5 ms·
Here are some interesting graphs from arguably the most transformative economic miracle in human history [0]. The risk isn't the US doing nothing, it is India,
by roenxi 6y ago
Here are some interesting graphs from arguably the most transformative economic miracle in human history [0]. The risk isn't the US doing nothing, it is India, Africa, etc, etc deciding that they seriously want a comfortable standard of living.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/co2/country/china?country=~CHN https://ourworldindata.org/co2/country/china?country=~CHN
- cher88 6y agoIsn't this the more pertinent graph? https://ourworldindata.org/co2/country/china?country=USA~IND~CHN~NGA~ETH https://ourworldindata.org/co2/country/china?country=USA~IND...
- roenxi 6y agoPretty sure. Nature, being unconcerned with fairness, has little regard for per capita statistics. If we want 8 billion people living in comfort, we need more energy. As always, I think we should have been building more nuclear plants back in the 90s. And again in the 2000s. And the 2010s. Maybe now we can go wind and solar. But we need lots of something.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe definition of comfort is the issue. There are simply not enough resources for everyone on Earth to live like an American. Maybe Europeans if we stretch with renewables and quickly cut down overfishing and stripmining agricultural practices. My money (unfortunately) is on a whole lot of death and despair from crop failures, drought, and mass migrations due to climate change even if we’re able to rapidly decarbonize energy infrastructure. We waited too long to change direction, and aren’t moving fast enough in the right direction.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe things you'd need to do to get the world to accept a definition of "comfort" that doesn't include eating meat (vegan definition) several times a week, living and working comfortably climate control buildings and access to a wide array of consumer products would not be pretty to put it mildly. Making people's standards of living go backwards make them shoot you. Holding down people's standards of living makes their kids or grand-kids shoot you. Policy sticks are a time bomb. Social solutions (convincing people to behave in a way that reduces their environmental footprint) only get you so far. We need technical solutions (more efficiency in the entire economy) such that people can eat fish or beef and drive in cars (or have access to functionally equivalent or superior analogues) at lesser environmental cost. The "western lifestyle" (moving target, I know) needs to scale because even if the west manages to reduce consumption enough to have a good impact the masses in developing nations are certainly not going to settle for the status quo let alone a reduction in consumption.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou need less people, fundamentally. The total fertility rate is declining across the world luckily (except a handful of countries and Africa) [1], but everyone around now is going to have a rough ride until equilibrium is reached (sometime after 2100). Can’t grow your way out of resource exhaustion (renewables excepted). [1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#country-by-country-the-decline-of-the-number-of-children-per-woman-since-1950 https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#country-by-country...
- pfdietz 6y agoIt's declining in Africa also. https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/demographics-of-africa/ https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/demographics-of-a...
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThanks for pointing that out. Our World In Data’s data is out of date [1], I keep poking them to update their fertility rate data but get no response (maybe busy with COVID data sets, I have no context into why). [1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate
- makomk 6y agoI suspect that Covid is going to run a coach and horses right through that improvement. The best ways of getting population growth down in places like Africa are education and a strong, stable economy - and it's just trashed both.
- pfdietz 6y agoActually, the best way is empowering women.
- ForHackernews 6y agoWe can also just have fewer people: If you lower infant mortality, educate women and give them access to family planning, all evidence suggests they will choose to have fewer children. It's much easier for the planet to support a high standard of living for four or six billion people than eight or ten billion.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAggressive population control should be given high priority, yet declining population growth and fertility rates are always depicted as negatives in Western countries. In Europe many countries still have incentives to boost fertility. It's high time we give up on the fantasy of an ever growing population as a ponzi scheme to boost the economy and finance public spending. We need to face the reality that we ought to have at the very least a stable population and reorganise society accordingly. In relation to developing countries, any healthcare-related aid should be conditional to implementation of birth control policies. Globally we really should have a target to reduce population by a few billions if we want to all enjoy life in comfort (~Western country level) on a thriving planet. Edit: Judging by the reactions, the penny has not dropped yet for some... Hopefully it will before it's too late.
- wwright 6y agoI’m really not sure this is the case. For example, we know that we have far more than enough capacity to produce food for the entire world, we just simply don’t do it. Of course, Americans are very wasteful, and we can’t scale that amount of wastefulness to the entire planet.
