12 ms·
There's another factor that's not mentioned here: the US has some bonkers expensive station design. Take the newish Hudson Yards station. Its platform is about
by jcranmer 6y ago
There's another factor that's not mentioned here: the US has some bonkers expensive station design.
Take the newish Hudson Yards station. Its platform is about twice as wide as the original subway station platforms, and it's far longer than it needs to be too. On top of that, it has a full-length underground mezzanine above the platform, which is unnecessary. Overall, the effect when I first used it was "why is this so unnecessarily massive?"
Oversized stations are even more problematic when you consider that the MTA wants to build all of these by mining rather than using cut-and-cover, because cut-and-cover has too much disruption to surface tenants. And mining is far more expensive than cut-and-cover, so the extra volume you need to dig out for excessive station sizes hits your purse even faster. For as high as the actual tunneling costs are, it's the station costs that truly make the subway extensions stratospherically expensive.
- bobthepanda 6y agoHudson Yards is Manhattan's newest office submarket and probably best-in-class modern office space in town. There were estimates that Hudson Yards would become the largest station by entries and exits. (MTA's station usage stats do not count transfers within a station's paid area.)
- jcranmer 6y agoYou have to include transfer density to account for platform load factors, and Times Square's situation of having 5 of the 7 Midtown Manhattan lines transferring there, all of them having both express and local platforms, on top of the massive local draws for boarding, and the location of the Port Authority's bus terminal virtually guarantees that it's going to the busiest station complex in perpetuity. By contrast, the Hudson Yards station is a terminus station of a single line. That means traffic is largely going to be directly from the single platform entrance (there's only one bank of escalators to the surface) to the waiting train, or vice versa. Even if it's potentially going to be busy, there is very little need for platform loitering, and certainly not for the massive overbuild of platform and mezzanine that exists today.
- Schiendelman 6y agoIt’s only going to be a terminus station for a few decades. That line will end up in Chelsea.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoWhat a waste. If anything it should end up in New Jersey.
- jcranmer 6y agoEvery fantasy subway map I've seen has extended the 7 into New Jersey. Extending the 7 down into Chelsea makes no sense, because you already have 4-track subway trunks on 8th and 7th, and the island is narrowing as you head downtown. If you need another Midtown N-S trunk, the logical choice is the 2nd Ave, as the east side is underserved (and that side of the island bulges out as you head downtown instead of disappearing). Even then, the return on investment for the southern portions of the 2nd Ave Subway is kind of shaky.
- Schiendelman 6y agoLet me know when New Jersey is willing to have the line come to them. You recall what happened...
- jcranmer 6y agoYeah, I'm aware that ARC was cancelled. The fact that a trans-Hudson subway extension is not really viable anytime in the next few decades doesn't mean that the extension to Chelsea is an alternative worth building, though; it just means that the reality is going to be that Hudson Yards will be a terminus for quite some time.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThey have to dig two new tunnels in the next 20 years. Just sweeten the deal and make it three. The new guy could make it happen sooner. The bigger deal is that MTA will have to implement zoned fares to keep from undercutting NJT. That is the unspoken feature that OMNY will be bringing to the city.
- megablast 6y agoBuilding for the future, rather than the now.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoRe-evaluate the future you're building for if it's unreasonably expensive to build for it. Sometimes it's cheaper to destroy demand or otherwise not build for density you don't need. This is way different (massively over budget and/or behind schedule public projects) then dropping extra fiber in a trench because you're there already ("Dig Once"). For example, Strong Towns [1] seems to champion the whole "the suburbs are unsustainable" perspective, but never the "public works projects in HCOL metros are too expensive for the resulting density" thesis. Market forces will likely work it out in this case though (people leaving HCOL locations for lower density locations where per dollar quality of life is higher, with major cities having to do more with less, or do less with less [tax revenue] [2]). [1] https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/27/nyregion/mta-virus-budget-money.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/27/nyregion/mta-virus-budget...
