2 ms·
Or at least who thought he carried computer science on his shoulders. He made significant, important contributions. He wasn't the only one. Hoare, Backus, Mc
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Or at least who thought he carried computer science on his shoulders.
He made significant, important contributions. He wasn't the only one. Hoare, Backus, McCarthy... there were a lot of people who made important, fundamental contributions.
Structured programming caught on. Proofs did not, for reasons that would have offended Dijkstra - they took time, and it was actually more valuable (both socially and financially) to produce mostly-working software quickly than to produce proven-correct software slowly.
But he never would have accepted that the real world was that way. He insisted that his approach was correct. As Backus said of him, "This guy’s arrogance takes your breath away."
So: Important contributions? Absolutely. More than anyone else's? Perhaps. Carried computer science on his shoulders? No, but he probably thought he did.
- marcosdumay 6y agoWell, static types and analysis are in fashion now, and always moving on the direction of more powerful proof systems. He was very likely too much ahead of his time on that. Decades after him we still don't have good enough tech to do the kinds of proof he expected... And yes, maybe too arrogant to realize that it's not the entire world that is dumb, but it's a core piece of the system that is missing. On the other hand, he did work to improve proof systems, so who knows what he really thought?