3 ms·
It’s better to do one of these: (a) downvote and move on, the parent comment has a lot of hallmarks of not engaging in good faith discussion. (b) steelman the
by mlthoughts2018 6y ago
It’s better to do one of these:
(a) downvote and move on, the parent comment has a lot of hallmarks of not engaging in good faith discussion.
(b) steelman their argument, improve it for them and see what conclusions are or further predictions it would indicate
(c) look for evidence that confirms it first. Saying something like, “I tried to research your claim but I only found FOO, which does not include any reputable or credible sources. Meanwhile, reputable sources like BAR have said <whatever>,” is much gentler and diplomatic as well as adding new information for other participants.
Other people will see the comment and realize it has no supporting argument. Any rebutting comment that only says “citation needed, your claims are extreme” isn’t helpful no matter how obviously poor quality the original comment was.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoMy prior on this is that it's probably incorrect. However, it's possible that I am wrong, and the OP may provide sources that change my mind. The most likely outcome is no reply, but that suits me fine as reasonable observers will conclude that there isn't any evidence.