through to every level.
- gmadsen 6y agonot 1-1. a personal wealth tax is not felt or distributed down lane. As long as it is not a company tax, it will not be directly pointed to the buyer.
- kansface 6y ago> The tax will levy an extra 0.1% to 0.6% on gross receipts made in San Francisco for companies ...
- stale2002 6y ago> personal wealth tax is not felt Yes it would be. A tax on salaries, would force companies to have to pay more to attract talent. And these are additional costs that the company would have to pay.
- gmadsen 6y agoI don't understand why this is said as a negative. Tech needs to expand to other parts of the country. If SF wants high taxes, so be it, let all participate in the competition of where to be located.
- _jal 6y agoHow many SF companies have FT in-house janitorial and facilities now? I've worked for a lot of (admittedly, tech startup) companies, and none of them have. For that matter, companies I've worked for who needed telephone-answerers or other low-compensation service workers have already spun that off into separate companies, for a similar reason - google '401K highly compensated employee' to see why.
- gumby 6y agoThe total amount is so small I have a hard time believing that anyone would restructure their operations around it.
- gcheong 6y agoCEO compensation historically wasn’t orders of magnitude greater than worker pay like it has ballooned to today and there were plenty of long term jobs. This just formalizes the idea that there shouldn’t be an egregious difference in compensation that was commonplace before the idea that a corporation’s sole purpose is to maximize shareholder value became the main driver of CEO compensation.
- rm_-rf_slash 6y agoI think you missed parent’s point, which is that companies will have (yet another) incentive to replace their lowest paid workers with contractors. First they came for the janitors, but I did not speak up, for I was not a janitor...
- XorNot 6y agoI'm completely at a loss as to why they wouldn't have already done as much of this as it was conceivably possible to do right now - or wouldn't get there eventually. Companies don't pay you more money because they CEO looks at his salary and goes "yeah I think I have enough".
- bluGill 6y agoBecause outsource vs in house is not a simple decision. there are many factors each with a set of pros and cons. Sometimes outsourcing lets "them" focus on efficiency and getting the details right and so you are better off. Sometimes out sourcing cuts quality to get better costs. There are many accountants, it is relatively standard across industries, and so you can outsource it all easily - but most big companies have it in house anyway. (though they will hire out some of the grunt work) This is one area where messing up will kill your company so you better keep a close eye on it. (An accountant can easily steel enough money that you can't maintain cash flow - you might get the accountant in prison but your great company is bankrupt anyway). This is but one example of many cases where out sourcing is bad. On the other side power utilities outsource most tree trimming around power lines. The companies that do this work give the utility a great deal because the contract that keeps their crews busy 3/4ths of the year which is important because most of this type of work is right after a storm and employees are easier to keep when they aren't laid off 3/4ths of the year waiting on the next job. When an out sourcing is borderline not worth it because of risks above it, it may become worth it after this change.
- momokoko 6y agoSounds like you don’t live in the Bay Area. Almost every tech job that isn’t salary, and plenty of salary jobs, already are. It is standard practice in the Bay Area to use staffing agencies for everything but executives and core talent with all signs pointing to the practice becoming even more common well before this.
- 908B64B197 6y agoWait until a commercial robot-vacuum/robot cook provider comes along and underbids the temp agency. You can rent a robotic fry cook for 1'500$ a month from Miso Robotics [0]. I know somewhere someone is looking at a commercial-grade surface cleaner and trash-picking robot. [0] https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/6/21503892/miso-robotics-flippy-roar-robotic-fry-chef-on-sale-price https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/6/21503892/miso-robotics-fl...