- ardit33 6y agoHave you been at the current Penn Station, in NYC? That's how a 'build for now' station looks like. It is a total shitshow during rush hour, and especially during holidays. Everyone in NYC hates it and we are currently building an extension at the old post office, as it is not fit for usage anymore. The old one (the one that got demolished in the 60s) was miles ahead in both space and aesthetics. Also, almost nobody hates the Grand Central Station, even though it gets overran with tourists as it is a beautiful peace of work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 6y agoBest comment about the new now old Penn Station. 'One entered the city like a god; one scuttles in now like a rat'
- Schiendelman 6y agoHi there! I started and ran Seattle Subway - I’m a bit of a transit nerd, and would love to chat about this. The MTA is planning on a 100 year horizon. It is ALWAYS cheaper to build capacity now than to retrofit later, even inflation adjusted. If you’d like to challenge their methodology, first go read the planning report!
- aplummer 6y agoIs a mezzanine considered capacity?
- Schiendelman 6y agoAbsolutely. Mezzanines are critical in flow management during peak. You know how if you go to a Disney ride, most of the line is inside the structure? Same concept. Get people out of the rain/snow/heat and normalize flow.
- asdff 6y agoBut a mezzanine is sort of silly considering no one lines up for an hour for a train like they do on a disneyland ride. All the stations in LA have these massive mezzanines too and they are just dead space. They are absolutely empty during rush hour aside from people charging through them to get to the actual platform, because it might take you several minutes to go from above ground, down the escalators, through the mezzanine, down a second set of escalators, and to the platform, at which point the train might be gone and you will sit there twiddling your thumbs for another 10 minutes, clogging up the platform for the next train since you should have made that first one. It's a huge problem at stations like 7th street in downtown LA, where the light rail platform is below a mezzanine but above the heavy rail platform, which bottlenecks transfers due to a lack of thought put into how many stairs and escalators should be made. Probably 1/5 days a week commuting in the before times would I actually make that transfer, the other times you are jammed up by people bottlenecked by the limited stairs and escalators and you watch the train go away without you. Take out the elaborate mezzanine and make it a simple single level multitrack platform directly under the surface, and you might make the first train and be out of the station in less time, lowering the needed capacity of the station structure in the first place.
- awhitby 6y agoI haven't been to the Hudson Yards stop, but many NY subway platforms are very cramped by modern transit standards (compared with even, say the DC metro). I'm sure they're not accessible and hard to make so, and some sections are so narrow as to be positively dangerous. Building new platforms that were just "as wide as the original subway platforms" would be the bonkers thing. Sure it's more expensive to build it big, but I bet its more expensive still (if not totally impossible) to build it small then _re_build it big a few decades later.
- nerfhammer 6y agoOne thing I've always wondered about was SFMTA's giant underground stations that could fit six actual Muni trains on the platforms, or the giant Caltrain+BART station at Milbrae that could fit about 2.5 times as many trains as it actually ever does.
- rhizome 6y agoMy Dad used to like telling a story about how when BART first opened, none of the trains had overhead bars because the trains were supposed to run so often nobody was going to have to stand. It's kind of wild that that wasted space for MUNI underground is not a bigger complaint in the main. My fantasy is that the last 20 years of tunnel computerization for MUNI was going to result in multiple trains per station, or hooking multiple lines together at the entrance of the tunnel (IIRC they did this with the Boeing trains until the Meltdown and Bredas) in order to utilize the whole station length. Or shrink and simplify the MUNI parts, there's no (apparent to a rube like me) reason MUNI stations have to be the same length as BART stations. Make 'em a single block long with NYC style foyers: attendant, turnstiles, ticket machines. No flowers, no coffee, no Jehovah's Witness tables.
- diebeforei485 6y agoYeah. BART was meant to be driverless so they could have many frequent trains (possibly with fewer cars) instead of infrequent 10-car trains.
- mistrial9 6y agoin the earliest days of the BART, I believe I saw the BART train doors open on the wrong side of the train, at the Rockridge station. Also those dumb LED destination signs by DAKtronics lasted decades; some may still be in place.
