4 ms·
we're still in the same place as the original publications: most scientists don't think that EM of rocks from that look like microbes on rocks on earth is a con
by dekhn 6y ago
we're still in the same place as the original publications: most scientists don't think that EM of rocks from that look like microbes on rocks on earth is a convincing argument. The morphological argument has held since before this rock, it wasn't added up afterwards.
There just isn't enough information here to conclude anything so it's easier to reject the hypothesis (I have to admit, it took me a while to accept the idea that there is that much mass exchange between planets in the first place!)
- garmaine 6y agoAnd yet, go try to find out an age for the origin of life on Earth. You'll find that ALL of the evidence is faint morphological features in rocks from Australia. It's the gold standard for one field, but circumstantial in another?
- dekhn 6y agoNot correct, the data on earth that is reliable is based on carbon ratios, which are a far better hallmark. The older morphological stuff, while fun, is really just speculative, still.
- garmaine 6y agoNot for origin of life, no. We’re talking >3gy. These fossils are rocks, not biomaterials. Isotopes of trace decay products in the rock itself are used to age it, as is done with other geologic samples.