8 ms·
Interestingly I once had a near-accident with a Waymo car because I had a stop sign and thought it was a 4-way stop (which would mean I got to go first since I
by dheera 6y ago
Interestingly I once had a near-accident with a Waymo car because I had a stop sign and thought it was a 4-way stop (which would mean I got to go first since I stopped first), but it was only a 2-way stop, and the Waymo had right of way.
That's right, in California, 4-way stops aren't [edit: consistently] labelled 4-way, so when you come up to an intersection with a stop sign you need to peek around at the transverse road (sometimes in the dark) to see whether or not they also have a stop sign to know whether it's 2-way or 4-way. All while looking out for cars on both sides.
The Waymo car stopped just in time and there was no accident. Not sure if this was because of the safety driver or because its algorithm had seen and extrapolated my car's motion and actively avoided the collision.
(Or if they are advanced enough, maybe they have mapped out all the stop signs in California and have labelled all the intersections that are 2-way stops in which a driver could accidentally think it's 4-way, and anticipate the possibility of an accident in advance at these dangerous intersections. I doubt that though.)
- denlekke 6y agoanecdotally, all the 4 way stops I encounter in day to day driving in the SF Bay area are labelled as 4 way or all way
- dheera 6y agoI'm in the bay area and adecnotally it has been very inconsistent for me. Here are a few I dug up in just a few minutes of 4-way stops without 4-way labels. This has led me to mostly disregard the absence of a 4-way label as a source of information. San Francisco https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7253706,-122.4072718,3a,75y,103.19h,83.29t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1skJk9td6MYU6CZOR4s8uFXQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7253706,-122.4072718,3a,75y,... Stanford https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4342864,-122.1680113,3a,75y,49.02h,90.9t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sSRKvv6W-XAO-Ab-X3ZJFHQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4342864,-122.1680113,3a,75y,... Palo Alto https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4671732,-122.1480907,3a,90y,11.17h,85.37t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sgEeaL-1mnuIwIrK1QhJNVQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4671732,-122.1480907,3a,90y,... Los Altos https://www.google.com/maps/@37.3977786,-122.1162461,3a,75y,198.2h,86.93t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6MYCs9nM3JkgqPRTHARQBA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.3977786,-122.1162461,3a,75y,... San Jose https://www.google.com/maps/@37.3313026,-121.8797736,3a,75y,166.18h,81.03t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s4-9VlO2eDAz4pkyMMqKT3g!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.3313026,-121.8797736,3a,75y,...
- verytrivial 6y agoI'm "that guy" in my area that reports and tracks and eventually shames-via-local-newspapers anything I find like this (and trash dumping etc.) Maybe you could be that guy too? This seems sort of dangerous.
- dheera 6y agoI could, though I really don't have time to drive around on street view and keep doing this. I found these violations within a few minutes, I'm sure I could spend hours and map out several hundred such intersections. Rather, I would be more interested in mapping out all the violations on a mass scale using neural nets, though I'd want my time funded to do something like that, considering it takes away time I could use to do other things.
- verytrivial 6y agoI hear you. Our time is limited. But I would argue that most good occurs due to many small interventions. And seeing these interventions and the improvements can encourage others to intervene. Maybe reporting these kinds of issues is too hard and that's the problem? Maybe a blog post describing how you just wasted 25 minutes filling out a web form and how a safety issue like this does not look good for the local governance? (This is all really obvious, but I'm clearly just trying to reframe what "that guy" could mean to you and anyone scrolling by :-) )
- linguistbreaker 6y agoBut a good feature and something that human drivers do - I know the sketchy intersections in my town.
- JaggedJax 6y agoThis must be handled by the city or county level as where I live in California there's usually (always?) a little "4 way" sign under the stop sign when it's 4 way. Either way, this should be made consistent across the state and all of them definitely should have it added if they don't.
- dheera 6y agoI wonder if I could get them to pay me a meaningful amount to identify all the intersections that need such a label. Like say, a bounty of $X for each non-compliant intersection or whatever. I think I could automate it with some simple perception neural nets. Or does the government just not give a damn about this kind of stuff ...
