10 ms·
U.S. sues Visa to block its acquisition of Plaid
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI find it just interesting that given the intense division in the US right now that the thing that seems to bring the highest bipartisan support is limiting market power of large tech companies.
- ericmay 6y agoThe tech companies (and large business in general) can be viewed as a threat to their power, so they take action. -edit- Just to be clear because I've seen some comments after mine. I'm not advocating for a position, but just stating what I believe is happening. FWIW I'm more inclined to think that neutering tech companies is beneficial, but open to arguments and nuance.
- packetlost 6y agoThat's... generally how governments should work, no? The government should not let private entities undermine it's power.
- ericmay 6y agoJust to be clear I'm not really advocating for a position here, just stating what I think is going on. But with that being said, yea I agree with you here in theory. But it's exceedingly difficult for me to not be skeptical about it when I think about it as a power struggle between a Congresswoman and a tech company over who gets to fuck me over.
- packetlost 6y agoYeah, there wasn't any language that indicated you were taking a side. The thing is, at least the Congresswomen is democratically elected and (in theory) serves the interest of their constituents. Whereas a company serves the interest of it's shareholders, by law, so well-being of it's customers and even employees is secondary to it's legal mandate for profit.
- sarah180 6y agoIs there a particular reason why it's women in Congress who make you skeptical? Is there some context I'm missing here?
- ericmay 6y agoI just try to use the terms interchangeably in hypothetical scenarios so that there isn't a sense of normal association. Sometimes I use Congressman, sometimes Congresswoman. Sometimes I use Congressperson as well. I think if people are noticing then that's a clear sign to keep doing it, because you probably had a prior bias that the person doing something wrong would have been a man.
- dragonwriter 6y ago“Congressmember” in the generic and “Representative” and “Senator” for the specific houses are widely accepted (standard and formally preferred for the house-specific ones) and gender neutral.
- ericmay 6y agoYes, thank you for that. I'm specifically not using gender-neutral terms in this instance, actually. The goal is to muddy the associations that exist and unfortunately gender-neutral terms are unable to do that. They definitely have a time and place for use, though, and I do use them when I think it makes sense to.
- edmundsauto 6y agoInteresting approach, but what it reads like is that you are intentionally gendering the term for some purpose. I was trying to figure out if you meant Senator Warren specifically, because she has been behind a lot of this discussion. You might be confusing your audience more than you are accomplishing your other objective.
- ericmay 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brummm 6y agoIt's just generally a surprise when the Republicans actually do their job.
- ericmay 6y agoHa. Depends on how you define what their job is supposed to be. :P
- cle 6y agoNot as an absolute. Speaking broadly, outside of this specific context, it seems obvious to me that systems which are sufficiently dysfunctional should cede their power to a better system. In the US at least, this is laid out at the very beginning of the Declaration of Independence: > That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government Bringing the context back in to this discussion, I don't have a strong opinion. The power the tech companies wield is scary indeed, but the amount of political dysfunction is also pretty scary. I suppose, since they are equally scary to me, that I'd prefer them to have equal power to act as a check against each other?
- drtz 6y agoWouldn't you want power to stay with elected officials who can be removed from office by the public rather than a private business that's primarily motivated by profit and only answers to shareholders.
- ausbah 6y agocomments like above are reminders of how strong libertarianism is in tech circles, for better or worse
- cle 6y agoThat sounds good in theory but I think in practice, at least in the relatively broken representative system in the US, I'm not so sure. Consider that politicians often operate against the will of ~49% of their constituents. As long as they can maintain a majority, they don't care as much about the minority. I don't think a company, operating in a healthy non-monopolized marketplace, would be as willing to lose 49% of their customers.
- leetcrew 6y agoin theory, yes. in practice, I'd rather be a customer than a constituent.
- closeparen 6y agoDepends on which kind of accountability is more necessary. In the same way that people buy good cheap stuff that works well from Satan himself, they also vote for their ideological allies whether or not public services are within a thousand miles of functioning.
- Nasrudith 6y agoWhen it is over what is a means of accountability for them (it is the media and not the tech which draws the aggro)? Fuck no - they already forget they are servants and not masters.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI think that there’s a dichotomy between east coast oil/finance/defense/old money power and west coast tech money power that’s somewhat independent of the right-left political dichotomy. There’s a desire among Washington and New York power brokers and journalists to knock big tech off its pedestal, which creates an insatiable appetite for anti-tech narratives. I think this explains why so much of the conversation around the 2016 election blames Facebook for the result, when it was one of 100 factors, and some of the more proximate factors were choices of institutions like the FBI and the New York Times. Facebook and Twitter’s measures to visibly suppress Trump’s claims of winning the current election can be seen as attempts to head off this kind of scapegoating, neutralize the narrative, and bow to those east coast institutions. These actions are legally unrelated to antitrust, but seem to be part of an effort to cede ground in the larger conflict the antitrust actions are part of.
- 24gttghh 6y agoDo you consider Visa west coast tech money? They started in Fresno, but by BoA which is old school. Plaid then would also be west coast tech money...
- shajznnckfke 6y agoYeah, I don’t think this thread is entirely relevant to this particular case, but the parent comment was about the anti-tech actions uniting the two political parties.
- vmception 6y ago> The Justice Department’s suit said Visa’s chief executive called the acquisition an “insurance policy” to neutralize a “threat to our important U.S. debit business.” Whoooops! To all CEOs whether its China or the United States, if you want to make some value for shareholders: Shut the fuck up, forever!
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYeah, when it comes to business, the definition of "gaffe" is to tell the truth.
