8 ms·
Post publishes a lot of disreputable trash that's outright false or unproven It doesn't matter. This strawman is presented every time this topic comes up. It
by reaperducer 6y ago
Post publishes a lot of disreputable trash that's outright false or unproven
It doesn't matter. This strawman is presented every time this topic comes up. It's not about the quality of the Post's journalism. It's about whether Twitter should restrict it.
I've been reading the Post off and on for the last 40 years, and you are correct that it is a rag. But it is a newspaper. A newspaper with a better reputation for reporting the news than Twitter.
Not every article is going to be to your taste, or ape your point of view. And as newspapers go, it is very sensational. This is not a secret. Everyone knows what to expect when they pick up a copy. And they read it with that filter in mind. This is literacy 101.
But people on HN try to falsely characterize it as the equivalent of the National Enquirer. It isn't. It's a legitimate newspaper, whether you like it or not.
99.9% of the Post criticism I see on HN is from people who have never lived in New York. Never actually read the Post, or any other newspaper. They just amplify and repeat the echo chamber hyperbole they see from other people who have never read the Post. Some of the most vocal have stated in other threads that they are Twitter employees.
If I have to choose between the Post being an information gatekeeper and Twitter, I'll go with the Post every time.
- rbanffy 6y ago> It doesn't matter. This strawman is presented every time this topic comes up. It's not about the quality of the Post's journalism. It's about whether Twitter should restrict it. Twitter is a private company. They constantly, if unevenly, exercise their right to ban hate speech and what causes it. > But it is a newspaper. A newspaper with a better reputation for reporting the news than Twitter. Twitter is not a newspaper. Or a news organization. It's a social network. > But people on HN try to falsely characterize it as the equivalent of the National Enquirer. That's debatable. You admit it's a rag, that publishes some of the lowest quality journalism. It's also very politically biased, in a way that damages the very fabric of society. Restricting its reach is the responsible thing to do in their case. As for the National Enquirer, nobody takes them seriously or call it a legitimate newspaper. That's why it's important to hold the NY Post to a higher standard.
- kshacker 6y ago> That's debatable. You admit it's a rag, that publishes some of the lowest quality journalism. It's also very politically biased, in a way that damages the very fabric of society. Restricting its reach is the responsible thing to do in their case. While I agree with you, something in your comment made me think. "What does not kill you makes you stronger". Maybe the test of our times is that we as a society learn how to ignore the trash ourselves, or if we do not learn the lesson, we perish. Do we want to learn to ignore, or learn to police?
- cweagans 6y ago> if we do not learn the lesson, we perish Would you consider Twitter refusing to propagate this nonsense "learning a lesson"? I would.
- chrisstanchak 6y ago>Twitter is a private company. They constantly, if unevenly, exercise their right to ban hate speech and what causes it. So is Verizon. Do you want to live in a world where your phone gets turned off if they don't like the conversation?
- hammock 6y agoSee also: net neutrality
- rbanffy 6y agoNet neutrality is not applicable outside the network layers.
- mox1 6y agoYou have no intrinsic right to a mobile telephone, so we do live in this world. If it made business sense for them to do this, they would. Call in a few threats to local businesses or SWAT someone and see how long it takes for your phone to get disabled.
- JohnBooty 6y agoTwitter is a platform with a editorial slant. The NYPost is a platform with a (large) editorial slant. Why should one be obligated to amplify the other? The NYPost gets to have an absolutely massive editorial slant (endorsing presidential candidates, etc) but Twitter can't? Should the NYPost be forced to amplify the NYTimes? What about other heavily user-driven platforms like HN and StackOverflow? Should HN be forbidden from curating its front page stories as well? Keep in mind that HN itself is heavily curated. Should HN be allowed to do that? (Browse HN with showdead on sometime to see what you're missing...)
- rbanffy 6y agoI'd say the NY Post is free to post on the Gab network or on Parler. Twitter, a private company, is under no obligation to provide them a platform.
