6 ms·
Asking Microsoft to resign from the RIAA over YouTube-dl takedown demand
- cwkoss 6y agoI'm slightly cynical that Microsoft will actually listen, but applying pressure from inside seems like useful advocacy.
- megous 6y agoNow that would be a nice MS :heart: OSS statement. Because what's MS to gain from this, other than some goodwill from some subset of people, if they did it specifically to stand up for OSS?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- softinio 6y agoIt does make me think whether GitHub is fitting place for open source projects anymore. I think GitHub is fabulous. I love the service and I think its great as a central place to look for and contribute to open source projects better than options we had before. But issues like this does clearly show an area of misalignment and conflict of interests.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThere's a reason I have several backups of code that I care about, hosted under different usernames on different platforms. People end up getting banned by these companies without any notice, and sometimes without cause.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoGitea/Gogs are great (self-hosted) alternatives. They preserve GitHub's UI and more importantly are just as fast. UI and speed are usually most people's complaints about Gitlab.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoGitHub is most definitely worthy as a node on the network of an open source project, with the caveat that in the event of loss, the project should be able to rapidly spin back up on GitLab or any other git-based project management system (my fork of youtube-dl was nuked as part of the DMCA takedown, but I was able to restore the tarball the Internet Archive had to my personal GitLab instance, for example). This isn't a call to move from GitHub wholesale (churning between git hosts isn't an effective use of resources imho), but to build more durability and resiliency into distributed version control systems (Keybase-esque identity management, signing every commit, etc). Just as the Internet Archive and others are championing a distributed web [1], technologists must champion distributed development systems. Perhaps a reasonable target is to be able to perform a "git pull" from IPFS? As Gilmore said [2], interpret censorship as damage and route around it. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=distributed+web https://www.google.com/search?q=distributed+web [2] http://kirste.userpage.fu-berlin.de/outerspace/internet-article.html http://kirste.userpage.fu-berlin.de/outerspace/internet-arti... (First Nation in Cyberspace, TIME International - Dec. 6, 1993, No.49)
- pabs3 6y agoLooks like there are a bunch of different git-remote-ipfs implementations: https://github.com/larsks/git-remote-ipfs https://github.com/larsks/git-remote-ipfs https://github.com/ipfs-shipyard/git-remote-ipld https://github.com/ipfs-shipyard/git-remote-ipld https://github.com/cryptix/git-remote-ipfs https://github.com/cryptix/git-remote-ipfs
- bergstromm466 6y ago> to build more durability and resiliency into distributed version control systems I'm following Git-SSB and Holochain. Apart from IPFS, any others you've found?
- 3np 6y agoThis is also based on SSB https://radicle.xyz/ https://radicle.xyz/
- pochamago 6y agoIt may well be the watershed moment. Microsoft wants to be seen as committed to the open ecosystem, and now we get to see the implications of what will happen with any conflicts of interest they have. I hope they're internally aware of the impact this scenario has.
- pabs3 6y agoOpen Source needs open source infrastructure, so in retrospect GitHub was never really the best place for hosting open source projects. https://mako.cc/writing/hill-free_tools.html https://mako.cc/writing/hill-free_tools.html
- paxys 6y agoWhat is open source infrastructure though? Can there ever be a public-owned and operated server?
- pabs3 6y agoI would say that infrastructure that runs open source is a good start. Secondly you probably also want the data to be publicly available and for the configuration to be public and for there to be mechanisms to contribute changes back to all of these. Some of the Linux distros operate in this way.
- Shared404 6y agoYou could make a pretty good case for Sourcehut. The code is all open source, and is decently simple to self host if you feel inclined.
- antpls 6y agoMicrosft and GitHub comply with the laws, there is no conflict of interest here. Open source doesn't mean illegal. The problem is not GitHub or MS, the problem is the current law about copyrighted content, tools, fair usage, counter procedures, etc.
- sam0x17 6y agoHere is the real test of Microsoft's resolve in their desire to woo the developer community.
- akersten 6y agoNot only should they resign from the RIAA, they should reinstate the code, and sue the RIAA for reputational damages resulting from the perjurious DMCA notice. The RIAA knowingly issued a takedown where there was no copyrighted content. That is perjury. It is spelled out in the DMCA. If they wanted to sue under the "no circumvention" clause, they could have. But they chose to misuse the DMCA takedown process again. Just once I'd love to see them put in their place for the rampant abuse of the system.
- Kranar 6y agoWhat is the misuse here? The DMCA makes it illegal to distribute software whose intention is to circumvent technical measures that prevent access to copyrighted materials [1]. youtube-dl's own documentation provides instructions on downloading copyrighted music videos and its test suite uses copyrighted material as well. It's pretty hard, although not impossible, to claim that the intention of the software isn't to engage in copyright violations given those two facts. Okay so you make a counterargument that maybe this qualifies as fair-use or falls under some other exemption. Maybe you're right, maybe you're not right, that's for a court to decide. The RIAA's lawyer is not here to defend youtube-dl's position on the matter, youtube-dl has the responsibility of defending itself and demonstrating why it chose to use copyrighted music videos as the key example and use case. You can object to the law and you can even provide a defense for youtube-dl and counter the takedown notice, but you can't say that RIAA's lawyer abused the DMCA takedown process by defending its client. [1] https://www.copyright.gov/policy/1201/#:~:text=Enacted%20in%201998%20as%20part,in%20technology%20or%20services%20that https://www.copyright.gov/policy/1201/#:~:text=Enacted%20in%...
