7 ms·
I guess the point of the post in particular is the London outlier but honestly I've always found comparisons of CCTV with 'surveillance' in a meaningful sense o
by Barrin92 6y ago
I guess the point of the post in particular is the London outlier but honestly I've always found comparisons of CCTV with 'surveillance' in a meaningful sense of the term pretty cartoonish. Obviously living in London is not like living in some police state.
The same goes for China even. Public camera surveillance I think mostly does what it's supposed to do with very little intrusion into people's daily lives, in contrast to old school police stops and frisks. Travelling I've had more bad run ins with corrupt cops in Bulgaria than I had in Beijing.
- donaltroddyn 6y ago.
- baby 6y agoNot saying that surveillance is right, but I've lived in London for a year and a half and never felt this way, I don't think I've ever talked to someone who felt this way there, you must be a very paranoid individual. I will say this though: having lived in both Beijing and London, I've always felt ultra safe (and I lived in London during some terrorist attacks). On the other hand, I lived in SF for the same time and I never felt safe there, avoiding walks at night, avoiding public transport for the most part, avoiding some streets, etc. I also lived in Chicago and I felt much worse there (at least in SF I could still take walks).
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoNot to discount your feelings completely, but I’m always a little skeptical when someone says a place “feels” safe or unsafe. Do you have reason to believe you actually were less safe in San Francisco compared to London?
- baby 6y agoMy first two weeks in SF I took the bus twice, the first time a group of kids started slapping random people, I was prepared to fight and protect my SO but they didn't get to me; the second time some guy just ran and took a girl's phone, she grabbed to it for what seemed like a full minute, screaming and shit, then finally let go... I was paralyzed, especially after the event of the previous week, after that I vouched not to ever take the bus again in SF. After that some homeless people screamed at me, some tried to punch me slowly (easy to avoid), I got used to it with time but it's still not a nice feeling to take walks. I wouldn't let my SO walk alone at 3AM through the streets for example (while I would have no problems with that in London or Beijing).
- Veen 6y agoMurder rate in London, including terrorism: 1.6 per 100,000. Murder rate in San Francisco: 5.17 per 100,000.
- Scoundreller 6y agoWould London or Beijing turn into a Chicago or SF if it weren’t for CCTV? Would Chi or SF become a London or Beijing with CCTV? Doubtful to both. But a lot can be explained by social determinants of wealth and what that turns people into.
- Google234 6y agoWhy is baby’s response flagged and dead ?!?!?? He literally just gave his perspective as a person living in that city. The people that flagged them should be banned from this site.
- detaro 6y agoI assume they took offence with the "you must be very paranoid" just because someone feels odd about surveillance. It certainly seems pretty rude to me.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- donaltroddyn 6y ago.
- monksy 6y ago> I also lived in Chicago and I felt much worse there (at least in SF I could still take walks). Depends where you are and what times. 3am on the redline in the northside.. Be ready to move at a moments notice.
- noncoml 6y agoOn the other hand, although I find driving in SF much more stressful and confusing than London(despite being a native RHT driver), I never managed to get a ticket in SF. Every time I visit London I keep getting letters with some bullshit traffic violation captured by a camera for months after I am back. Also having lived in London for 7 years, I can't say I felt safe walking at night other than in the very central places. Try visiting Elephant and Castle or Seven Sisters alone during the night. Edit: spelling
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> although I find driving in SF much more stressful and confusing than London(despite being a native RHT driver), I never managed to get a ticket in SF. Did you ever park outside a parking garage?
- CaptainZapp 6y agoDid you enter the congestion zone without paying? That's fined pretty swiftly.
- lmm 6y ago> Try visiting Elephant and Castle or Seven Sisters alone during the night. Did that many times, it was fine? Only place I've ever felt unsafe was Brentford after I got hassled there.
