4 ms·
Okay, forget the CoC for a second, can we evaluate this talk with just regular human empathy? Because I think he’s being somewhat of a dick. Like it’s a little
by Spivak 6y ago
Okay, forget the CoC for a second, can we evaluate this talk with just regular human empathy? Because I think he’s being somewhat of a dick. Like it’s a little rude and not in the best taste.
Like it was totally possible to give this talk in a positive manner talking about all the reasons you think notebooks are good and demonstrating the use-cases.
* You don’t have to call out or reference the original speaker at all and say they’re wrong. Even if they are objectively wrong don’t be a dick and call them out publicly. Just shoot them a message and they can post the correction themselves. Were taking a professional peer, not someone intentionally trying to mislead and arguing in bad faith.
* Talking over their original slides gives a super adversarial tone. You can give your reasons why notebooks are good and even tackle common criticisms without picking apart their talk specifically. It’s the conference version of the gross “name and shame pattern” you see all over the internet.
* Why would you say something negative about a peer’s work on stage? Like it’s fine to have an impassioned rant at the bar afterwords if you want but this is the spiritual equivalent of saying something negative about a coworker in front of them and their boss. If it were me it would certainly leave a bad taste in my mouth.
- civilized 6y agoWhat, exactly, do your personal feelings and values have to do with the question of whether Jeremy was "a dick" to Joel? Isn't that between Jeremy and Joel? Joel didn't have a problem with Jeremy's talk. Why do you think you know better than Joel whether it was appropriate to criticize Joel in the way that Jeremy did? Your belief that, whatever Joel may have thought, your perspective is the one of "regular human empathy" is indicative of a certain narcissism about the superiority about your own moral sentiments. The same narcissism that motivated this farcical CoC accusation and persecution mess to begin with.
- bawolff 6y agoI disagree in principle. The "victim" doesn't have to be offended for the behaviour to potentially be inappropriate. Behaviour has second order effects beyond the direct "victim" (e.g. people watch and think its ok, so more people do it, and it becomes "normal"). Its also entirely possible for the victim to be hurt, without him admitting it for a variety of reasons (E.g. social pressure, not wanting to be seen as weak or a crybaby, etc). To be clear, I'm speaking in principle. I don't agree in the particular case that the behaviour was inappropriate.
- civilized 6y agoThat's fair. I would hope we can recognize that some things just can't be done in public, while other "offenses" are more subjective and their validity can depend on the relationship of the individuals involved as well as how the supposed target/victim took it. For example, whether it's OK to hug someone in public depends on things like whether it was your life partner or a stranger, and whether the recipient was OK with it.
- glangdale 6y agoThis is a very good point. I worked with a group (when we were a very small team at a startup) where we would say terrible things about each others code/ideas more or less for fun, as we had a long-running relationship and understood that everyone respected everyone else. Once we were in a bigger company, we had to stop talking like that (at least in venues where others could hear us) as the perception that we were "ripping each other apart" could be perceived as very threatening to people who didn't have that rapport nor the understanding of the background. The perception would be that we were mean people who might turn on them at any moment. The argument that "oh, X can both dish it out and take it (with respect to criticism from Y)" often ignores the fact that somewhere, "Z" is quietly watching this interaction and deciding that they don't want to participate in this apparently hostile environment.
- civilized 6y agoYes yes, these are all fine points, but to apply them in a one-size-fits-all universal way is inhuman. Curse words might be considered inappropriate at work regardless of the people involved, but things like hugs or negative feedback aren't that simple. However well-intentioned, aggressively universalized conduct rules become a boot stamping on the face of perfectly normal human relationships and communication styles.
- ben0x539 6y agoEven if OP were to have committed a horrible sin in the talk, this isn't the outcome anyone was hoping for. Hence the actual talk is very much a side issue.
