6 ms·
People say the sam thing about ad-tech today. They even using the exact same phase: "Entire generations of the best and brightest". But look at the innovation
by jedberg 6y ago
People say the sam thing about ad-tech today. They even using the exact same phase: "Entire generations of the best and brightest".
But look at the innovation that comes from both endeavors and leaks out into the rest of society. Arguably computer technology would not be where it is without the war machine driving the initial innovation.
And similarly, web technology, such as Javascript and just the ability to update a webpage without reloading it wouldn't exist without ad-tech.
- citizenkeen 6y ago> And similarly, web technology, such as Javascript and just the ability to update a webpage without reloading it wouldn't exist without ad-tech. I don't know what I find more depressing - that somebody thinks this is true, or worse, that somebody thinks this is a good thing.
- jedberg 6y agoWe can debate whether or not javascript took off because of adtech, I will concede that. But I think you'd be hard pressed to provide evidence that the web would be better without Javascript. Yes, people abuse javascript and make it do awful things, but think about all the good things Javascript enables. On reddit, you can comment without reloading the page thanks to javascript. There are ton of great games that are all in javascript. Simple things like when you log into a webpage and it shows your username in the corner. Status notification on webpages. Being able to make a request and then continue working while the request processes. Javascript is a tool, and I'd say it's a tool that makes things better overall.
- UweSchmidt 6y agoIt's of course subjective, but I've recently rediscovered an old browser-based game from around 2000, pure PHP, zero javascript, zero development in a decade. Just fast-loading websites representing an updated game-state of travelling through space, mining and fighting in real time. Perfect. If you comment on reddit, don't you watch the page to confirm your comment went up? So not necessarily a productivity gain through Javascript. Conscious reloading is nice as there is no distraction: You take an action to see new state like login, new messages and notifications. Again, totally subjective. There were plenty of games made with Flash, so game dev tools were developed independent of ad-tech.
- fastball 6y agoThere is no possible way you are seeing something happen "in real time" on a web game written entirely in PHP.
- UweSchmidt 6y agoOf course not, the page is static, but the game runs in real time on the server, so you could be in danger and have to refresh/move to find out. The point is, and it is subtle, you never get distracted by a website and some self-updating elements until you decide to pay attention and take some action (refresh). It works and is very simple.
- derivagral 6y agoI assume this is oGame or similar? When I was in high school I had a lot of fun learning Javascript/HTML in the console & TamperMonkey to create shortcut menus, faster actions, track area activity, etc. The modern versions of these use a lot more Javascript for countdown timers, and while that's nice the pages usually feel slower.
- PopePompus 6y agoI think it's the financial sector, not ad-tech that's wasting the abilities of many bright people, at least in the USA.
- jedberg 6y agoFintech pays better, but it seems like most new grads would rather go to FAANG, which in the case of GAF means adtech.
- goatinaboat 6y agowhich in the case of GAF means adtech I've lost track, which is A now? Only Facebook and Google are adtech, Apple wants to sell hardware and Amazon wants to do retail, adtech/surveillance capitalism could be banned tomorrow and both the A's would not skip a beat.
- jedberg 6y agoAmazon is an adtech company. 25% of their revenue came from ads in 2020.
- angott 6y agoAdtech is a major driver of growth for AWS products. See https://aws.amazon.com/advertising-marketing/ https://aws.amazon.com/advertising-marketing/. Amazon retail business also uses targeted advertising as part of their ad network: https://advertising.amazon.com/products/sponsored-display https://advertising.amazon.com/products/sponsored-display
- mindslight 6y agoIt's not either-or, it's all of the above. Military, commercial surveillance ("adtech"), finance, healthcare, legal, institutional administration. None of these things are entirely useless, but are still mostly zero-sum or redundant waste. Technological progress is continually making us more productive, but instead of realizing the gains (eg full time employment being under 10 hours per week by now), our economy is structured to keep creating endless make-work jobs. We're trapped in a paperclip maximizer for human labor.
- MontyCarloHall 6y agoI’d love to see a thorough analysis on the technological externalities of the Cold War. How many decades would we be set back technologically if it never happened? I’d say at least 20 years.
- mzkply 6y agoI thought Microsoft invented xhtml no-refresh tech just for web outlook no?
- c22 6y agoPerhaps not, but a world without computers would be markedly different from the world we live in, whereas a world without Javascript and the ability to update a webpage without reloading it would be... pretty much just like the world we're living in now, except perhaps less annoying.
- bpodgursky 6y agoMost of the big-data processing stack (Hadoop, Spark, Tez, HBase etc) only really exists because adtech companies needed to process mountains of garbage logs and cookie data in daily batch jobs. So they developed big-data libraries capable of it. But those technologies are now used pretty widely across the whole tech industry, including in the hard sciences.
