6 ms·
My cousin lives in a place with shitty internet, and regularly creates a list of YT URLs for later downloading when they go in-town. This is going to devastate
by Scoundreller 6y ago
My cousin lives in a place with shitty internet, and regularly creates a list of YT URLs for later downloading when they go in-town. This is going to devastate them. Especially when they need to repair something or do maintenance where a rando’s video is 100x better than the manufacturer’s instructions and they download all the videos.
I do the same thing before a flight or train ride (Canada has $5-$10/gb wireless pricing) so I can catch up with my favourite subs on-the-move.
- rocgf 6y agoThe Youtube app has a download feature for watching videos offline.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoOnly available if you signed up for a premium account.
- Scoundreller 6y agoDoes it permit it 100% of the time, or do you pay to discover that there’s a bunch of exceptions? And I guess once you stop paying, it’s all gone?
- itsoktocry 6y ago>discover that there’s a bunch of exceptions? Periodically the downloaded videos become unavailable offline if you don't have an internet connection to refresh them. Maybe once a month or something. Which means you can't hold on to a video through their service indefinitely.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWait, how does that even work?
- strictnein 6y agoThe downloaded videos likely have time constraint applied to them that can be updated when the app connects to the Internet. I don't think the downloaded videos can be played outside of the app.
- Scoundreller 6y agoOh, it’s app only? That would already be a pain. I think they got into a good groove of saving URLs for later downloading. Needing to load each one on a tablet is ruining the automation of them visiting a friend or sitting in a cafe, socializing and downing a few dozen gb via youtube-dl just hitting a list of URLs in the bg.
- judge2020 6y agoThere are no exceptions except for things like paid TV shows (not clips, actual TV shows and movies you can pay for[0]) - you can download any video and, as said in the sibling comment, it only expires after 30 days of being offline. 0: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9679194?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9679194?hl=en
- enriquto 6y agoI don't understand the concept of "expiration" for an actual file that you have downloaded. How does it work, technically?
- altrunox 6y agoThe "normal" app yes, but there is another one called Youtube Go, which you can download and save the video on your phone, IDK if it´s avaliable worldwide.
- ComodoHacker 6y agoIt's available to everyone with a Google account, but not for all videos.
- Buttons840 6y agoPremium also generously allows you to turn off the screen while listening. Yeah, seeing that recently was a good reminder that my phone is not under my control.
- rektide 6y agoThe war on general purpose computing is strong. The RIAA has been at the forefront of restricting & preventing user freedoms since time immemorial. Only this time, unlike with Betamax[1], they are winning. Backed by anti-circumvention laws like the DMCA section 1201, which makes any lock, no matter how poorly built, a criminal violation to break or even to build or discuss ways of breaking. [1] https://consumerist.com/2014/01/17/on-this-day-in-1984-the-supreme-court-saved-the-vcr-from-certain-death/ https://consumerist.com/2014/01/17/on-this-day-in-1984-the-s...
- fsflover 6y ago> The war on general purpose computing is strong. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279.
- tsimionescu 6y agoHint: if on Android, Firefox will allow you to do that anyway, even allowing you to do other things on your phone with YT playing in the background. And with uBlock, you won't even get ads.
- MauranKilom 6y ago> Premium also generously allows you to turn off the screen while listening. As does telling your browser to display the desktop site instead.
- Udo 6y agoWhile I do appreciate that feature, it's also very spotty. More than once I downloaded something only to later find that it won't play when I'm offline on a plane. Also, whenever Youtube decides to ban or suspend a video, it automatically disappears from the downloads area as well. Plus, this requires a mobile device, which is not necessarily where you may want to watch these things.
- irjustin 6y agoMaybe Starlink one day?
- itsoktocry 6y agoStarlink might solve the issue of providing internet to far-flung places, which is great. But I'm skeptical they'll be able to massively undercut all of the telecom providers. Building, launching and maintaining a satellite constellation isn't cheap; it's still a question as to whether the economics will work at all.
- StavrosK 6y agoPresumably the costs amortize pretty well, though.
- autumn_unlaces 6y agoThe announced pricing for the current "beta" is $99/month plus $500 upfront for the hardware.
- Scoundreller 6y agoIf it can offer anything near the speeds advertised without the BS of incumbents, I could see a massive amount of demand. I figure 5% of consumers « served » by both cable and xDSL can’t get good service, and then they have virtually every rural customer that’s anything more than a low-data user. And I’d expect them to capture that one day with a « light » plan. It’s a massive market.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>The announced pricing for the current "beta" is $99/month plus $500 upfront for the hardware. Yes, that's the price they charge. What are the costs of providing the service?
- autumn_unlaces 6y agoWhen you said undercut their competitors I assumed you meant undercutting the price consumers pay so I told you the price they are currently offering. I do not know that their costs are and since SpaceX is a private company I don't think we know how much it is costing them to provide it.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Canada has $5-$10/gb wireless pricing Well, if you are counting overage charges I guess. My (national) provider has an all-in, bring-your-own-device plan with 9GB of data (recently with a 2GB bonus, for a total of 11GB) for under $60/month. I'm sure the competitors are similar. So, while not perfect, it's not as onerous as you describe.
- znpy 6y agoHere in .it I have 30gb/month in LTE for 5.99€/month (fixed price).
- itsoktocry 6y agoYeah, Canada is definitely behind the times. Some of that can be attributed to our vast land area making infrastructure buildout expensive, but some of it is also due to our telecoms having a government supported monopoly. It's getting better though, at least in my opinion. I'm paying less today than I was just a few years ago, for far more data.
- Hello71 6y agoEven ignoring the fact that your plan as described falls within the specified range ($60/month/11 GB = $5.45/month/GB), I have never heard of plans or overage charges this cheap from any of the three major Canadian wireless providers. Last year, the three major providers simultaneously increased the price of the well-publicized $60/10 GB offer by at least $5/month. I'm not aware of any standard plans offering more for less, although you may be able to bargain for less. You may also be able to find slightly cheaper rates with a smaller provider, but despite offering nominally nation-wide coverage, the practical coverage usually ends up being substantially poorer. Regarding overage charges, I would be genuinely shocked if anybody, including a minor provider, has overage under $10/GB, seeing as by your own admission, even your standard rate exceeds $5/GB. Rogers overages are $70/GB, Bell is $110-120/GB, Telus is a whopping $130/GB. If overage charges are under the normal rate, then that's not an overage, that's pay-as-you-go.
- itsoktocry 6y ago
- officeplant 6y agoNewpipe on the F-Droid repo allows for video/audio downloads if they are an android user.
- 29083011397778 6y agoI would have assumed NewPipe used youtube-dl somehwere along the line, and therefore be affected by this new assault on the youtube-dl library.
- officeplant 6y agoThere Github[0] page is still active so I'm assuming they may have dodged the take downs. I believe they integrated youtube-dl into the application, but because they don't outright mention it on the page they may have dodged attention from the RIAA. This is just a wild guess from me. [0]https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe