4 ms·

Thinking react vs. angular as though they are trying to "win" some universal battle is just propagated by clickbait blogging. Enterprise + larger scale teams te

Thinking react vs. angular as though they are trying to "win" some universal battle is just propagated by clickbait blogging. Enterprise + larger scale teams tend towards Angular, blog posts and hip projects tend towards react.

maclockard 6y ago
I don't think this distinction is exactly correct. I've worked on some enterprise projects with larger scale teams that have used React. It offers a bit more control than Angular does in terms of what your frontend 'stack' is comprised of. This level of control can be appealing for large projects. I kinda see a trend that projects started after x date tend to use React over Angular, but I am unsure of what x is or how universal this is.
- xxffgg557 6y ago
  Obviously some enterprises have used either. This is not about subjective experience. Regardless, it should be obvious to anybody that has ever worked in a massive corporation that a DIY approach with react will not be opted for. Talking about the corps where most people get jobs, not the ones that publish blog posts on hacker news
  - dragonwriter 6y ago
    > Regardless, it should be obvious to anybody that has ever worked in a massive corporation that a DIY approach with react will not be opted for. While it's public sector, I work for a fairly big, boring, enterprise org that doesn't publish anything on HN and for our apps that use a SPA framework, a “DIY approach with React” is pretty much exactly what we are doing,at least in my corner of the org. Never heard of anyone in the org using Angular (there's some shops doing jQuery/Bootstrap stuff, and some at least experimenting with Blazor which isn't surprising given how .NET-heavy the org has been.) There was a time when Angular was sort of the enterprise Java of SPA frameworks, but I think that's kinda past already, and lots of big boring enterprises missed it completely.
  - maclockard 6y ago
    In my experience bigger companies seem possibly _more_ prone to a DIY approach than scrappy startup. Especially if there is a 'not built here' mentality.
nfRfqX5n 6y ago
yes, hip "projects" like as facebook, airbnb, walmart, nytimes, netflix use react
bluedevil2k 6y ago
I disagree with this statement. The last 3 projects I've been on, all huge enterprise level projects, have all been React. Angular was purposefully not picked on the first project because it gets hard to maintain on huge projects, and the last 2 projects were moving existing Angular apps to React for that same reason.

maclockard 6y ago

I don't think this distinction is exactly correct. I've worked on some enterprise projects with larger scale teams that have used React. It offers a bit more control than Angular does in terms of what your frontend 'stack' is comprised of. This level of control can be appealing for large projects. I kinda see a trend that projects started after x date tend to use React over Angular, but I am unsure of what x is or how universal this is.

xxffgg557 6y ago
Obviously some enterprises have used either. This is not about subjective experience. Regardless, it should be obvious to anybody that has ever worked in a massive corporation that a DIY approach with react will not be opted for. Talking about the corps where most people get jobs, not the ones that publish blog posts on hacker news
- dragonwriter 6y ago
  > Regardless, it should be obvious to anybody that has ever worked in a massive corporation that a DIY approach with react will not be opted for. While it's public sector, I work for a fairly big, boring, enterprise org that doesn't publish anything on HN and for our apps that use a SPA framework, a “DIY approach with React” is pretty much exactly what we are doing,at least in my corner of the org. Never heard of anyone in the org using Angular (there's some shops doing jQuery/Bootstrap stuff, and some at least experimenting with Blazor which isn't surprising given how .NET-heavy the org has been.) There was a time when Angular was sort of the enterprise Java of SPA frameworks, but I think that's kinda past already, and lots of big boring enterprises missed it completely.
- maclockard 6y ago
  In my experience bigger companies seem possibly _more_ prone to a DIY approach than scrappy startup. Especially if there is a 'not built here' mentality.

nfRfqX5n 6y ago

yes, hip "projects" like as facebook, airbnb, walmart, nytimes, netflix use react

bluedevil2k 6y ago

I disagree with this statement. The last 3 projects I've been on, all huge enterprise level projects, have all been React. Angular was purposefully not picked on the first project because it gets hard to maintain on huge projects, and the last 2 projects were moving existing Angular apps to React for that same reason.