- akersten 6y agoThe misuse of the DMCA takedown notice is that none of the content in the repository was copyright to the RIAA or to an entity the RIAA represents. That's it. The DMCA takedown process is emphatically not the avenue to remedy an alleged circumvention tool as defined by the DMCA. The DMCA allows relief through the courts in that case, a route the RIAA chose not to persue because it is easier to misuse the takedown process. The DMCA takedown process is intended only to remedy the situation where your or your clients' copyrighted content is hosted without permission - any other use is perjury. You can read more about how a claimant must identify the specific infringing content in a takedown notice here [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_Liability_Limitation_Act#Notice_from_copyright_owner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_...
- mensetmanusman 6y agoHumanity for centuries has decided that information is potentially dangerous. Those in power get to choose what information that is. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_books_banned_by_governments https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_books_banned_by_gove... Modern day version: RIAA thinks ideas/instructions about how to record music will destroy the record industry. Twitter thinks that some ideas from the NYPost will harm democracy. The NYTs thinks that revealing anonymous sources will harm democracy (because their inside sources would be fired). etc. etc. Freedom of speech in the broadest sense is not the equilibrium state of cultural norms.
- Rochus 6y ago> While we'd prefer that Microsoft would simply [...] reject their DMCA requests Yes, they should and could have done that, all the more so, since justification for the request is on thin ice. > Microsoft can take the easy first step of resigning from RIAA in protest What should that be good for? Rather they should use their influence there to prevent such nonsense in the future.
- Arnavion 6y agoDoes anyone know when Microsoft joined the RIAA and what MS had to say about that? I'm curious what reason MS gave for it, if any. The RIAA was founded in 1952 so it couldn't have been a founding member, yet I can't find any news or press release with permutations of "Microsoft joins RIAA". Based on archive.org's oldest copy of the RIAA website's members page, it was a member since 2016 at least.
- echelon 6y agoNot sure, but they've been on good terms since the Zune era at minimum. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20061108/235014.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20061108/235014.shtml
- solarkraft 6y agoIt's fascinating what some people are demanding. AFAIK (not a lawyer) DMCA requests are presumed correct so the hoster has to take the content down, with a later process to handle a dispute. Microsoft is a site that hosts projects for free while following the law. They have no interest in defending a project legally (besides, maybe, PR). Why would they? The request isn't clearly fraudulent, the RIAA's case is shaky, but it's something one could defend in a court and maybe even win with, provided a strong imbalance of money to spend.
- marvy 6y ago> maybe even win with In a U.S. court? You really think so? If you're right then in my opinion that's proof that the law needs fixing.
- Shared404 6y agoIt's the "Imbalance of money" part that's critical to that. And unfortunately, yes. I think so. Remember, Google v. Oracle has hit the Supreme Court. The only reason it's gone on so long is both sides can afford to keep throwing money at it. What happens when one side can't?
- gamblor956 6y agoCounterpoint: in the dancing baby case, Prince lost. Money is less important to the outcome of a trial than people think it is.
- junon 6y agoIMO it's chance. Depends very much on the judge, which unfortunately all have a different take on the law.
- nullc 6y ago> presumed correct so the hoster has to take the content down Absolutely not. The hoster won't enjoy a safe harbor (for the specific accused infringement) if the request is properly formed (which they seldom are, including this one) and they they do not take the material down, but they are under no obligation to do so. [And as other posters have noted-- in this case a copyright infringement isn't even alleged; they're complaining under the anti-circumvention provisions which have no notice and takedown or safe harbor at all.]
- 533474 6y agoMicrosoft employees! raise the issue, make yourselves heard!, this is a horrible precedent to the developer community and a shot in the coffin for centralised git repositories!
- msfthrowaway 6y agohow? microsoft is big. and every time there is somekind of hot topic around microsoft, I try to find if someone is discussing it internally. to this date I have not able to find any written internal discussion (which actually makes sense in a way :P). maximum you get is some discussion in cafeteria or smoking area, but no follow up in yammer, teams or mail. I'm probably doing something wrong...
- junon 6y agoI know why. Same reason why we didn't say shit when Uber was burning from the inside and our CEO was on drunk rampages with seedy women in the car. The US has no labor laws protecting the employee. Saying something can easily get you fired, next day. They don't have to give a reason. A protest would require a non-trivial amount of people all coordinated in a 24 hour period or so to come forward with demands.
- panic 6y agoWhy is Microsoft even an RIAA member in the first place?
- dredmorbius 6y agoGood question. Microsoft Store online marketplace dropped books and music in 2017: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-47810367 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-47810367
- kimsant 6y agoIMO open source projects need open source tools. I use gitlab for example. The problem here is that Microsoft has interests now on GitHub, same as Nvidia has interest on ARM. Sure they will assure blablabla bla bla... seriously, do not even try to denny interest on expensive acquired stuff
- Qwertious 6y agoProjects != services instantiating the project. Gitlab wouldn't fix the problem here - if Gitlab were owned by Microsoft, even if fully FOSS, Microsoft would probably do the same thing. The problem here is that Microsoft has plenty of interests, and protecting Github's sanctity is not #1 on that list. IMO this is the problem with FOSS services running on a corporate of under base. We aren't their main source of money, so they have perverse incentives.
- pabs3 6y agoUnfortunately gitlab.com does not run the Open Source version of the GitLab codebase, it runs the mixed proprietary & open source version.
- projektfu 6y agoMicrosoft is not a powerful member of the RIAA. Their resignation would only strengthen the case that technology companies and recording artists are at odds.
- Griffinsauce 6y agoThe RIAA are not "recording artists". It is a group that protects a media industry, not the artists within that industry or all music creators generally. This and many of their actions hurt independent musicians. Don't fall for their gaslighting, there are many artists that they do not represent.