- mathh 6y agoIs it so hard on HN to use specific and appropriate verbs other than “to scale” for any idea related to something expanding or getting bigger ?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWe have enough fossil-fuel-dependent capacity to strip-mine soil to feed the entire world. I'm not sure if we have enough capacity for sustainable food production, and even if, the methods, technologies and supply chains aren't there (and won't be, as long as they have to compete against modern agriculture).
- swiley 6y agoDo you have a source for this? Because last time I checked this wasn't the case.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoFrom a quick Google search: https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-33133712 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-33133712 More depth can explored using keywords like “global footprint” and “ecological footprint”. What’s your source (“last time I checked”)?
- tomtomtom777 6y ago> Pretty sure. Nature, being unconcerned with fairness, has little regard for per capita statistics. But nature also has little regard for per country statistics. Splitting China into two countries, isn't going to lower their polution. Using per capita statistics at least allows us to focus on those that are emitting excessively more than others.
- belorn 6y agoSplitting a country is not going to lower the pollution, but equally so does a high populations density not decrease pollution.
- op03 6y ago>> If we want 8 billion people living in comfort, we need more energy "We want" is language that hides reality. Who wants this? How many people? As the Trump election (and many other elections around the world) show there is no "we want". Different people want different things. Sweeping that fact under the carpet again and again leads to Paris type meaninglessness. Paris fails because there was never any "we". All the narratives of fear and blame, guilt and shame that have been tried did not make a dent. Those who want to do something will do it and those that don't want to wont. Reconcile to that reality and things will actually move forward.
- Mahn 6y ago"We want" here is a figure of speech. The world doesn't actually care if you don't want other people to live as comfortably as you, because it's gonna happen either way, no country in the world is going to stop pursuing a better quality of life. The real question here is "do we want to figure this out, or do we look the other way".
- contravariant 6y agoAlthough we probably do need to explain why the U.S. requires significantly more energy per person to let people live in comfort compared to European countries.
- einpoklum 6y ago> If we want 8 billion people living in comfort, we need more energy This is not true. It is possible for 8 Billion people to live in comfort (of course, for a reasonable definition of comfort, which isn't typical US lifestyle at the moment), with the amount of Energy produced right now. _If_ production and distribution, political and economic structures, transportation and habitation systems etc. were to change significantly. (This is regardless of the Nuclear yes/no discussion.)
- koheripbal 6y agoFrom the perspective of actually fixing the problem (which takes capital investment), the most pertinent graph would be per unit of GDP. It acts as both an efficiency measure as well as an indication of whether those most able to solve the issue are doing so.
- belorn 6y agoWhich graph to look at depend on what question one has. If the question is "Who is polluting the world and need to stop" then country’s annual CO2 emissions is the single most relevant graph since that is where the pollution is right now coming from. If one is to ask "whom's individual citizen way of living is contributing most" we would look at per capita C02. If the question is "Who is at risk of increasing their pollution" you would look at living standards and growth rates. If you ask "Who has the beast means to invest into climate change preventing technology" you would look at GDP. If you ask "where in the production chain pollution is created" then looking at trade gives that. If the question is whom is to be blamed historically for getting us into this situation then the historical global cumulative CO2 graph shows that, through I am a bit skeptical that it actually gives a correct picture since ww1 and ww2 were very central in ushering us into the age of fossil fuels.
- blackoil 6y agoAs my logical view, the one who is emitting and can afford to reduce, should work on it.
- tzs 6y ago> Which graph to look at depend on what question one has. If the question is "Who is polluting the world and need to stop" then country’s annual CO2 emissions is the single most relevant graph since that is where the pollution is right now coming from. So if China were to spin off each province as a separate country and the US were to spin of each state as a separate country with each of the new countries emitting exactly as much CO2 as it had before it was a separate country, this would be an improvement?
- belorn 6y agoSplitting of countries has as much improvement as getting higher population density. A 5 person household does not have less pollution than 4 person household just because they got one person more to share the blame. Similar two countries combined do as much pollution as if they were separated, because physics does not care about borders. If we go by per capita, the country that contribute the most to the world pollution is a island country with 300 islands and 1700 people. At the same time there are a bunch of oil countries which list as the most green countries in the world because per capita they got close to nothing in pollution per person. If we go outside of countries, the international space station and antarctic would have insane amount of CO2 per capita since only a very small number of highly specialized people living there. If we want to stop climate change, going to Palau and Luxembourg with remedies will have zero impact. Their numbers at top of the table is only relevant in terms of statistics.