- bawolff 6y agoSo i only skimmed the presentation (It is an hour long). > You don’t have to call out or reference the original speaker at all and say they’re wrong I disagree. His talk is essentially a direct response to the other presentation. He is assuming context from the original presentation (A very famous one in this space from what I can pick up). Without explaining the context, his presentation would make less sense to those not as familiar with this particular tech scene. Its not like he's saying the other person is an idiot or something. He actually compliments the other speaker multiple times. > You can give your reasons why notebooks are good and even tackle common criticisms without picking apart their talk specifically If your goal is to talk up notebooks sure. If your goal is to respectfully disagree with the widely accepted dogma, then you should make direct reference to the work you are responding to. > Why would you say something negative about a peer’s work on stage Making provocative statements challenging widely held beliefs is literally the job of a keynote speaker. Not that anyone should really consider constructive criticism of an argument the same as saying something negative about the person making them. Personally, I think it'd be pretty passive-aggressive to demolish someone's work without doing the courtesy of referencing the work you are arguing against. Edit: At the same time, I'm very sad to see you being downvoted. You make a reasonable argument that deserves to be debated on its merit, not downvoted imo.
- jimbokun 6y agoYou need to develop a little sense of humor. The author was responding to a talk made by a friend and he let him know ahead of time he would be using some of his slides and the friend was ok with that.
- gojomo 6y agoIf the 'target' is OK with a more-critical, even a hyperbolically- or teasingly- critical tone, why not allow it? Lots of big personalities carry on 'feuds' that are largely acts, to their mutual. The back-and-forth, even with campy insults, creates a framework for understanding the key points and evolution of the disagreement. Using more forceful, even facetiously disrespectful language expands the range of imagery/metaphor/emotion that can be deployed, often to humorous or insightful effect. It makes conversations, whether live in person or slowly over months of counter-performances, more memorable. If such talk rubs a few people the wrong way, out of some expansive concern for targets who do not themselves find the tone/language objectionable, I'd love to find a place where those people can be comfortable. But I don't want to sabotage the value of the free-to-all discourse for the much larger group of people who find vibrant, disputative, raw communication – even to the point of prickliness – more efficient and preferable. We're losing something if we require all speech to be sanitized for maximal gentility under new secular Sunday School rules.
- Barrin92 6y ago>If the 'target' is OK with a more-critical, even a hyperbolically- or teasingly- critical tone, why not allow it? if it's between two people who stand on the same level roughly as is in this case and it's all in good fun it's no issue. However in general this is a horrible idea, because someone with outsized influence can bully in ways that the victim will simply have to take if the imbalance is too large. Imagine Elon Musk gives a talk and absolutely drags someone with awful criticism, the person couldn't stand up against his twitter mob if they tried and would probably defer to keep their sanity even if they're right. Even in literal bullying this is kind of how the victim responds, just pretending it wasn't an issue as to not get bullied even more. So one has to be careful on this one.
- gojomo 6y agoSure, but your Musk hypothetical isn't like this case. And, in cases of massive power/following imbalance like your hypothetical, it's unlikely any community CoC like this would even apply. The nasty person would just use any of their outlets that don't try to enforce a hyper-genteel environment.
- NamTaf 6y agoI disagree with you completely. Presentations are a public dialogue about topics; that's literally their purpose. By presenting on a topic, you are putting your ideas and viewpoints into the public sphere for discussion, sharing, critique, criticism and further development. Hiding one side of that conversation makes no sense whatsoever. You can disagree respectfully with someone in public. That's pretty fundamental to progressing the dialogue. Hiding it means people don't then get to evaluate opposing viewpoints and understand the relative merits of each. My colleagues and I disagree about our work - in public, in front of each other - all the time. The trick is to do it politely and respectfully, which is overwhelmingly the case. This is how we all learn from each other and develop a higher overall standard of output. And all that considered, in this particular case why not just ask the original presenter how they feel about it? Surely that is the authoritive answer to whether there's even an issue here.