- MaxwellM 6y agoAlso maybe, try to innovate instead of suffocating innovation with a pillow stuffed with cash.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 6y agoUS debit business is likely replaced with Fed instant payments in 2-3 years [1] (the core functionality is approved and building has started [2]). Can't innovate your way out of a central bank replacing your product. You're only left with uncompetitive business options to hold onto your regulatory capture as long as possible. Plaid exists because the US hasn't mandated financial API access like Europe did with PSD2. Regulatory requirements to support this would negate the need for "innovative" startups. EDIT: Real Talk, these networks should not be taxing economies percentage points of total payment volume [3] (again, Europe used regulation to cram down interchange fees to be more reasonable). These are legacy businesses that should be replaced with low cost utility-esq payment services such that the Fed is doing (and already exist in most first world countries [4]). [1] https://www.bankingdive.com/news/fed-gives-new-details-on-its-real-time-payments-system/583153/ https://www.bankingdive.com/news/fed-gives-new-details-on-it... [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/brainard20200806a.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/brainard202... [3] https://theweek.com/articles/850232/why-are-all-paying-tax-credit-card-companies https://theweek.com/articles/850232/why-are-all-paying-tax-c... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant_payment#Examples_of_instant_payment_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant_payment#Examples_of_in...
- teclordphrack2 6y agoThe usa is really showing its anti-capitalist.
- seneca 6y agoAdam Smith, the man who literally wrote the book on Capitalism, warned of the danger of monopoly power and urged State regulation to prevent it.
- kmonsen 6y agoBoth you and your parent can be true, just because Adam Smith wrote the book on capitalism doesn't mean he was 100% for it in all forms. I guess the real answer is what is capitalism, and the first answer I could find is: "an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state." This ruling would not bring any trade or industry in state control so in that way I cannot see how the parent is correct. Edit: Wikipedia says this though: "Capitalism is an economic system. In it the government plays a secondary role. People and companies make most of the decisions, and own most of the property. Goods are usually made by companies and sold for profit. The means of production are largely or entirely privately owned (by individuals or companies) and operated for profit.[1][2] Most property, for example, is owned by people or companies, not by the government or by the workers. Capitalism has a more or less free market economy, which means that prices move up or down according to the availability of the products. People buy and sell things according to their own judgment. In most countries there is some regulation (trade laws) and some planning done by the government. They are sometimes called "mixed economies" to indicate this. Some people disagree on whether capitalism is a good idea, or how much of capitalism is a good idea." According to this I guess it is fair to say that this is anti-capitalistic. In a true capitalistic society government should not be involved in transactions or take important decisions about this. I don't think such a society would work but people can have different opinions on this.
- jtuente 6y ago> In a true capitalistic society government should not be involved in transactions or take important decisions about this. Even under a purely capitalist system, if there is a suspicion of malfeasance in such a transaction, it is reasonable for the government or others to ask for more clarity. Blackmail, bribery, embezzlement, or other bad faith agreements can introduce legal proceedings, none of those things are permissible under capitalism.
- maurys 6y agoAs someone who doesn't fully understand the rules around these acquisitions, is there a clear enough framework for what companies one can acquire? Are companies more frequently flouting that or is this a case of suing companies while the regulatory framework catches up? Basically, is suing companies to block acquisitions standard procedure?
- frenchman_in_ny 6y agoBasically, it's codified in Hart–Scott–Rodino [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hart%E2%80%93Scott%E2%80%93Rodino_Antitrust_Improvements_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hart%E2%80%93Scott%E2%80%93Rod...
- ballenf 6y agoThere are clear-ish rules for when you need to report the transaction and seek clearance in advance. They come down to transaction size, I believe. But the DOJ/FTC can sue to block any transaction on antitrust grounds, whether reportable or not. There are no rules that block any particular acquisition, just rules about whether you need to preemptively notify the government about the transaction and give them time to decide whether to challenge it.
- texasbigdata 6y agoHere is likely what you’re referring to. Above ~~$75M it has to be declared and then you are subject to review. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hart–Scott–Rodino_Antitrust_Improvements_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hart–Scott–Rodino_Antitrust_...
- mrkurt 6y agoYes it's standard, or at least it was. The FTC has been rubber stamping acquisitions for almost 20 years.
- xoxoy 6y agothey blocked the Harry’s Razor acquisition successfully
- pgrote 6y agoFor those like myself that are unaware of what Plaid does: https://plaid.com/what-is-plaid/ https://plaid.com/what-is-plaid/ "Connecting your bank to your apps We power thousands of the apps that people rely on to manage their financial lives. Venmo (peer-to-peer payments) Betterment (automated investing) Chime (online banking) Dave (earned wage access) And thousands more..."
- lights0123 6y agoNow of course, if only banks implemented some kind of OAuth instead of relying on a third-party logging into your account as you...
- simonke 6y agoBanks are already doing that with openid. See partners of https://yes.com/ https://yes.com/ (European)
- easton 6y agoPlaid would still have a place, as they could manage connecting applications to every bank in the US (so you don't have to use different client libraries for every single bank, because god knows they won't pick a common setup). I'm really surprised they haven't gotten BofA to give them access to their consumer accounts API, considering Plaid can't deal with BofA's SMS 2FA. It's the largest bank in the US and Plaid can't handle it, which shows how fragile the whole scraping thing really is.
- twostorytower 6y agohttps://teller.io/ https://teller.io/ is trying to do something like this.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThe fact that Plaid has been so successful convincing so many consumers to enter their banking credentials into random, unverified third party sites (with no verification whatsoever that you're even talking to Plaid in the first place) is pretty amazing to me.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoPlaid speed… denied !
- alberth 6y agoMastercard announced an acquisition of Finicity (Plaid competitor) a few months ago that is still pending approval. Have to imagine that acquisition is now under further review.
- jbverschoor 6y agoPlaidis one of the few companies offering access to banks through the PSD2 api