- dionian 6y agoShould they continue be exempt from lawsuits per section 230
- rbanffy 6y agoSection 230 doesn't require neutrality.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoCorrect. It requires companies no not be treated as publishers. However if the companies themselves behave as publishers, yet avoid that designation bybhiding behind a regulation intended to protect Non-Publishers... Then clesrly they are going against the spirit of the law and the law should be updated so there are consequences, particularly if they enjoy network effect monopolies. This is very simple to do. Any company using 230, that is publicly listed, has more than 1B in revenue or 100M of users should inmediately lose section 230 protection. Full stop. Any infotech company of size becomes very attractive for political influence, and should be closely watched for potential violation of campaing finance laws among other things.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe Post was the newspaper with the good sports page and sport betting odds when I was growing up. The paper version pretty much is just that today. Online, it’s a different spin looking for a similar audience. Instead of cranky Jets fans, it’s targeting blue collar conservatives. The quality is much lower imo — they run native content that looks like Taboola.
- dionian 6y agoSo? I don't want Twitter deciding what I can and can't read.
- Spooky23 6y agoFortunately, Twitter hasn’t taken down www.nypost.com.
- olliej 6y agoI just checked, and yes Twitter can, just like you can’t force any business you want to stock copies of the nypost. Also nypost.com is a thing. The reality is that plenty of sites use Twitter as an essentially free billboard ad. Then get upset when they’re told they can’t put whatever they want on a billboard on private property, especially one that they have no contract to use, nor pay rent for.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoOk. Except they happen to be the billboard of the world Size matters. A highway billboard and a world billboard are not the same. Thats why we have antitrust laws. Microsoft doesnt get to do whatever it wants just because its a sovereign company. Twitter Goog Fb should not leverage protections originally intented for sites like HN
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 6y agoIt does matter! Twitter and Facebook swore that they would limit this kind of garbage rumor mill information for the election. if NYP would have showed how they verified the information then twitter would have let them spread the info. Twitter is a private company and they are trying to be more responsible about slowing the spread of disinformation. This is a good thing and not a bad thing.
- NeverFade 6y ago> NYP would have showed how they verified the information then twitter would have let them spread the info. Did Twitter or Facebook ever ask The Atlantic to "show them how they verified the information" about Trump calling war heroes "losers" and "suckers"? https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/09/trump-americans-who-died-at-war-are-losers-and-suckers/615997/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/09/trump-a... That story was based on 100% anonymous sourced. Unverified, unverifiable by definition. People who were on the scene went on record to deny it. Twitter and Facebook were happy to spread it. The Atlantic accounts were never blocked. How about the NYT story about Trump's tax returns, also based on 100% anonymous, unauthorized, unverified document leak? Has the NYT account been blocked for that, too? By contrast, the NYP actually did explain how they got the emails: from a laptop dropped off and signed for by Hunter Biden himself at a PC repair shop. The double standard here is beyond obvious.
- ericb 6y ago> By contrast, the NYP actually did explain how they got the emails: from a laptop dropped off and signed for by Hunter Biden himself at a PC repair shop. Yes, from a man who happens to be legally blind and can't verify who dropped it off. What are the priors on that? Turning up a week before the election? The was supposed to be a professional servicing a machine, he violated his clients privacy for his own purposes, and now we're to trust him?
- NeverFade 6y ago> Yes, from a man who happens to be legally blind and can't verify who dropped it off. Still more verifiable sources than the Atlantic and NYT stories, which were based on zero verifiable sources. > Turning up a week before the election? The Atlantic and NYT stories were also published very recently, also a few weeks before the election. > The was supposed to be a professional servicing a machine, he violated his clients privacy for his own purposes, and now we're to trust him? The NYT story was based on illegally leaked tax returns. Whoever leaked these documents has not only breached their duty of confidentiality and privacy that they owe every taxpayer - they in fact committed a crime. Why didn't Twitter and Facebook block a story that could only come from a source who breached their legal duties and committed a crime? And in your words, how can we trust such a source?
- scoot_718 6y ago> A newspaper with a better reputation for reporting the news than Twitter. Hard nope there.