- dwwoelfel 6y agoPlease report them in the SF311 app or at https://sf311.org/ https://sf311.org/. They won't pay you any money, but they're very responsive in my experience. Things usually get fixed.
- dheera 6y agoI'm happy to report the few I found to them. To whoever downvoted me: I wasn't suggesting that I would not report the ones I already know without pay, but rather that if I was funded, I would be able to carve out time to write code to find non-compliant intersections on a mass scale.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoHere in Australia sign upgrades or road modifications or both tend to occur either pre-emptively for no apparent reason in an effort to make traffic flow worse, or only after multiple people have died and the local community has been complaining for a decade.
- m463 6y agoUsually there's a yellow sign underneath the stop sign saying "Cross traffic does not stop". I don't know if it's a requirement, but it is common.
- stronglikedan 6y ago> which would mean I got to go first since I stopped first Careful with that. No one has the right-of-way at four-way stops in some (most? all?) states. Whoever enters the intersection first gets the right-of-way. Same reason you have the right-of-way to finish a left turn after your light turns red, if you were already in the intersection waiting for cross-traffic to clear/stop.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoHere in Australia, last time I checked, no one is considered to have right of way. Very one on the road must do everything reasonable to avoid a collision.
- Dylan16807 6y agoThat's not what it means.
- projektfu 6y agoThe “right of way” refers to the road, and it must be yielded to the car stopped simultaneously to the right in the US uniform traffic code.
- ghaff 6y agoBe careful with reliance on what many would consider to be a fairly obscure right-of-way rule. More commonly if it's not clear someone just waves someone else through. It's like depending on people knowing obscure operator precedence :-)
- projektfu 6y agoFollowing my rule, you would always either yield or verify that they have yielded. Seeing a wave can be a good verification. The annoying thing from people not knowing the rule is the “Mississippi standoff” with two cars at a 4 way stop sign waving at each other and not moving. :)
- abduhl 6y agoCaltrans has a readily available copy of their Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices at https://dot.ca.gov/programs/safety-programs/camutcd/camutcd-rev5 https://dot.ca.gov/programs/safety-programs/camutcd/camutcd-... Part 2 is specific to signage. Turn to Part 2B.05: At intersections where all approaches are controlled by STOP signs (see Section 2B.07), an ALL WAY supplemental plaque (R1-3P) shall be mounted below each STOP sign. The ALL WAY plaque (see Figure 2B-1) shall have a white legend and border on a red background. The ALL WAY plaque shall only be used if all intersection approaches are controlled by STOP signs. In other words, the intersections you're running into are not in compliance with the Caltrans MUTCD.
- dheera 6y agoYup, and I run into dozens of non-compliant intersections every day. See my other comment below in which I listed several examples on street view that I dug up within a few minutes.
- abduhl 6y agoI understand, but your comment was: "That's right, in California, 4-way stops aren't labelled 4-way" which is true in practice but not any more useful than saying "4 way stops aren't labelled 4-way anywhere" because some intersections may not be up to code. They are SUPPOSED to be labelled. You can probably get them fixed by reporting it to the local government.
- BurningFrog 6y ago"True in practice" is the real truth!
- dheera 6y agoYup, I made an edit, I should have said "consistently labelled as 4-way"
- sushshshsh 6y agoCan you? I can't even get a driver's license renewed.
- discordance 6y ago4-way intersections in the US have always bothered me. Roundabouts are a much better solution.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI like roundabouts too, but which choice is most appropriate depends on circumstance. The US is big and spacious, which makes spending extra on roundabouts not too appealing in many places. And in some circumstances four-way stops flow more traffic.
