4 ms·
Grid batteries have slightly different requirements compared to EV batteries. Weight/volume doesn't matter. Charge speed isn't a priority. Discharge speed i
by londons_explore 6y ago
Grid batteries have slightly different requirements compared to EV batteries. Weight/volume doesn't matter. Charge speed isn't a priority. Discharge speed isn't awfully important either. Round trip efficiency and cycle life are even more important. Temperature ranges aren't as wide.
Overall, I think these differences will lead to separate production facilities and differing designs.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> Charge speed isn't a priority. Discharge speed isn't awfully important either. Not yet, but if power production becomes more volatile (more wind/solar and ???) without associated demand response, how quickly you can charge and discharge starts impacting your duty cycle (“inventory turns per hour”).
- mdorazio 6y agoI don't think that's necessarily the case for sufficiently large installations unless the cells are really slow. For any grid-scale battery you're going to have many thousands of individual cells linked together. Even if each cell is individually only capable of relatively small charge/discharge rates, it shouldn't matter at the scale of the whole installation for normal supply/demand scenarios. I would only expect brown-out situations if something bad happens to the grid (like PG&E decides to shut down power distribution elsewhere because of fire risk...)
- tgb 6y agoI think there will always be a trade-off where charge/discharge rates need to be comparable to the durations of peaks and troughs in supply/demand or else capacity must be over-provisioned. If peaks/troughs last N hours and you have K times the minimum capacity needed, then each cell needs to charge/discharge in N/K hours.
- Scoundreller 6y agoIf you’re a public utility, sure. But a faster recharge lets you do more of your buying the absolute trough. And faster discharge lets you capture more of any spike (but that’s less valuable methinks). Kinda like being able to charge your Tesla with a bigger circuit at home so you don’t have to charge as much during peak hours.
- toast0 6y agoI think there's some applications for high discharge cells. The local car ferry is electrifying, and they're planning on charging at every docking. On my side, our grid power is somewhat fragile, and they're adding redundant wiring between substations (it will be a loop instead of a tree), and a battery bank at the substation nearest the ferry dock, to ease the peak demand.
- pjc50 6y agoMore wind and solar tends to decrease volatility on the short term, while increasing the diurnal and seasonal variation. A big market for grid batteries then becomes "frequency stabilisation services": they are paid not for actual turnover, but for being there and able to respond to demand within an AC cycle.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 6y ago>Discharge speed isn't awfully important either "On December 14, the Loy Yang coal power plant — one of the largest in Australia — suddenly went offline. In an instant, the grid shed 560 MW of electricity, enough to power 170,000 homes. 600 miles away, the Hornsdale Power Reserve battery system, as the Tesla system is officially known, kicked in within 140 milliseconds. It reacted so quickly, in fact, that the local grid operator was unable to measure the response time accurately. " https://cleantechnica.com/2017/12/27/tesla-grid-storage-battery-reacts-record-time-power-outage/ https://cleantechnica.com/2017/12/27/tesla-grid-storage-batt...
- NegativeLatency 6y agoThe amount of power for charging or discharging is not the same thing as the latency to start sending power.
- beervirus 6y agoThat's switching speed, not discharge speed. Discharge speed is how many amps a battery can put out.
- vegardx 6y agoThe article mentioned that the battery was only able to supply 16MW to the grid. By all means a significant amount, but nowhere near the required 560MW needed to stabilize the grid. This is where hydro-based power plants excel, they're able to adjust the power output as quickly as gravity can push the water down the pipes. They're able to ramp up from almost no output to full capacity in minutes. Gas-turbines are also able to do this.
- pjc50 6y ago"Minutes" is not "140 miliseconds". But it's well worth reading https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/system/files/docs/2019/09/eso_technical_report_-_final.pdf https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/system/files/docs/2019/09/eso_techn... on an actual UK grid trip event to see what kind of things can happen; start at "summary of event" on p4. Note the three paragraphs starting with "However" as subsequent stability systems also failed. > This made the cumulative loss of generation 1,691MW (!) > All of the available “backup” power had already been deployed
- bryanlarsen 6y agoAccording to Tesla battery day they are going to use the same production line to produce three different batteries, varying the cathode. Iron Phosphate for low-cost or full-discharge use cases, Nickel Manganese for mainstream and Nickel for high performance.
- kjsthree 6y ago> Temperature ranges aren't as wide. I thought people were mounting these out in the garage. For me that would be an 80° delta between the highest summer highs and the lowest winter low. The delta in places like Wyoming would be a lot more.
- minitoar 6y agoPresumably that’s less range than in a car driving around in Wyoming?
- londons_explore 6y agoBig fixed installations (think multi megawatt industrial sites) have far more batteries compared to surface area. That means it makes sense to simply wrap the batteries in insulation and use heaters to keep them warm over the winter. Sure, you use a little power to do that, but you gain back far more performance. For $50 worth of electricity, you can keep something the size of a refrigerator 40 degrees F warmer than the outdoor air all year if you can surround it with an insulating box 2 inches thick. In a car, the volume to surface area ratio is worse, and you can't guarantee it won't be left in the cold for months without a grid connection, so you need to ensure the chemistry can work cold.
- rovolo 6y agoI'm more familiar with Alaska and had a 130˚F delta between the high and low air temp. The garages I'm familiar with were always insulated and contained the furnace. Even if the garage was unheated, the excess heat from the furnace and insulation would keep the inside above freezing. Also, the insulation and lack of windows would keep the garage cool in the summer.
- pjc50 6y agoCounterintuitively it seems that "make it up with volume" is winning; rather than all sorts of different battery designs (with associated fixed costs of manufacture), they're just going to turn out a billion 18650 cells.
- cptskippy 6y ago> Counterintuitively it seems that "make it up with volume" is winning; The 18650 is a form factor, not the chemistry. Tesla uses the 18650 in the Model S and X but uses a 21700 form factor for the Model 3, Powerwall and Powerpack. They announced during their Battery Day event the transition to the 4680 form factor. The Powerwall and Powerpack uses a Lithium NMC chemistry which is different from the Lithium NCA chemistry used in their automobiles. * Clarification
- audunw 6y ago> Grid batteries have slightly different requirements compared to EV batteries. Weight/volume doesn't matter. Charge speed isn't a priority. [...] I have the impression that Tesla tweaks the chemistry depending on the application. The cells used for power wall and grid storage might be slightly different to take advantage of those differences. While weight/volume isn't important itself, reducing the weight/volume per kWh will also tend to reduce the cost per kWh since you're using less materials. There are storage solutions that go further in taking advantage of the points you mention, such as flow batteries, but in that case I think it can be expensive to get high power output. The article mentions that price per kW is also important. With batteries you automatically get more watts the more watt-hours you add, which is useful in many cases.
- cptskippy 6y agoThey do, the Powerwall and Powerpack use a Lithium NMC chemistry as opposed to Lithium NCA used in their automobiles.
- N1H1L 6y agoYes. In fact the thinking is that increasingly grid batteries will be sodium-ion, because weight is not that big of a deal. Additionally, we have enormous quantities of sodium available, which is why it's predicted to be significantly cheaper in a decade.