10 ms·
David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics
- ymzbhx94 6y agoDavid Shor could have used a study that looked outside the us.
- rayiner 6y ago> And I think the real synthesis of these views is that Obama-to-Trump voters are motivated by racism. Hmm. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/18/opinion/biden-latino-vote-strategy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/18/opinion/biden-latino-vote... > We began by asking eligible voters how “convincing” they found a dog-whistle message lifted from Republican talking points... Almost three out of five white respondents judged the message convincing. More surprising, exactly the same percentage of African-Americans agreed, as did an even higher percentage of Latinos. These numbers do not translate directly into support for the Republican Party; too many other factors are at play. Nevertheless, the results tell us something important: a majority across the groups we surveyed did not repudiate Trump-style rhetoric as obviously racist and divisive, but instead agreed with it. Shor makes basically the same error as the authors of the New York Times piece above: assuming that opposing immigration and supporting law-and-order are inherently “racist” views. Progressives need to ask themselves: is opposition to abolishing ICE (to use one of Schor’s examples) actually “racist?” Because if they just run with the assumption that it’s racist, they’ll force themselves into taking an incredibly unpopular position. As Shor himself points out, the people running the campaigns are ideologically progressive. Even if polling shows that abolishing ICE is incredibly unpopular, so long as they accept the premise that it’s the anti-racist thing to do, they will support it (or the far left will make them support it). This was basically the story of the 2019 Democratic primaries, where nearly every candidate embraced incredibly unpopular issues out of fear of being “called out.” And “demographic destiny” won’t eventually vindicate progressives’ all-consuming view of racism. As the New York Times article above explains, a message focused around racial identity and the idea of pervasive “white supremacy” (like Elizabeth Warren ran in the 2019 Democratic Primary) actually polls poorly among Latinos (who are now the largest non-white group in the electorate). Meanwhile, Trump’s polling is up 100% among Black people and 60% among Hispanic people under 45 compared to 2016: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-is-losing-ground-with-white-voters-but-gaining-among-black-and-hispanic-americans https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-is-losing-ground-.... If Republicans can convert that into votes, states like Texas and Georgia will stay solidly red. Shor is ultimately right. Democrats need to get back white voters in a country that will be 50%+ white for the foreseeable future. Because in the long run non-white voters aren’t as much of a lock as they assume. But they really need to introspect about why they would ever have thought otherwise to begin with.
- irrational 6y agoWhat do you mean by demographic destiny? I assume that means something like, over time the demographic makeup of society will come to look more and more like "college-educated coastal progressives"? Do people really believe that? If so, that is hard to believe. "College-educated coastal progressives" tend to have few or no children compared to the "majority of the country". It would seem the demographic makeup will go in the opposite direction.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bumbledraven 6y ago> What do you mean by demographic destiny? Presumably he means the same thing CNN means by it. https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/01/politics/election-2020-trump-choice-past-future/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/01/politics/election-2020-trump-... (emphasis mine): “It happened four years ago when Donald Trump scored an Electoral College victory with his turn-back-the-clock campaign to Make America Great Again. He'll have trouble pulling it off again. That's partly because the pace of demographic change keeps shrinking the America Trump evokes in the rear-view mirror.”
- salamimonger 6y agoI love how acceptable it is to brag about how eventually white people in the US will be outpopulated by non-white people who we assume will all vote Democrat. How would the reaction be if the mainstream media was bragging about white people outbirthing Mexicans in Mexico and soon taking over their politics? Note: I'm not white btw so don't @ me, just making an observation
- obscoth 6y agoMaybe it would be less acceptable if white people hadn’t produced so many atrocities against nonwhites. I don’t feel sorry for them.
- 6y ago
- cwp 6y agoWow. This guy is a really strange combination of brilliant and clueless.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoHe’s a Jew. He’s only pretending to be retarded.
- sideshowb 6y agoCare to outline what you think is clueless?
- cwp 6y agoLots of little things that suggest Shor is so deep into politics he can't remember what a regular person is like. For example: The single biggest way that highly educated people who follow politics closely are different from everyone else is that we have much more ideological coherence in our views. If you decided to create a survey scorecard, where on every single issue — choice, guns, unions, health care, etc. — you gave people one point for choosing the more liberal of two policy options... He completely misses the fact that the liberal-conservative spectrum we see in American politics is pretty arbitrary and has more to do with tribalism then ideological coherence. For example, it would be "ideologically coherent" to be both pro-life and pro-gun-control. Or concerned about climate change and pro-nuclear-power. Or anti-racism and anti-immigration. So his conclusion is wrong. Highly educated people who follow politics are not more ideologically coherent, they're more ideologically conformist. Another example: At some point, you have to be like, oh, actually, these people were motivated by racism. It’s just an important fact of the world ... Who's he talking about? Obama-Trump voters. He's looking at this sophisticated polling where they ask questions designed to probe for "racial resentment" and seeing no other way to interpret them. Ok... so why did they vote for Obama? Were they motivated by racism then? Did their motivation change between elections? These aren't rhetorical questions; I have no idea why Obama-Trump voters made those choices. But Shor is so deep in the numbers he can't see that his conclusion is nonsense.