- fastball 6y agoI think non-CCTV plastered European cities is probably a more apt comparison than Chicago and San Francisco, two cities that have a reputation for being unsafe in the US (which has major problems with violent crime across the board).
- seppin 6y ago> This is not obvious to me. London subjectively feels like an oppressively surveilled and policed city to me any time I spend time there, and avoid it for that reason. Spend some time in a real autocracy, then see if you feel the same way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mortenjorck 6y agoThis is a critical point, that CCTV and surveillance are two different, interrelated things. Imagine you appear on 50 different CCTV cameras on an average day. Now imagine two different scenarios: Scenario A: Each one of these cameras is operated by a local business or property management company. The cameras record video that gets overwritten within a few days if there are no incidents or requests from law enforcement. Scenario B: All of these cameras are on a network operated by a company with contracts for the city, law enforcement, and digital advertising networks. Facial recognition technology tracks you across all 50 locations, with an "anonymized" identifier attached to your biometrics. This identifier can be cross-referenced with other "anonymized" identifiers to build an advertising profile, while another contractor's machine learning system builds a threat profile based on movements of these identifiers, flagging outliers for human review. Both scenarios have the same number of cameras, but I don't think many would consider the two comparable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwawaygh 6y agoWorth thinking about how the scenarios converge when a few companies capture the commercial surveillance market and everything is streamed directly to a cloud storage account.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoAnd this. Which is EXACTLY what Ring figured out and so they took all those doorbell cameras, gave local law enforcement access, and now even on residential streets there are hundreds of cameras they have easy access too.
- dmix 6y agoRing is evil and all, but since we have a problem with them one of us genius hackers should make a product that has the functionality and critically the same UX but... doesn't use the 'cloud'. The sharing with LEO will always then be optionally and at your option, which still provides a similar net security benefit. Purely localized home storage and IOT stuff which offers similar features like remote access and whatnot, is clearly a really, really difficult problem to solve. Just like smartphone being essentially your entire one ISP coordinated popping from having your whole life in any security agencies hands. Maybe we need an organization like OpenAI to solve this problem. Like OpenHome or something. A place we can centralize our developer resources to providing a solution to this obvious proto-police state that is being developed out of pure utility, aka usefulness. Right now my friends moms washing machine and coffee maker are all wifi connected to be controlled and notified when done remotely from here phone. It's entering out lives fast and we need a solution and startups offering similarlly good products - or a private solution which can be sold to the manufacturers like Whirlpool.
- noncoml 6y ago> London is not like living in some police state I lived there for 7 years and I don't share the same feelings. Sure it's not like you live in 1984 but it feels much more like a "police state" in comparison to the rest European capitals.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoYou can get tossed in prison for saying the "wrong thing", which strikes me as a pretty police state thing. Examples: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/uk-man-jailed-over-facebook-status-raises-questions-over-free-speech/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/uk-man-jailed-over-facebook-sta... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-offensive-facebook-and-twitter-posts-soar-london-a7064246.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-offensive-face... https://thesuffolkjournal.com/26253/opinion/detainment-of-british-woman-for-misgendering-person-shows-free-speech-is-under-attack-in-uk/ https://thesuffolkjournal.com/26253/opinion/detainment-of-br... https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/count-dankula-freedom-speech-comedy-joke-iran-offended-a8270631.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/count-dankula-freedom-s...
- markb139 6y agoIn the context of London and the UK “get tossed in prison” has an alternative meaning
- swebs 6y ago>On Feb. 9, The Daily Mail in the U.K. published a story detailing the harrowing detainment of 38-year-old Kate Scottow. Scottow, a resident of Hertfordshire, England, was handcuffed in front of her autistic ten-year-old daughter and breastfeeding 20-month-old son, brought into custody and held for seven hours in a single jail cell. >What heinous action warranted such drastic measures? The crime of “misgendering,” or calling a transgender individual by their biologically determined set of pronouns instead of their preferred pronouns, precipitated Scottow’s arrest. Stephanie Hayden, a biological male who recently transitioned to identifying as female on social media, reported Scottow to the police. If you would have tried to tell people 10 years ago that this actually happened, people would have thought you were crazy, or accuse you of promoting the slippery slope fallacy.
