3 ms·
You'd have to nail down what rhetoric you mean for me to have any response to that.
by shadowgovt 6y ago
You'd have to nail down what rhetoric you mean for me to have any response to that.
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoI don't think specific examples are really useful here. At the end of the day, either I'm allowed to say "I am not a racist" at work and be left alone for making that statement, or I'm not. If I'm not, it's a cryptofascist struggle session.
- shadowgovt 6y agoWithout specific examples, I have no idea if I am committing a motte and bailey fallacy because the specific examples I have in my mind are the weaker example, the specific examples the speaker has in their mind are a different example, I've never experienced their example (but have experienced people experiencing my example and treating it as something more draconian that could, perhaps, approximate their example). So not much more to say on this topic without specific examples.
- rayiner 6y agoThe example is in my OP: It's a session where white people acknowledge that they take personal responsibility for participating in a system of "white privilege" and admit to being "racist" and "gatekeepers of white supremacy." (That's the bailey.) By contrast, your motte: "training on how to work with people from diverse backgrounds.
- shadowgovt 6y agoHonestly, I don't see much distinction between teaching people about structural privilege and suggesting they admit they benefit from it. Difference of degree, perhaps, but not much. You trusted your alma mater when you were taught there; not trusting the direction it's taking now? Is it possible you're not seeing the picture the way they are?
- maxwindiff 6y agoBenefitting from structural privileges is very different from being a racist though.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn computer security, we often talk about the lack of distinction between malice and ignorance---if the security system is bad, it doesn't matter if the attacker is intent on causing harm or merely innocently curious and hack-sawing away through your computer security for fun. The outcome is the same. I think the same principle applies here. Malicious racism and passive racism have the same effect.
- tpxl 6y agoI'll bite, what the fuck is passive racism?
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe unconscious biases people walk around with in their heads. They're things people pick up without realizing it that lead to friction for minorities in society. Studies have shown that people who don't think themselves to be actually racist still act in race-discriminatory ways. For example, people with non-ethic-names get more callbacks for their resume controlled for qualifications on the resume (https://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/employers-replies-racial-names https://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/employers-replies-racial-n...).
- tpxl 6y agoSo a bad way to say unconscious racism.
- darawk 6y ago"Ism" is a suffix that implies a philosophy. An ism is a suite of beliefs. Anything that is unconscious is, by definition, not an ism. Racism refers to people with a philosophy of racial hierarchy, or ideas about race that evoke or imply such a philosophy. For instance, Buddhism is a suite of beliefs about enlightenment and transcendence. We don't refer to people as "structural Buddhists" simply because they have equanimity.