- chasd00 6y agoand don't forget. The internet porn industry pretty much invented the streaming video tech. we all take for granted. In fact, there use to be a saying that no Internet innovation can be considered a success until it has been adopted by the online porn industry.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- samoa42 6y agoidk an url of a video file passed to a player worked 20years ago as it does now. "the streaming video tech" integrated the player into the browser to control it and show ads. not much gained imo.
- raverbashing 6y ago> pretty much just like the world we're living in now, except perhaps less annoying. Compare Mapquest vs Google Maps to know why Javascript is important If you don't know what Mapquest was, there's your answer
- Pulcinella 6y agoUhh the web technology predates ad-tech. CERN was not funded by advertising. Also you say no ad-tech would mean a world without JavaScript like it’s a bad thing.
- deeviant 6y agoA world without ad-tech or JavaScript, tell me more of this Utopia.
- mpclark 6y agoThe way I heard it, Cern could be considered to be indirectly financed by the war machine as it was essentially provided as a playground for Europe’s atomic scientists to stop any one nation running away with the ball.
- iguy 6y agoYes there is some truth in this, I think. It seemed entirely plausible (at least to politicians) in the 50s that the scientists might well come up with something else on the scale of the bomb.
- ncmncm 6y agoSimilarly ITER and the whole fusion research project is a jobs program to maintain a population of high-neutron-flux physicists to draw on for weapons work. (There will be no fusion power.) But has anything useful spun off? Maybe plasma dynamics maths. Inertial confinement drove development of short-pulse lasers, which are good for research into chemical reaction dynamics.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoDidn't you know that porn is what drives Internet tech? Some time ago, someone here posted about running the infrastructure for one of the main pr0n sites, and it was crazy cool. It wasn't "cutting edge," but it was incredibly well-engineered and robust.
- jedberg 6y agoYes, porn has always been a big driver of entertainment technology. Some would say the same things about porn resource usage as they do about adtech. :)
- ncmncm 6y agoMissed it. Link?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'll look for it... This might be it (not sure): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23976449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23976449
- anonu 6y agoJavascript was created for/because of ad tech? Source?
- pilsetnieks 6y agoIf anything, I'd attribute the popularity of (client-side) Javascript to the iPhone for inspiring the industry to kill off Flash, and iOS has to be the most hostile (relatively) OS to advertising.
- jedberg 6y agoNo it wasn't created for ad tech, but it really took off because of ad tech.
- chasd00 6y agoin my mind, it was whoever decided to start using XMLHttpRequest and then jquery that made people start looking closer at Javascript. Prior to those two things, Javascript was not taken seriously at all.
- nitwit005 6y agoThe innovations that have come out of military efforts are impressive, but can seem a bit limited if you realize just how vast military spending can be. I suspect we'd have made decades of progress if we'd truly dumped all the funds spent on military efforts in the 20th century into research. Not to mention the lost opportunity cost of making millions of people have the occupation of soldier, rather than something more productive.
- jedberg 6y agoMost of the ex soldiers I know transformed for the better in the army. Admittedly this is selection bias, because all the ones I know now work in tech. But the ones that do, learned leadership and teamwork in the army. So it did at least help those people.
- nitwit005 6y agoSure, it's not a total loss obviously. It's just less productive than other options. You can always create a civilian training program with the same sort of structure as a military program if that's worthwhile.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoCan you? If people agree that it would be useful, and that it would be more productive otherwise, why doesn't it already exist?
- nitwit005 6y agoThere are military schools all over the world. Some of them are to prepare students for actual military service, but others are just trying to have the same sort of dicipline. But generally people don't seem to view it as the most effective form of education. The time spent on any military discipline or studies is time taken away from some other subject.
- 6y ago
- UweSchmidt 6y agoThe war machine brought about some tangible technological achievements (although of course in an incredibly wasteful process), but even more, the arms race was driven by technological progress in civilian economy: all improvements and inventions of civilian economy had to be put into military equipment and forced new generations of planes, tanks, guns. Market based economies and state sponsored science are pretty solid at bringing about progress and the trillions in military spending that could have reasonably been saved since WW2 would have have lifted all boats and would have provided money for better education, telescopes, particle accelerators and many other things we can't even conceptualize, since so many ressources were squandered. And regarding ad-tech: similar thing. All that money that goes into it is paid for by us through the products we buy, plus we are manipulated by it so our decisions are all worse. Do away with it and we would have better things all around.
- angry_octet 6y agoThere are many things which the US brought into being, which could not have been achieved commercially, as the ROI is too far away and dilute. The military has long term objectives and spending priority like nothing else -- except perhaps NASA in the 1950-1970 period, and even that was tied up with the space race and the military. We certainly would not have GPS, 20cm satellite imaging and many other things. Culturally, humans are short term focused. It takes a big abstraction tied to real core needs to get us to do anything long term. God(s), the tribe, survival, basically sex and death. Ad tech is about tomorrow. Surveillance+capitalism was our only long term bet of late, but I think we're pivoting to systematic mass disinformation.