3 ms·
> Over the years, it has been a waste of time to explain ourselves why we need to charge for our labor. This is the last time I say anything about this. Trolls
by robertlagrant 6y ago
> Over the years, it has been a waste of time to explain ourselves why we need to charge for our labor. This is the last time I say anything about this. Trolls will be blocked.
How badly does someone need to misunderstand a topic to write something like this? No one mentioned charging being bad.
- Latty 6y agoThe fact they claimed it was a complete rewrite shows they don't misunderstand: they knew they were doing something wrong and tried to hide it, just now they are caught they are just trying to gaslight their way out and claim they are the victim here. I absolutely buy some people were shitty about them deciding to create a commercial product. That in no way justifies stealing from others who contributed to the project, which is the reality here.
- jhardy54 6y ago> I absolutely buy some people were shitty about them deciding to create a commercial product. That in no way justifies stealing from others who contributed to the project, which is the reality here. 100x this. I'm super supportive of them making a living via a commercial product, especially one based on AGPL code. My only frustration is that they're pretending that it isn't AGPL code and refusing to respect the contributors whose code they're using.
- mehrdadn 6y ago> My only frustration is that they're pretending that it isn't AGPL code and refusing to respect the contributors whose code they're using. But what I don't get is: how do you even know this with such confidence? How do you know they don't have some legal agreement with those people? How do you even know they didn't contact those contributors? How do you know the other contributors' contributions weren't trivial enough (for all I know they could've even just been formatting/indentation) and not warranting any action? How do you know the contributors aren't fine with it? And how does everyone somehow know other contributors want them to seek some sort of justice on their behalf?
- gspr 6y agoSuppose what you're saying were true. Why would then this buunguyen respond to the GH issue in this way? Why go on the offensive, calling people trolls? Why lie about having rewritten the code? If what you say is true, he could simply say so. This is not the behavior of an innocent person respecting the software's license. It's the behavior of a very guilty person. Or a clown. Or both.
- mehrdadn 6y agoI don't know, I don't think either is impossible, but let's say they are guilty. I repeat my question: how does anyone here know the contributors aren't fine with this regardless (maybe they don't feel their contributions were minor enough not to justify casting a spotlight on them, raising a public feud over a trivial issue, and cancelling this guy)? How does everyone here somehow know the contributors want vigilante justice? It's as if we're trying to play out https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/ except we're replacing "wrong" with "violating someone else's copyright"...
- totony 6y agoA deleted comment in the github issue was a contributor stating that they didn't know but didn't care. It's fair for people to not like this because the contributors were not made aware of this. Thus the only people who were wronged did not even know of it.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> maybe they don't feel their contributions were minor enough not to justify casting a spotlight on them, raising a public feud over a trivial issue That sounds like bullying. That wouldn't be okay either. Even if they would actually be fine with it, a ticket saying "ask them!" is a valid issue.
- jhardy54 6y ago> But what I don't get is: how do you even know this with such confidence? Because instead of saying "yes it's based on the AGPL code, I have consent" they're saying "no it's not based on the AGPL code, it's a complete rewrite", which is an easily provable lie. The minified JavaScript has tons of 1:1 copies of the AGPL code, clear as day (example: https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecomment-719980414 https://github.com/christianbundy/octotree/issues/1#issuecom...), and the maintainer is deleting any comment that mentions the clear evidence.
- mistrial9 6y agoGUESS -there are two ways to make money: charge for something; avoid paying others. The original Octotree author, thinking of business as a whole, blurred the ideas of "we charge for our product" and "we pay nothing to anyone"