- jcrawfordor 6y agoMuni's very long platforms at underground stations are largely a coincidence of history. The Muni stations on the Market Street Subway are simply the same length as the BART platforms because they were built at the same time in a single cut-and-cover operation. At 710' BART operates some of the longest transit trains in the world, but due to the construction process making the Muni platforms shorter probably wouldn't have netted significant savings. The underground stations between the Market Street Subway and the Twin Peaks Tunnel, like Castro, were built similarly to the Market Street Subway stations since the length would allow for double-platforming or possibly longer trains - although they are not quite as long (Castro incidentally has an unusual curved platform just because of the practicality of squeezing it in between the older Twin Peaks tunnel and Market St). Like many surface lightrail systems, the total length of Muni trains is limited by the intersection spacing of the surface streets it operates on, among other factors - the train needs to be able to stop without blocking adjacent intersections. Full double-platform operation of Muni trains on the Market Street Subway has been on and off over the years with changes in station operations and controls, I believe it is currently on at least at Embarcadero. There have been technical (related to the ATC) and procedural problems (people waiting at the wrong position and having to run) that have made double-platform operation tricky. I also think the gains in efficiency by double-platforming are fairly modest since the throughput of the Market Street Subway has long been limited by signalling considerations.
- jeffbee 6y agoYou should see the plans for the BART station in San Jose. There will be pointless mezzanine, of course. The excavation will be the size of an airport. It's completely ridiculous. There are S-Bahn stations in Switzerland with 10 times the daily riders of BART that are nothing more than a signpost and a place to stand. The American obsession with gargantuan stations serving a couple thousand daily riders costs a lot of money. https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/29/barts-san-jose-extension-is-woefully-delayed-and-the-hardest-part-is-still-to-come/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/29/barts-san-jose-extens...
- cossray 6y agoThe obsession is not just with stations;everything is bigger over there. My first visit to the US, I was traveling from Japan. The difference in size of things in the two countries is uncanny. From people to cars to food;my impression was Americans like it bigger.
- brigandish 6y agoIsn't that because of the obvious - Americans generally are bigger than Japanese people and America is bigger than Japan? I'm not sure it's a preference as much as an adjustment.
- brigandish 6y agoI suppose I'm destined to wander around my small(er than most other places in the world) Japanese flat, with fittings made for someone much shorter than I am even though I'm average height in my own country, and ponder on the existence of downvotes for a fairly innocuous musing. Perhaps I should leave comments like "Japanese people just like things smaller because when I was there everything was so small" and not notice that they have a lack of space and are on average, smaller, hence the need for space saving measures and smaller fittings, or is that just one more, in my opinion, fairly innocuous musing that must not be stated… maybe it's just me? Maybe.[1][2] しょうがない [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ezwox3YfyoU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ezwox3YfyoU [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5glLhvj4yd4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5glLhvj4yd4
- andjd 6y agoNo offense, but this sounds like the reaction of someone who doesn't actually use the subway to get around. The older stations in NYC are cramped and _dangerous_ because they're too small to handle the foot traffic heading through on a good day without delays. The new 2nd avenue subway stations are similarly large, and I can personally attest that this scale, which seems frivolous to you, makes life tangibly better for the commuters who rely on this infrastructure every day.
- jrockway 6y agoIt really goes either way. The IND stations are great with their trademark full-length mezzanines. Sometimes, the mezzanine wasn't needed, though; a lot of them are just flat-out abandoned on the G. My takeaway from this is that careful planning and analysis is necessary to decide what sort of station design is required. There is no one-size-fits-all answer, as many replies suggest there is, so it's not obvious to me that the MTA screwed this up.
- m463 6y agoI believe the Russians have some pretty amazing stations.
- xvilka 6y agoMoscow metro builds now with cheaper but less artistic stations, to build as much as possible as fast as possible. Nevertheless, even these new stations are practical enough since the Moscow metro can be quite cramped at times.
- spaetzleesser 6y ago“bonkers expensive station design.” Sounds a little like American healthcare. Either super expensive but shiny care or either nothing or subpar care. No reasonable middle. I always wonder why all hospitals have to be super new with new devices.
- zdragnar 6y agoWe choose which hospital to go to (barring an emergency) but aren't able to know what the cost of services will be; most human nature in that case will prefer to go to the one that looks better, as a proxy for more likely to get the right outcome. A recent executive order by the president will force hospitals to reveal their pricing, but I'm not sure if that applies to actual negotiated prices for various insurance plans, or only to the phoney prices that they use for negotiating and noone actually pays. Either way, a small ray of hope that things will change for the better soon.
- aschatten 6y agoIt seems pretty ordinary compared to metro stations in Europe or even Eastern Europe.