- paganel 6y agoAnd people still say Malthus was wrong. At least some of them have woken up to the realisation that exporting your pollution/nasty stuff to other parts of the world doesn't really solve all that much, but even so, they're still a minority, the great majority still believes in silver bullets like recycling, "clean tech" etc.
- corty 6y agoThe silver bullet is natural self-regulation. Mankind will shrink automatically after hitting a real ceiling.
- perfunctory 6y agoI guess people who say this kind of things don't believe they themselves will be part of the cohort undergoing the shrinkage. This so called natural self-regulation will be ugly and painful. I don't envy the generation that will have to go through it.
- hengheng 6y agoNot GP but I do say the same, and yes it will be uglier than the first half of the 20th century. The fight for food will be very real and it takes away confidence from my family planning.
- ptr 6y agoIf every woman gives birth to less than ~2.1 children, we're shrinking. Is having <= 2 children painful and ugly?
- originalvichy 6y agoI feel like this is a deflection and a critical reason why progress isn’t happening fast enough. Your house is already messy, and the need to clean it up is now. Not when China and a couple billion other people mess their house up. My country’s ambitious plans are shot down by members of parliament going for the kneejern ”but India and China...” response, and the net result would be no action if they were in power. Luckily we at least have people some people in the government who are willing to make sacrifices. It’s about time the US as a developed country caught up (not just on the state level).
- noworriesnate 6y agoIf we bring jobs back to the U.S., we will no longer be outsourcing our pollution production. The same jobs will produce less pollution in the U.S. than in China. Of course prices will go up for the goods being produced. So there is something we can do about China and India being major polluters.
- he0001 6y agoIsn’t this something that’s up to the companies that put their production there to decide?
- noworriesnate 6y agoNo, because companies that want to employ Americans can't compete with companies that want to employ Chinese, because it costs less to employ Chinese. In other words there are externalities (polluting the global environment) that aren't priced into the cost of labor when you're comparing the two countries. Tariffs and similar things can help price in that externality.
- he0001 6y agoTariffs have been good for China. In fact their economy is booming. Polluting your own soil is never a good thing and spills over on other aspects of society makes it more expensive.
- jwr 6y agoThis is a very harmful, and yet depressingly common answer. "But look at [...finger-pointing here...]" — which "justifies" doing nothing. So we are doing nothing. And eventually it's going to catch up with us all.
- neya 6y ago> The risk isn't the US doing nothing, it is India, Africa, etc, etc deciding that they seriously want a comfortable standard of living. I can't believe that a country wanting to have a "comfortable standard of living" is seen as a "risk". Almost suggesting as if those countries don't deserve them and a comfortable standard of living should be reserved only for a select few countries. I just can't fucking believe what I just read.
- dannyw 6y agoDon’t apply emotions to science. Ending COVID19 is a risk to global emissions, because the pandemic‘s lockdowns has reduced emissions. Risk doesn’t mean emotional judgment or anything about who deserves what.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Ending COVID19 is a risk to global emissions, because the pandemic‘s lockdowns has reduced emissions. Long term it isn't. Reducing emissions is going to cost a lot of money. There is less money available for that after economies shrink and governments print money to support their people. Covid helps emissions temporarily but harms the overall path.
- OGWhales 6y agoRight? Surely it is the responsibility of the already developed nations to solve this crisis. Putting the blame on developing nations for daring to live the same way we do is... pretty ridiculous.
- OGWhales 6y ago>The risk isn't the US doing nothing, it is India, Africa, etc, etc deciding that they seriously want a comfortable standard of living. Do you not think it is a responsibility of the already developed nations to solve this crisis first?
- gnramires 6y agoIf the US, brimming with wealth, technologically advanced and educated can't commit to fighting climate change, what will the poorest developing countries decide? They would need to take the burden themselves and falling behind economically (something China in particular would strongly resist). A few defectors can ruin the entire plan because of economic pressure. I think we should be nearing an accord with greater control anyway -- defectors will need to suffer harsh economic sanctions greater than what they'd spend on the accord anyway. I expect this to happen within a few years.