6 ms·
Real estate is designed for people to live in. Money laundering through real estate is ancillary -- a bug -- and attempts are made to stop it. Regularly. Up to
by arcticbull 6y ago
Real estate is designed for people to live in. Money laundering through real estate is ancillary -- a bug -- and attempts are made to stop it. Regularly. Up to and including Vancouver instituting a 15% tax on foreign buyers and New Zealand banning non-residents from buying real estate.
Cryptocurrency is designed specifically, by virtue of its decentralized and trustless nature, to facilitate money laundering. It was a design goal. This is what it's for. That and of course, collecting the proceeds of ransomware. Another way of describing 'money laundering' is transferring value, without the permission of a centralized government authority, with the intent to conceal the source of funds (hey it's your money right?).
That it has yet to achieve the same scale is not relevant.
All sorts of illegal activities aren't done at scale, that doesn't mean they shouldn't be policed. Otherwise you'll be pointing to the small scale right up until the moment it's not small anymore, and then it's too late.
- vmception 6y agoDespite you being incorrect, its not even worth debating because the common denominator is that it looks like the state should just quit using public resources on trying to whitelist transactions since that seems to be the real waste, and find a new tool to curb whatever activity they were actually trying to stop.
- arcticbull 6y agoWrong in what way? I made three fairly factual statements. 1. Houses are meant for you to live in. Not super contentious I wager. 2. Trustless and decentralized means you can transfer value without the permission of a centralized authority. I believe that's frequently touted. 3. Money laundering is transferring money without the permission of a centralized authority with the intent to conceal the original source of funds.
- vmception 6y ago> [Money Laundering] is what [cryptocurrency's] for. That and of course, collecting the proceeds of ransomware. That's the wrong part, even if it was just hyperbole for literary effect then you are conflating legal terms you don't really understand then. Money laundering is a legal term that requires an illicit origin, not merely circumventing the permission of a centralized authority. You were correct that it is designed to ignore the concept of centralized authorities, the rest was either a completely incorrect extrapolation of that, or hyperbole that did not give the effect you thought it did as it just undermines your point and the strength of your argument.
- arcticbull 6y agoDepends, I maintain that Paul Le Roux is the most likely Satoshi, and of course -- if true -- that would be why Paul Le Roux created it. [1] > Money laundering is a legal term that requires an illicit origin. I'm not 100% sure if it requires both an illicit source and intent to conceal or not. It might, but it sounds like we both have half the definition. For instance, structuring -- breaking apart large transactions into smaller ones to avoid a currency transaction report -- is illegal regardless of whether the source of funds is criminal or not. [1] https://www.wired.com/story/was-bitcoin-created-by-this-international-drug-dealer-maybe/ https://www.wired.com/story/was-bitcoin-created-by-this-inte...
- vmception 6y ago> Depends, I maintain that Paul Le Roux is the most likely Satoshi, and of course -- if true -- that would be why Paul Le Roux created it. [1] Okay. And that's partially why I'm open to the idea of the government ceasing to use public resources on whitelisting all transactions, instead of debating you over whether something is or isn't money laundering. Structuring is a different crime than money laundering, which is actually another exhibit on why I want the government to cease using bothering using public money and resources on whitelisting all transactions. I read enough court cases on Google Scholar about paranoid people doing legal things convicted for only structuring on Google Scholar to make this opinion, and this was before HSBC got a slap on the wrist for literally accepting cash deposits from the literal cartel and getting caught, undermining the whole point of whitelisting transactions to begin with.
- pbhjpbhj 6y ago>"For instance, structuring -- breaking apart large transactions into smaller ones to avoid a currency transaction report -- is illegal regardless of whether the source of funds is criminal or not."// I assume you mean according to USC (ie USA law), could you cite which section please?
- vmception 6y agohttps://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/31/5324 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/31/5324 https://www.justice.gov/archives/jm/criminal-resource-manual-2033-structuring https://www.justice.gov/archives/jm/criminal-resource-manual... and pretty much trying to avoid any monetary reporting threshold is a criminal charge whether you intended to or not. so this one is funny because almost every fairly poor person I know, the kind of people that would rarely have over $10,000 at once ever, are the exact people that would harbor some belief about doing X, Y and Z to "avoid transferring over $10,000" believe it or not, jail, right away.
