8 ms·
Asteroid samples escaping from jammed NASA spacecraft
- rhn_mk1 6y agoIf the container is open, how are they planning to retrieve the sample without losing it on reentry?
- JshWright 6y agoThe container will be loaded inside a sealed reentry capsule.
- jimmydorry 6y ago> "Lauretta said there is nothing flight controllers can do to clear the obstructions and prevent more bits of Bennu from escaping, other than to get the samples into their return capsule as soon as possible." This, I'm guessing. Also, I found these parts interesting: >"Regardless of what’s on board, Osiris-Rex will still leave the vicinity of the asteroid in March — that’s the earliest possible departure given the relative locations of Earth and Bennu. The samples won’t make it back until 2023, seven years after the spacecraft rocketed away from Cape Canaveral." >Because of the sudden turn of events, scientists won’t know how much the sample capsule holds until it’s back on Earth. They initially planned to spin the spacecraft to measure the contents, but that maneuver was canceled since it could spill even more debris. >“I think we’re going to have to wait until we get home to know precisely how much we have,” Lauretta told reporters. “As you can imagine, that’s hard. ... But the good news is we see a lot of material.”
- rhn_mk1 6y agoThanks. That means there are two containers: the open one where the samples are now, and the sealed return capsule, where the contents will be transferred soon. In that light, this quote confuses me: > scientists won’t know how much the sample capsule holds until it’s back on Earth. They wanted to spin the spacecraft to measure the mass, but they can't risk losing more samples from an open container. But why can't they spin the spacecraft after the sample is secure in the return capsule, but before reaching Earth? Is it precisely in the center of mass?
- SamBorick 6y agoI recommend the scott manly video another commenter linked to for a more full explanation, but: The sample container that's currently jammed open is on the end of a long arm, while the sample return capsule is mounted on the body of the spacecraft. The only way to measure mass in free-fall is to spin the entire craft and measure where the center of rotation is compered to before the sample capture. The difference is then used to calculate the sample mass. With the sample at the end of a long arm, the spacecraft doesn't have to rotate very fast to get a large enough difference in rotation to measure the sample. If the sample is in the return capsule, the moment is so much smaller that it's probably below the sensitivity of the instruments they were planning to use.
- yetihehe 6y agoBright side - they have so much material, that weighting it is not really that much of a concern. They were hopeful to get maybe 50 grams of material, they got about 400g, but maybe 100g will be lost. They won't have exact number, but they will have more than expected anyway.
- Jaruzel 6y agoWon't the extra weight require a change in earth re-entry fuel calculation etc. ? Without knowing the exact change in weight, they are going to be firing in the dark, as it were.
- yetihehe 6y agoI don't know that much, but I suppose they will do a burn and then some corrections. If mass difference is big enough to be detectable for reentry, it will be detectable when they are going back to earth.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoA key difference is that spinning the full satellite with the arm extended and measuring the center of rotation measures the mass of the samples collected regardless of the thrusters/reaction wheels. Measuring the trajectory of the reentry vehicle gives a parameter that can be used to estimate the sample mass assuming nominal thrust values, but you can't distinguish between an underperforming or overperforming rocket engine and heavier or lighter samples. This ambiguity doesn't really matter for the purposes of burn correction - you need to get to the correct reentry trajectory no matter what caused the deviation - but your sample mass estimate may be off. I don't think there's a whole lot of utility in knowing the sample mass, as long as you've got enough (and they've definitely got enough!), it would just help satiate the curiosity of the scientists and engineers who otherwise have to wait a few more years to see their results.
- rtkwe 6y agoThere's a sample return vehicle that detaches with the sample canister inside of it. There's some concern with so much material floating around from the sample head no sealing properly that some bits might get in the way though. Scott Manley has a pretty good video about it as per usual when there's slightly vague space news. I've linked directly to where he's talking about the sample return portion of the mission. https://youtu.be/cmQfWuFbLNg?t=443 https://youtu.be/cmQfWuFbLNg?t=443
- JshWright 6y agoAs with all "current events in space", Scott Manley has an excellent video on this. https://youtu.be/cmQfWuFbLNg https://youtu.be/cmQfWuFbLNg
- augusto-moura 6y ago> Blowing a raspberry in the surface of the asteroid Classic Manley
- lolbot 6y agoFrom TFV: "In order to be able to perform the landing they needed to update their software to give it optical navigation abilities ..." Imagine being part of the team that had to do that, fast, chop-chop, or else their billion dollar space mission would fail miserably. "Oh, you only need us to implement vision. Ok, no biggie."
- londons_explore 6y agoI assume it was more a case of "We have an algorithm that successfully lands the craft 80% of the time, but we would like it to be 99% of the time, so get to working on it..."
- peterwoerner 6y agoUsually its 99.7% percent of the time: three standard deviations.
- moron4hire 6y ago"So they actually performed a software upgrade of on the spacecraft to give it optical navigation capabilities..." God dammit. And here I have trouble getting software updates into a server I have full control over on Earth.
- shadowgovt 6y ago
- 7373737373 6y agoIs a second touchdown possible?
- bo0tzz 6y agoNo, the spacecraft is already on a trajectory away from the asteroid, and any further maneuvering is not an option until the sample capsule has been stowed to avoid more debris spilling.
- NortySpock 6y agoDisagree. The sample arm was designed with spare gas for up to 3 sampling attempts, so they could go back and get more if they didn't have enough. Since their sample-cup is filled to the brim and spilling over on the first attempt, they are choosing to stow the sample container, rather than go for another (redundant) attempt with an already-full sample container.
