20 ms·
This blows my mind. I know, it's much more incremental than it is revolutionary, but I think the form factor achieves a much greater degree of access for many p
by ineedasername 6y ago
This blows my mind. I know, it's much more incremental than it is revolutionary, but I think the form factor achieves a much greater degree of access for many people than a typical Pi whose bare hardware may be a lot more intimidating. Now, it's "just" a computer, which happens to expose a 40-pin connector for the standard Pi hardware fun. And unlike other options you might find, this has the massive built-in community that comes with Pi
It reminds me of what Apple does when it redefines a product category by "just" bringing together existing technology into a more convenient form factor and UX.
I don't know if this will quite have that level of impact, but I see the potential, especially now with remote learning: My kids are on a hybrid schedule. I'm fortunate to be able to provide them their necessary computing resources. Not everyone can: The district couldn't secure all of the necessary Chrome Books, and some students have been left attempting remote learning via their parent's phone, or simply left behind. A cheap mass market device has some truly amazing potential to fill in these gaps at the same time that it enables more advanced S(T)EM learning than you could get with a typical cheap Chrome Book.
I'm also old enough to remember when you'd be hard pressed to find a desktop computer for under $1000, perhaps $1500 adjusted for inflation. One for $70-$100 really just hammers home how far we've come.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoDoes Chrome OS run on Raspberry Pi? How crazy is it that one of the Big Players come in, port their OS to the device, and more or less take it over as just another platform with a Start Menu?
- dunnevens 6y agoThere's a way to make Chrome OS run on Pi's, but it's insecure. Uses the Fyde version of Chromium OS. https://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?t=227281 https://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?t=227281
- ant6n 6y agoWeil that support the Linux add-on inside Chrome OS?
- flohofwoe 6y agoAt that point, why not just run Linux? The official OS (Raspberry Pi OS) is a regular Debian-based Linux distro: https://www.raspberrypi.org/downloads/raspberry-pi-os/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/downloads/raspberry-pi-os/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- holtalanm 6y agonot sure but CloudReady might run on it: https://www.neverware.com/freedownload#intro-text https://www.neverware.com/freedownload#intro-text
- fouric 6y agoAre you talking about Microsoft/Windows or Google/Chrome OS here? They're both Big Players, and both trying/would try to take over/appropriate the Raspberry Pi platform.
- TheRealPomax 6y agoI understand the sentiment, but you know that Raspian, Ubuntu, etc. have all had the equivalent of a start menu for years now, right? =)
- dleslie 6y agoManjaro for Pi ships Chromium in a docker image. It works great; Netflix and all.
- ineedasername 6y agoThat would be useful given that many schools are standardizing their distance-learning based on Chrome OS, so (as much as I might want a more open OS) it might help streamline students' experiences on this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jononor 6y agoVery curious to see how the third-party market will build up around this device. For the RPi Single Board Computer there is a lot of products to extend it into all kinds of directions, assuming one is willing to breadboard and maybe solder a bit. With this new PC/keyboard things are opening up even more for casual geeking around, which I think might bring even more people in. If the community picks it up I think it could be very impactful!
- codysan 6y agoIt reminds me of what Apple does when it redefines a product category by "just" bringing together existing technology into a more convenient form factor and UX. That's a wonderful observation. The form factor is as clever as it is logical. Stuff like this makes me really optimistic for the future of Raspberry Pi (and widespread computing!).
- geerlingguy 6y agoIt's one of those designs where you kind of go "ah yes, I thought that would be a good idea". But before you saw it you might never have planned it in your head exactly the way it is. The iPod was like that for me, with its scrolling click wheel. Like getting to the platonic form of a specific type of device. The Pi 400 is the completion of the idea of an educational computer for kids, IMO. It's not going to compete with a Mac mini or anything like that, and the keyboard is likely not going to be anyone's top choice for a 'professional' keyboard. But it's good enough in all the right ways as a general purpose computer.
- paulcarroty 6y ago> the idea of an educational computer for kids Especially for poor kids in Africa/Asia/etc. Hope it will be the "educational iPod" for them.
- ilrwbwrkhv 6y agoand it is british. anecdotally in terms of longevity and development i have seen they do the best job.
- qz2 6y agoAs a British person we tend to tell everyone we do that and people believe it. However it’s not necessarily true. We produced a ridiculously large amount of crap to the point we nearly killed our manufacturing industry. If there’s anything to aspire to its Hewlett Packard’s test and measurement and computing offerings between 1960 and 1990.
- diehunde 6y agoI was talking to some friends who are teachers about remote learning the other day. They were saying many of their students (they work in rural areas) had the devices but no access to internet. It's a very complex issue now with all the restrictions.
- azernik 6y agoDifferent students have different challenges. In urban areas, hardware access can be the limiting factor.
- leoc 6y agoYes, but if hardware is the access problem then clamshell devices with a built-in screen are probably the better solution.