- bleepblorp 6y ago> Obviously living in London is not like living in some police state. In recent years, the police in London had a policy to harass anyone who was seen using a camera in a large, but completely unpublished, geofenced region of the city. That's not US/China/Saudi-level police state bad--as in, the UK police aren't able to arbitrarily confiscate cash or shoot people with impunity for having the wrong skin color--but it's bad enough that I consider such behavior a feature of a police state. Any jurisdiction where it's not possible to perform the normal functions of everyday life, including creating works of art through photography, without fear of hostile police interaction is to some degree or other a police state.
- Symbiote 6y agoIs that this case, from 10 years ago? https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/dec/15/yates-police-terrorism-powers-photography https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/dec/15/yates-police-terr...
- qz2 6y agoI've had a couple of run-on this front. I spent a couple of years photographing industrial landscapes in London. Unless you are trespassing then you can tell them to hop it. Being arrested wrongfully is quite profitable for the receiver of the arrest and they are usually intimidated by reminding them of that in return.
- bigiain 6y ago> and they are usually intimidated by reminding them of that Would I be wrong to assume you say that from a position of middle class white privilege? (A position I also hold, but from which I have significant empathy with those who do not.) I'm guessing intimidating police by reminding them of the laws they're supposed to uphold works a lot less well for young black kids.
- qz2 6y agoYes on both counts. The latter is a travesty and a very real problem.
- PrinceKropotkin 6y agoI can just google "london police harassment" and see plenty of evidence the UK has issues with policing.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI think the problem is that the infrastructure is being being built up. Even if they aren’t using the cameras right now for surveillance, the infrastructure is ready to be used be a bad actor in the future. I think that’s the real risk of building this up.
- bergstromm466 6y ago> I've always found comparisons of CCTV with 'surveillance' in a meaningful sense of the term pretty cartoonish I think your experience is related to class. When I read your comment I think - ok they must be a Petty Bourgeoisie or Bourgeoisie. CCTV is used to catch and punish so called 'criminals'. But when many public spaces and parks in London have been sold off/privatized[1], and the Commons has been plundered everywhere (IP, knowledge, etc.)[2], the laws punishing 'theft' are pretty laughable to me. In my research lately, I've been coming to the conclusion that maybe the ones who are making the laws are the real criminals. There are systemic thefts taking place: the slow privatization of public lands, the pay-to-play dynamics of modern day law, and the plunder of the educational and knowledge Commons through Intellectual Monopoly - making human curiousity illegal. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jul/05/revealed-how-london-parks-are-partly-privatised-festivals-wireless-finsbury-park https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jul/05/revealed-how-... [2] https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/plunder-commons-compensate-commoners/ https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/plunder-commons-...
- fastball 6y agoAnecdotal, but in my experience living in London, CCTV does fuck all. I've been robbed / stolen from multiple times in London, all caught on CCTV, never once helpful in apprehending any criminals or getting my possessions back to me. And clearly not a great deterrent, as I've been the victim of more crimes in London than anywhere else.
- torified 6y agoWouldn't it be nice if you could access all that CCTV infrastructure that the public paid for, to investigate for yourself...
- djmobley 6y agoI’m sorry to hear about your experience, but have you considered that this was a reasonable outcome of a cost-benefit analysis? It’s a time-consuming and costly process to collect, review and pursue CCTV evidence. If you’re the victim of a relatively minor property crime (e.g. having your phone or laptop stolen) it’s probably not worth the police pursuing it. If, on the other hand, you are the victim of serious violent crime (murder, attempted murder, rape, assault, etc.), the police most certainly do trawl the area for cameras, request footage, review and identify suspects, issue appeals, etc.