5 ms·
Does anybody else find very unnerving that the CPU clocks are undisclosed? They can't be found anywhere. Not even the product brief[0]. [0]: https://sifive.cd
by snvzz 6y ago
Does anybody else find very unnerving that the CPU clocks are undisclosed?
They can't be found anywhere. Not even the product brief[0].
[0]: https://sifive.cdn.prismic.io/sifive/c05b8ddd-e043-45a6-8a29-2a137090236f_HiFive+Unmatched+Product+Brief+%28released%29.pdf https://sifive.cdn.prismic.io/sifive/c05b8ddd-e043-45a6-8a29...
- rwmj 6y agoIt's 1 GHz [WRONG - see below], it was mentioned in the presentation. The Unleashed can be overclocked just by catting an entry in sysfs, I'm not sure if the same will apply here. EDIT: The clock speed I quoted above is WRONG. I'm on the breakout call now and they are NOT announcing clock speed at this time.
- snvzz 6y agoThat's good to know. At least that does ensure it's an ASIC, not an FPGA. Besides lack of V extension, I'm sad about the seemingly artificial limits (8GB RAM onboard instead of slots, so you can't easily make a workstation out of this) and the still outrageous price. I think that it has its market niche (developers working on risc-v ports), but most of us are better off trying RISC-V cores on an FPGA or emulator. I'm hoping China will solve the cheap RISC-V SoC situation by releasing some cheap chip SBCs can be built on, at some point soon. Lowrisc used to be all about doing that in an open hardware manner, but it seems the moment they got some funding, they got distracted into experiments (e.g. pointer validation stuff) that have little to do with achieving the original goal.
- rwmj 6y agoI can assure you it's certainly an ASIC, and so was the Unleashed. Their very early development version from ~2017 was an FPGA costing about $3-4K. Qemu's RISC-V emulation is excellent and if you have a fast CPU it's a reasonable enough development environment.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoQEMU is shockingly excellent. Do not extrapolate, but one piece of code I was working on ran at a 1/4 of the speed in RISC-V under QEMU compared to the host. That's a really amazing result.
- zozbot234 6y agoMuch of that is due to RISC-V being quite emulation-friendly as far as ISA's go. You wouldn't guess that given e.g. the weird encoding of insn operands, but that turns out to be a minor factor in practice.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoAbsolutely. QEMU is JITting so decode is only done once. What helps here is the absence of crazy semantics, like flag updates. Some things are still expensive, such as indirect branches (jalr), virtual memory translation (load/store), and handling RISC-V's 31 registers without hitting memory for each of them (the host ISA, x64, has only 16 architectural registers).
- zozbot234 6y agoNote that RISC-V instruction set extensions can always be emulated in machine mode, so the lack of V or B extensions will only ever be an issue wrt. performance, not compatibility.
- ncmncm 6y agoThe only reason to use V or B instructions would be for their performance. Trapping and emulating them would be a cruel joke.
- justinclift 6y agoWith 4x 1GHz cores, 8GB of ram, gigabit ethernet, and PCIe... this thing could potentially run as a reasonable low end NAS. :)
- Koshkin 6y ago> 4x 1GHz... low end NAS I still can’t get used to this. Just thinking of how much has been accomplished on 4.77 MHz.
- Jtsummers 6y agoNo kidding. If I weren't too burnt out at the end of the day, I'd really like to explore the true limits of modern computers. Especially since I stopped playing video games, and I no longer do any real number crunching, I feel like every computer I use (for work or home) is greatly underperforming relative to its potential.
- amelius 6y agoDisplays had fewer pixels in that era. Files were much smaller (the video and mp3 files we have now would have been considered insanely large back then).
- tremon 6y agoTo illustrate: a 3.5" high-density floppy disk holds 1 second of DVD-quality video. (yes, I know, it depends on the rate of change in the image since modern video codecs are incremental -- I'm going by data rate rather than effective compression ratio)
- snvzz 6y ago> 4x 1GHz... low end NAS Low clock + lack of B extension means limited hashing and encryption rates. Even a simple ZFS setup with encryption and mirrowing will be slow.
- amelius 6y agoYes, I'd also like to see ops/s, flops/s, ops and flops per Joule, and memory bandwidth, among others.