- Robotbeat 6y agoStarlink has just started beta service (without requiring an NDA like the pre-beta service did). ~100Mbps and a competitive 20-40ms latency (although I think sometimes you can get worse as the constellation isn't yet fully deployed... some satellites that have already been launched still haven't fully raised themselves to operational orbit, but this is still a Beta service, so that should be addressed within weeks). It’s spendy at $100/month (which is comparable to other, FAR worse, satellite internet options... and some non-satellite broadband in the US costs this much for worse service), but rural folk should qualify for the rural broadband subsidy which should help a lot. This post shows some unboxing of Starlink: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48297.msg2148953#msg2148953 https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48297.msg2... I’m really excited about these LEO satellite constellations just solving the rural/urban digital divide. As launch costs continue to go down (SpaceX’s partially reusable Falcon 9 has already made a massive difference in making this feasible, about a quarter the marginal launch cost per kg, and Starship should enable an order of magnitude improvement on that) and competition increases (OneWeb has been brought through bankruptcy but is starting to launch again, plus Amazon’s Project Kuiper and the potential of launching on the partially reusable New Glenn), it’s an exciting time for the ending of digital poverty in rural areas.
- cactus2093 6y ago> The district couldn't secure all of the necessary Chrome Books, and some students have been left attempting remote learning via their parent's phone, or simply left behind. A cheap mass market device has some truly amazing potential to fill in these gaps at the same time that it enables more advanced S(T)EM learning than you could get with a typical cheap Chrome Book. How many households in this situation have an extra monitor lying around to plug this into, or even a proper desk to have a desktop computer set up on? Plus they'll need a separate webcam (and I'm guessing finding one that just works out of the box on Raspbian without fiddling around with drivers and such could be non-trivial). This new Pi form factor is kinda clever but surely a $200-$300 chromebook or tablet is still significantly more accessible. And how does a desktop enable more advanced STEM learning than a laptop?
- jvanderbot 6y agoOh, I don't know if it takes a lot of imagination to see how a desktop like this one enables more advanced stem learning. The I/O ports, low form factor for portability, the raspbian ecosystem and so on.
- sbuk 6y agoI'd assert that TV's are commonplace. This, just like the BBC Micro, ZX80/1 and C64, can easily be used with a TV.
- leoc 6y agoThe reason that the old '80s microcomputers were often plugged into TVs was that monitors were too expensive. Sharing the TV with every other device and person in the house was a necessary evil. TV-hogging is probably about as problematic now as it was then, while displays are much less expensive. So including a screen makes much more sense for a low-cost access-to-computing device these days.
- rini17 6y agoIt's not so problematic today, there are multiple TVs in most families now. And old functioning, like, 1280*1024 LCD monitors can be had for free.
- zoomablemind 6y agoI understand the value proposition of Pi platform. It's definitely popular with quite educated audience in developed countries. However, is Pi offering indeed reaching out to the developing countries? Are there any sources that substantiate the adoption of Pi platform in such communities, especially whether there're any lasting effects beyond the inaugural opening and ribbon-cutting, so to speak? It's tempting to seek the BBC Micro effect from Pi platform, and I hope it can be achieved. Still, one needs to keep in mind that such effect largely was a result of a government policy which supported wide adoption.
- dleslie 6y agoLeaving aside developing countries for a moment; I know, personally, multiple game developers who have switched to using RPi4 and Pinebooks as their personal computing devices. They hit this sweet spot of just enough power to be useful, yet totally silent (with a Flirc case on the Pi). The RPi3b just wasn't quite there yet in terms of speed, but the 4 can easily drive dual monitors and provide enough oompf to be useful in a game jam. Quite a nice little device for hobby development.
- colordrops 6y agoDoes zoom work with the pi? If it came with a camera it would sell like hotcakes.
- geerlingguy 6y agoYes, it's not perfect (mostly slow, and sometimes you have to try a few times to get both camera and audio working), but I got it working with my Logitech C920, and also with a Pi-zero + HQ Camera webcam that I set up using https://github.com/geerlingguy/pi-webcam https://github.com/geerlingguy/pi-webcam
- baq 6y ago...I don't know. I mean, I've had an Atari 65XE myself when I was a kid, but tvs are much bigger nowadays, less accessible and HDMI cables are much more difficult to run through the room (stiffness and length limits are real issues); OTOH keyboards and mice are easy to come by. The hard part of the Pi is the display. The kit also doesn't include a cam nor a headset, nor even a mic. This is super important for online learning. Maybe you could fit in a mic in the keyboard somewhere? A Pi all-in-one (iPi if you excuse me) or a Pi-book in an affordable price range would be revolutionary. I have an old VGA-only monitor but guess what - no D-SUB on the Pi 400 and a proper dongle would be another... $30? As is, nostalgia value is super-high but I don't feel it's as practical as one would hope without any kind of display.