- 6y ago
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoThank G-d that two seconds of searching was all it took to confirm that David Shor is a filthy Jew. I see no reason to read whatever nonsense his diseased kike mind has produced other than to verify that the opposite of whatever he’s saying is definitely the truth.
- rendall 6y agoFrom the article: But a lot of people on the Clinton campaign tricked themselves into the idea that they didn’t have to placate the social views of racist white people. This seems like a pretty important insight and I really wish the interview could have unpacked this a lot better. It seems to be an operating assumption of the Democratic campaign, and I imagine if one is locked into this view (by implacable statistical analysis), then it would be really difficult to hear any other concern as anything but dog-whistling racism. While Shor did somewhat outline his thinking, it would be nice to be able to follow this trail to see why, exactly From the article: There’s a paper by the political scientist David Broockman that made this point really famous — that “moderate” voters don’t have moderate views, just ideologically inconsistent ones. The words a paper in that quote links not to the paper itself, but to a Vox interview, from which all links are to a draft paper that 404. I would like to read this paper for myself, but apparently it has been withdrawn I wonder if David Shor is quick to cite papers that support his preconceptions, rather than let the quality of the papers lead him to conclusions? This is why I would like to actually see the results of these polls and such for his first assertion.
- nyanpasu64 6y agoTook a while to find, but "How Ideological Moderation Conceals Support for Immoderate Policies: A New Perspective on the “Disconnect” in American Politics" http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.688.8618&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.688...
- rendall 6y agoThanks. Oof. 54 pages is no joke. It will take me some time to absorb it
- sideshowb 6y agoI'd like to see that paper too if you find it. Over in the UK, Cummings credits his win of the Brexit campaign to a similar insight about "moderates". (Oh and there's a PG blog on the topic too).
- 6y ago
- insickness 6y agoThis article gives a perfect, if unintentional synopsis of why Trump is in power. The left has embraced hook-line-and-sinker Critical Theory and Identity Politics. All power and victimhood is seen through the lens of identities, causing the left had to abandon class because it is not an immutable category. The working class abandoned the Democratic party because the party abandoned the working class and then poured salt onto their abandonment by shaming them as racist/sexist/homophobe, etc.
- casept 6y agoWhen was the democratic party ever truly "left"? My impression of them is that they were arguably mildly SocDem in the past, and then turned into (neo)liberals in the 90's. Liberals are not leftists.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoSame as the Labour party in the UK, and the Labor party in Australia. While the politicians might be socialist, the parties are definitely centre-left neo-liberal.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI think you are on spot with that assessment and it might even happen again since the strategy is mostly unchanged. A bit sad to see what the author believes about his countrymen and he doesn't seem to have noticed that many of those already picked up on them while even having fewer prejudices.
- webmaven 6y ago> All power and victimhood is seen through the lens of identities, causing the left [...] to abandon class because it is not an immutable category. I don't think that really captures the motivation or pressure to stop talking about class. Rather, class in the US is really really messy (compared to, say, Britain, where despite the additional complications of social vs. economic class, you can describe yourself as 'lower upper middle class', and be understood), and the fact that speaking about class at all got you branded as communist (in the past), or socialist (currently), or elitist (always). America is largely branded as a classless society rather than trying to get to grips with class. Confusing the issue even more is the denigration on the right of "coastal elites" that are largely middle class. As far as US political rhetoric is concerned, socialism seems to be the new communism. Meanwhile, though speaking using the lens of racism isn't exactly easy (eg. "That's racist!" "No, you're the racist!"), it is at least somewhat possible. Is it any wonder that politicians on the (US) left don't talk about class? Confusing your audience isn't exactly going to win elections. They can talk about creating jobs and inequality, but that's about it.
- Tomminn 6y agoThis is interesting from the perspective of showing a particular ideological blindness very, very clearly. He claims that Obama to Trump voters are motivated by racism and cannot see any problem with the idea that a racist would vote for a black man to have the most powerful job in the world. If that is something a racist can do in your categorization of the world, than juuuuust maybe your categories are broken. Otherwise we're in a world where racists would happily pick Barack Hussein Obama over Mitt freaking Romney, but couldn't bring themselves to pick Hillary over Trump.