- RoyTyrell 6y ago> It's not about the quality of the Post's journalism. It's about whether Twitter should restrict it. I agree with that. > A newspaper with a better reputation for reporting the news than Twitter. Twitter is a social media site that anyone can post on, it's not a news aggregation site and certainly isn't even a news generating company. Every news organization in the world could delete their Twitter account, and everyone could stop sharing links to news companies articles, and Twitter's purpose wouldn't change. Twitter doesn't hire journalists to research and write articles...
- madmulita 6y ago> Twitter is a social media site that anyone can post on... Anyone agreeing with Twitter's agenda, it appears.
- kyuudou 6y agoWhy is this being downvoted? Because of someone else's tip, I tried tweeting these 7 characters: gtv.org and had my account locked within 3 seconds. What kind of orwellian shit is that?!? The twitter account itself was used very sparingly to upload content from my PS4, not controversial in the least. There is very clearly an agenda being applied here. Which is fine with me because this kind of repression is indication of desperation.
- kyuudou 6y agoto whoever downvoted me, it's this simple. You are either: A platform. That allows all voices to be heard. 1st Amendment protections. A publisher. That can edit or censor. And can be sued for slander and libel. Whatever sophistry section 230 discussion is being fogged with, the above should be the way it is, period.
- 75dvtwin 6y agoTwitter restrict free speech using their selective outrage. It is morally reprehensible, but allowed. They are free to have their selective outrage, but they are a publisher, not a platform. And therefore cannot claim protections under 47.230 This is like claiming tax exceptions of a non-profit charity, while being a for profit business >" ... (c)Protection for “Good Samaritan” blocking and screening of offensive material (1)Treatment of publisher or speaker No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. (2)Civil liability No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be held liable on account of— (A)any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material that the provider or user considers to be obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected; or (B)any action taken to enable or make available to information content providers or others the technical means to restrict access to material described in paragraph (1).[1] ..." [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/230 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/230
- h0l0cube 6y ago>> Post publishes a lot of disreputable trash that's outright false or unproven > It doesn't matter. This strawman is presented every time this topic comes up. I can't ignore the irony here that you complain about straw-manning of the OP by cherry-picking the only negative comment in spite of the 99% of commentary in favor. Edit: I also can't ignore that the plaint of pervasive "echo chamber hyperbole" is juxtaposed with statements like these: > This strawman is presented every time this topic comes up. > This is literacy 101. > 99.9% of the Post criticism I see on HN is from people who have never lived in New York. Never actually read the Post, or any other newspaper.
- h0l0cube 6y agoGetting downvotes for this, not because there's any solid argument against what I'm saying, but because people are upset. The reason why I had to say something is because the GPs comment highlights much of what is wrong with online discourse. That 'The New York Post has more merit than people afford it' might be worthy claim, but making a bunch of loud baseless claims isn't the way to convince people of it.
- robertlagrant 6y agoIt's not people being upset, it's that talking about irony and juxtaposition is not helpful. Making a simple case is a lot more effective than vague comments on other people's cases.
- h0l0cube 6y ago> It's not people being upset If it wasn't they would have critiqued my comment as you have. But instead it was a string of drive-by down-votes. > it's that talking about irony and juxtaposition is not helpful I think it is important to point out bad faith dialogue wherever it is seen. And that's what I did, by pointing out the contradictions in the moral stance made, and then the poster completely disregarding them in the same breath. > vague comments on other people's cases. They weren't vague at all, they were very specific. The poster was making a rhetorical play rather than furthering the discussion, and I pointed it out with direct quotes.
- ykevinator 6y agoThe post and fox news are absolutely light weight versions of the national enquirer. Regardless, Twitter can do what Twitter likes. You can start your own Twitter if you like. Twitters rights are as precious as fox news's.
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>Regardless, Twitter can do what Twitter likes. Hopefully not for much longer, and what a sad day that will be for corporate bootlickers.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIt what sense are they lightweight not heavyweight?