- pharke 6y agoI don't know if the monitor is as big of an issue, a quick search on walmart.com yields their cheapest option at $69.99 for a 19". That's if you have to buy one new. I'm sure the local craigslist would have second hand TVs with HDMI in. A lot of households already have multiple, cheap flatscreens. If we narrow the discussion to only those who cannot afford or do not have any of the above then I think we're also talking about the same group of people that would not be able to afford the Pi400 at its current price. It would be more beneficial (and probably cheaper) to focus on making aid available for them to obtain what they need rather than redesigning the system. The webcam is a different issue, there doesn't appear to be much for a plug and play option for the Pi. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong. If these were to be used as an option for remote education, I would hope that the same organization promoting them would also sell a kit with the system preconfigured to use an included webcam.
- steffan 6y agoEven though it's not included (and supplies are incredibly constrained right now for new ones) a standard USB webcam can work. Logically it doesn't really make sense to include a built-in webcam for a keyboard form factor. Adding an external one doesn't make sense in terms of meeting their pricing goals. Doubtless one of the resellers will augment this with a package that includes an inexpensive USB webcam.
- cbozeman 6y agoMy first computer was a CRT monitor / tower bundle from Sam's Club (back when it really was a warehouse club). 15" CTX monitor with a Pentium 75 mHz CPU, 8 MB of RAM, 540 MB hard drive, and I believe a 2 or 4x CD-ROM. Of course, it had a 3.5" drive. $1499. In 1994.
- evo_9 6y agoRegarding the price you mentioned... this is awesome because it reminds me of the old Atari/Commodores you could buy at a store like K-Mart for $200-500 bucks. Which, granted, back then was a lot more than $70 now. I wonder how many programmers lives this thing will start like those old 8-bits did back-in-the-day.
- samstave 6y agoA couple things - I worked at intel during the time we were trying to prove a sub-$1000 PC was even possible (hence celeron).... But you know what would be really interesting with these guys - is if they would auto-hive once online - and would just have access to whatever apps were avail - say, you pick a role or profile (switchable) for the unit... "e-learning box" or "games" or "news" or "community" such roles/profiles And it would join that hive and then auto pkg whatever apps it needed to to provide access to those communities or content...
- an_opabinia 6y agoOld iPhone hardware probably has a BOM less than $100. Giving students a $100 phone + $10/mo of cell internet access for 9mos out of the year pays bigger dividends. Besides the longest essay you have to write on the ACT, SAT or AP tests is about 300 words. You can do that on a phone - kids do it now on paper. What if kids cram tests on their phones for a few hours then read books the rest of the day? Maybe take your phone outside. Sounds like a decent enough curriculum to me. Anyway my point is you don’t really need a keyboard in education. And with that the logic of this stuff as an educational policy kind of goes away.
- gmadsen 6y agoThat seems horribly misguided. and education should really be separated from the entire phone mobile ecosystem with all the behavioral manipulation that it entails
- garyrob 6y ago"I'm also old enough to remember when you'd be hard pressed to find a desktop computer for under $1000, perhaps $1500 adjusted for inflation." I'm old enough to remember buying a 40MB hard drive for $4,000 (about $9,600 after adjusting for inflation).
- dheera 6y agoI wish it had a trackpoint device in the middle instead of a separate mouse. That way everything would be in one box. One less thing to carry around.
- yellowapple 6y agoOr better yet, a built-in trackball like on some IBM/Unicomp keyboards.
- thom 6y agoAre there patent reasons this can’t be the case?
- _ph_ 6y agoUnlikely, as Thinkpads had this for ages, any patent would have to be expired long ago.
- tlrobinson 6y agoI wonder if they’ll come out with a tablet or laptop form factor. Remember OLPC? It was painfully slow, but that was more than 10 years ago. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OLPC_XO https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OLPC_XO
- musicale 6y ago> I wonder if they’ll come out with a tablet or laptop form factor. Seems like you could just repurpose a cheap android tablet... > Remember OLPC? It was painfully slow, but that was more than 10 years ago. OLPC may not have been a hit itself, but it seemed to usher in an era of inexpensive low-powered-but-still-useful PCs.
- rhizome 6y agoThere was a stretch when you had Gateway, eMachines, Dell (et al) in competition that could have resulted in machines that cheap if the market for desktops hadn't died (relatively). But even now Dell's lowest-end desktop is $350, and that's with an i3. I wouldn't be surprised if that's an engineered price point because lesser hardware at lower prices can't even be shipped and make a profit. And frankly, if I remember back 10-15 years, there were $350 boxes back then, too, so maybe it's a minimum price/rule of thumb that was calculated a long time ago.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoThere's also the second hand market. My first PC was a used Compaq. Weighed about 50 lbs too.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoBack in 1988 or so in Norway when me and my brother got our first computer an Amiga 1000, that costs about $2200 adjusted for inflation. And salaries where lower then. It would have been impossible to buy without a generous "donation" by my grand parents which had quite some savings. And back then salaries where much lower even adjusted for inflation. That Amiga had 256 KB of RAM. This Raspberry is just a beast in comparison to what me and my brother had and it costs 31x LESS, in a world where salaries are higher than back then. I can see this opening up a lot of opportunities for families and schools in less affluent countries. Maybe even businesses. I can imagine various famers and small businesses out in the countryside in Africa or India could benefit from a computer like this to lookup market information for crops, plan budgets, savings, purchases etc.