- ballenf 6y agoI don't think 3 provides a very robust definition. Otherwise cash, if introduced today, would meet the definition way better than Bitcoin. Or maybe that's intentional.
- arcticbull 6y agoI suspect, like someone attempting to introduce cigarettes as a new product into today's market, that's quite intentional.
- URSpider94 6y agoCash does work pretty well for money laundering, except that it’s bulky. The $1 billion mentioned in this article would weigh 10,000 kilos and would require a semitrailer to move. And the big problem is that now you have to do something with it. You can’t buy anything worth more than $10k with it, without the government getting paperwork on it, so you’re kind of stuck with it.
- freeone3000 6y ago(3) is a sufficient component in the US to be money laundering, so it's a sufficient working definition. cash is tracked fairly extensively, as anyone who's transferred large sums can attest to.
- leppr 6y ago1. Houses are not "the real estate market". People need dwellings to live in, and the real estate market is there to regulate people's ability to build and occupy them. In a similar fashion to you, I could very well argue that real estate was designed to perpetuate class by way of a multi-generational ponzi scheme, because that's the de-facto situation. In reality, like with cryptocurrency, trying to attribute intention where you only see an effect is just manipulative.
- baybal2 6y ago> Cryptocurrency is designed specifically, by virtue of its decentralized and trustless nature, to facilitate money laundering. It was a design goal. If it was its designed goal, it would've also included provisions to provide proofs anonymously, and reduce physical traceability. I very much see some cryptocurrencies tried, and some are moderately successful with it, but none have progressed much on the former other than by using crypto signing by some centralised, or semi-decentralised entity which processes the ledger, or does proof of work. So, none of the popular cryptocurrencies have achieved a true "non-chain" way of working, which does not rely on a continuous record of the global state of the ledger. The cryptographic trust in such mechanism would be much less than in a non-anonymous ledger, where the state of all wallets is recorded for everybody to see, and check for signs of something weird.
- kmeisthax 6y ago[laughs in Monero]
- jfrunyon 6y ago> Cryptocurrency is designed specifically, by virtue of its decentralized and trustless nature, to facilitate money laundering. It was a design goal. ... with the intent to conceal the source of funds That is simply false. Virtually every cryptocurrency is 100% traceable.
- arcticbull 6y agoNot, obviously, Monero and Zcash. Pseudonymity is often sufficient, money laundering doesn't require anonymity.
- jfrunyon 6y agoPseudonymity is almost never sufficient, as Ross Ulbricht proves. Yes, there are a few cryptocurrencies for whom untraceability is a design goal. Obviously this does not include Bitcoin (which is the subject of this thread), and in general it doesn't include the vast majority of cryptocurrencies.
- arcticbull 6y agoTumblers seemed to work just fine. One single counter-example of someone who failed to take necessary precautions when committing a crime doesn't mean the tens of thousands of people you never heard of haven't been very successful.
- jfrunyon 6y agoIs that the same as a mixer? If so: sure, they work just fine, except that you've introduced a SPOF who can tell everyone who you are/where it came from/where it went, etc. It's also tough to call something that arose long after BTC itself a "design goal" of BTC. Maintaining proper opsec for any significant length of time is extremely difficult, nigh impossible. Almost everyone will fail at some point. With pseudonymity, a single failure ever means everything is lost. With anonymity, only that single failure is lost.
- javert 6y ago> Cryptocurrency is designed specifically, by virtue of its decentralized and trustless nature, to facilitate money laundering. It was a design goal. This is what it's for. That and of course, collecting the proceeds of ransomware. You probably have some good points to make, but saying something like this is just willfully not engaging in communication with the other side of the argument. That is an egregious strawman which obscures whatever valid points you actually have.
- gl00pp 6y ago"Cryptocurrency is designed specifically, by virtue of its decentralized and trustless nature, to facilitate money laundering. " No it's designed to eliminate debasement and inflation