- yetihehe 6y agoSecond touchdown would be required if they didn't caught enough material first time. Since they got 10x too much, even if they lose half it's not a tragedy.
- codeulike 6y agoNot really 'jammed', I think they mean 'jam packed' edit: ok I see, it jammed because it was jam packed
- peeters 6y agoIt's jammed. There's a film that was supposed to close on the collector to keep the material inside, but because of debris it wasn't able to close, so material is escaping.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoI'm concerned that they'll have a hard time closing the reentry vehicle, that its hinge and hermetically sealing systems will become jammed open as well. There's no one available to wipe the gravel and dust off the sealing surface with their finger... I'm not involved in the project, but I do work on terrestrial automation projects, often involving CNCs - chip management to prevent swarf accumulating on your hard stops and tapers is a real problem! Here, we have plenty of compressed air as well as gravity to clear chips, and preventative maintenance schedules for the stuff that the automated cleanup processes missed, and we remove parts to cleanrooms for important measurement stages, but that spacecraft is basically floating in a cloud of gravel...not a good environment for precision seals!
- hikerclimb 6y agoGood. Hopefully it never comes unstuck
- ChicagoBoy11 6y agoAt the original 60oz/$800 million dollars, would that make it the most expensive bit of mineral on Earth in 2023?
- moron4hire 6y agoProbably still cheaper than 1st-party printer ink.
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoonly about 10x more expensive than tritium.
- jccooper 6y agoThat's $13,333,333.33/oz, if you charge the whole cost to sample collection. They also get plenty of other science observations, but the main point was sample return. Apollo brought back 842lb of samples for something like $260 billion (inflation adjusted), that being $19,299,287.41/oz. Of course, science was basically a side-effect of Apollo, so you can't really charge it all to sample collection. But if you did, the moon rocks are pricier.
- ChicagoBoy11 6y agoI appreciate you doing the math! Kinda amusing that it comes out to roughly the same order of magnitude!
- DonCopal 6y agoStardust cost 200 million and collected a few grams at most. Hayabusa cost 100 million and collected less than 1 gram. I think those two beat Osiris in price/weight.
- bullen 6y agoImagine the pickup managed to deviate the asteroids course so that it hits us! You wanted 100 grammes of rock, 78 billion kg incoming! :D
- hinkley 6y agoSo no max depth set into the software controlling the excavating arm? "Bugs are boundary conditions we refused to take seriously."
- macintux 6y agoWatch the Manley video linked elsewhere in the comment thread. The capture was entirely analog.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 6y agoThat is the weirdest sampling tool I've seen NASA build. I disagree that it was an analog system. They were measuring force as a proxy for contact, with no depth-finding system in place. The arm just sank in and never hit the force threshold for the automated system to react.
- burnte 6y agoIt was expected to hit the surface, NOT plow into it like a pile of gravel, use the blower to grab particles in the bucket, then blast backwards. Instead, it DID plow into the asteroid like a pile of gravel, even at a slow 40cm/sec. It was thought it would be much more solid than it turned out to be. It had no way of controlling how far it went in.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI think due to Newton's 2nd law retracting the arm prematurely would've caused the rest of the probe to strike the surface of the asteroid Edit: and by 2nd law, I really mean 3rd
- moron4hire 6y agoI'm sure NASA has thought of this, but won't the mylar film close if the sampling disk loses some material, before it loses all of its material? Why not give it a shake to get some of it out so the seal can close?
- rtkwe 6y agoIf there's a piece wedged tightly in there it could let most of the rest of the sample out without dislodging the piece holding it open.
- trynewideas 6y agoHow bad would it be if a piece large enough to wedge the entire container open was the _only_ piece we recover? How big would that piece have to be? Are they expecting a certain diversity in the sample that would be lost if they only got one huge piece?
- rtkwe 6y agoI think the scientific goal was 60 grams which is more than just one piece at the size of the gathering head so they'd have to decide which tests they would actually do instead of being able to do all of the planned tests. So yeah just getting one larger piece would be a loss for the mission.
- doodlebugging 6y agoAfter watching the video from Scott Manley (great video) I can see how the sampling mechanism is supposed to work. I wonder whether they can make use of momentum to close the sample doors and capture the samples preventing closure. Since there are some chunks preventing closure and they had planned to be able to sample more than once in the event that the first attempt didn't recover enough material that means that they can control the opening and closing of the sample doors. It seems to me, having grown up as a kid being transported in an old Pontiac station wagon back before seat belts, that you could extend the arm behind Osiris-Rex pointing opposite the direction of travel and then trigger the doors open just as you fire to decelerate and the particles preventing closure should zoom into the collector like preschoolers into the windshield of that old station wagon when the brakes were applied.
- rtkwe 6y agoThe sample doors are just a flap that gets blown open by the nitrogen during sample gathering then springs shut, there's no direct control over them, the solution is to just pack it away in the return canister very carefully.
- doodlebugging 6y agoI figured it couldn't be that easy or they would already have considered it. Springs are probably more reliable for that application on a spacecraft. Thanks for clarifying that for me.
- rtkwe 6y agoMy rule of thumb is NASA/JPL/JAXA/ESA are full of far smarter people than me so if I think of it in 5 minutes they definitely thought of it already and have a binder full of reasons it's not the best option.
- SeanFerree 6y agoThe aliens will be displeased with all the scattered debris
- american_aurora 6y ago"Why didn't they plan for a soft asteroid?" is the annoying question I am sure the team will be asked, and I do not the answer.