3 ms·

This smptomatic of the green-washing trend. Planting trees by itself is not an action that is inherently good: it is if placed where useful for instance to figh

This smptomatic of the green-washing trend. Planting trees by itself is not an action that is inherently good: it is if placed where useful for instance to fight desertification, it can be dommageable in other cases such as planting non native species, or planting moni-cture forest. As usual with this kind of initiative, there is no info on the type of trees planted, where they are and why it does matter to the local environnement. There is no way to verify impact. My comment might be harsh, but most of the releved criticized can be easily addressed with more information.

aclimatt 6y ago
You're absolutely right, it can be easily addressed with more information. So perhaps it would have been worth it to get that information first and level a more applicable criticism before posting valueless FUD. https://teamtrees.org/ https://teamtrees.org/
parhamn 6y ago
Sure, it's a fair question :) The idea came to me when I saw the popular youtube campaign TeamTrees [1], and wondered how we can achieve a similar throughput on a regular basis. We're still looking for t he best partners forward the money to. We'd love to allocate to any provider we think is going to do the most for the climate. I'm happy to forward they money to Stripe as well if they have better strategies for this. It seems fine to forward it to the team that Mark Robber and Mr. Beast put together (assuming they have done proper due diligence given Elon & Tobi have donated 1m respectively), until we find better strategies. [1] https://teamtrees.org/ https://teamtrees.org/
skrtskrt 6y ago
What do you think about this option from Project Wren? It looks like the money is going to an established organization (TIST) run with an eye towards everything you said. https://projectwren.com/projects/community-tree-planting https://projectwren.com/projects/community-tree-planting I just found out about Project Wren recently, turns out they are a YC company. I want to pull the trigger on signing up for it but I want to be really sure what I'm donating towards is actually effective.
garth5689 6y ago
If anyone wants some evidence supporting this comment's overall idea, here's an applicable podcast episode to provide some examples of when indiscriminately planting trees might have unintended consequences: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/for-the-love-of-peat/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/for-the-love-of-peat/

aclimatt 6y ago

You're absolutely right, it can be easily addressed with more information. So perhaps it would have been worth it to get that information first and level a more applicable criticism before posting valueless FUD. https://teamtrees.org/ https://teamtrees.org/

parhamn 6y ago

Sure, it's a fair question :) The idea came to me when I saw the popular youtube campaign TeamTrees [1], and wondered how we can achieve a similar throughput on a regular basis. We're still looking for t he best partners forward the money to. We'd love to allocate to any provider we think is going to do the most for the climate. I'm happy to forward they money to Stripe as well if they have better strategies for this. It seems fine to forward it to the team that Mark Robber and Mr. Beast put together (assuming they have done proper due diligence given Elon & Tobi have donated 1m respectively), until we find better strategies. [1] https://teamtrees.org/ https://teamtrees.org/

skrtskrt 6y ago

What do you think about this option from Project Wren? It looks like the money is going to an established organization (TIST) run with an eye towards everything you said. https://projectwren.com/projects/community-tree-planting https://projectwren.com/projects/community-tree-planting I just found out about Project Wren recently, turns out they are a YC company. I want to pull the trigger on signing up for it but I want to be really sure what I'm donating towards is actually effective.

garth5689 6y ago

If anyone wants some evidence supporting this comment's overall idea, here's an applicable podcast episode to provide some examples of when indiscriminately planting trees might have unintended consequences: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/for-the-love-of-peat/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/for-the-love-of-peat/