- codeka 6y ago> And in some circumstances four-way stops flow more traffic. There's no way that's true, is it? What circumstances would a four way stop sign allow for more traffic flow than a roundabout? I'm pretty sure it's purely cost-cutting. Four way stop signs are extremely cheap compared to roundabouts. There's no other advantage that I can think of. Roundabouts are safer (there is no opportunity for t-boning at a roundabout), faster and simpler to navigate than four way stop signs (a roundabout you just give way to people already on the roundabout, a four way stop sign requires you to keep track of who arrived first and then do a weird dance if you both arrived at the same time, and you still need to watch out for people attempting to go out of turn -- which is not possible with a roundabout)
- nitrogen 6y agoThere's a 6-way roundabout I know of that frequently has one of the 3 intersecting roads dominate the traffic, so people just go full speed from that road. In that case, the other roads can be completely starved, so a 6-way stop would have been better for those roads in those times. As for t-boning, you can definitely have someone enter a roundabout early/late and hit another car on the side, or dart in front of a car that's in the roundabout (especially possible if the roundabout is not perfectly circular) and themselves get hit on the side. And people manage to go "out of turn" in roundabouts all the time, by not yielding, or by tailgating.
- theptip 6y agoThis is one of the worst UI decisions around driving in the US, in my opinion. Even if the "all-way" addendum was displayed below every stop sign without fail, the semantics of those two stop signs are so different as to warrant a different color and shape; if you mistake a "stop[just you]" for a "stop[all way]" then it's a really dangerous situation. It's easy to fail to spot the difference with a quick glance. I'd be interested to see statistics on how many people die at these intersections, I suspect this is one of the needlessly dangerous aspects of driving in cities.
- Ruthalas 6y agoPerhaps I am alone, but after moving to an area with the 'Stop All Way' signs, I initially misinterpreted them as exhorting drivers to stop 'all the way', as in to come to a complete stop.
- dheera 6y agoThe first time I saw "Do not pass" signs I thought they meant "Thou shalt not pass" as in "Do not enter"
- macintux 6y agoToo often a "Do not enter" sign is in an awkward place where there are two different roadways side by side, and at a glance it's not obvious which one is verboten. Frustrating UI.
- scrose 6y agoThere’s a few ‘Stop: Full stop’ signs in my neighborhood in NYC where cars have to cross over a sidewalk because they realize people’s idea of ‘stop’ is normally ‘drive across sidewalk with blind spots on either end at 10 mph with face in phone’
- granshaw 6y agoI don’t know, the “can turn left on green but oh make sure you yield to full speed cars coming right at you first” is pretty bad US driving UI too
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- doctor_eval 6y agoAs an Australian I find 4-way stop signs to be a form of madness. They don’t exist here. Put an island in the middle and call it a roundabout, or just choose an arbitrary street to have right of way. Either change makes the rules entirely objective. I’ve driven in the US and Canada, and I never understood the 4-way stop sign. Why do they exist? Non rhetorical question.
- the_pwner224 6y agoThey're good in residential areas with smaller streets - one lane in each direction, and cars on the sides of the road. With a 4-way stop sign everything works well, and traffic stays slow since you're not going more than one block without stopping: no room to accelerate to fast speeds. Roundabouts take a lot of space. 2-way stops are dangerous because traffic can be going a bit fast for the small roads, and visibility is low. There's a two way stop near my house and it's always hard to see if another car is coming, until they're almost inside the intersection. Most of the intersections in the area are 4-way and they just work.
- robertsdionne 6y agoYou can have tiny roundabouts: https://www.google.com/maps/@32.2437203,-110.9539392,84m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@32.2437203,-110.9539392,84m/dat... This one is also a 4-way, haha.
- wasdfff 6y agoThese are hillarious when they do implement them in the US. People stop anyway to yield. If anything it makes it a little more dicey to bike through because people also don’t signal when they are exiting.
- craz8 6y agoMy neighborhood (In the Seattle area) has intersections with small, 4 way roundabouts that are combined with 2 way stops (there’s a main street no stop with 2 side streets with stop signs) It’s madness!
- grogenaut 6y agoThe way I deal with that situation is look at the drivers eyes. If they see me it's safe. If they don't, don't give a care if I have right of way. Can't see waymos eyes but maybe I should consider they see me but will follow the legal right if way from the book they can see that I cant