5 ms·
Is there any real proof that these diversity sessions actually help people work in diverse environments? The way you describe this, it reads like a really, real
by zozbot234 6y ago
Is there any real proof that these diversity sessions actually help people work in diverse environments? The way you describe this, it reads like a really, really weird cargo cult where just confessing to one's supposed racism will somehow make you more open to people of differing backgrounds. How exactly does this help?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _iyig 6y agoIn the manner of all business consulting, it 'helps' by letting management say, "Look, we hired a consultant! We care deeply about ____ and have given it our best shot. If any problems related to ____ arise in the future, blame the consultant." In this case, the blank is diversity and inclusion.
- michaelt 6y agoDemanding people declare they are racists sounds very strange to me - I'm not sure that would help things much. But I've also seen some people do some pretty oblivious things in my time - like ordering company tee-shirts for their mixed-gender team, but only getting male sizes. Or evaluating every interview candidate's communication skills and cultural fit based on a conversation about rock climbing and craft beer. And other stuff managers might need to get good at aren't taught at home or in college. If you get performance complaints about an otherwise-good employee who is fasting during Ramadan, what's the right way to address that while respecting privacy and being fair to the complainant, complainee and the company? I can understand why an employer might want their employees to have a bit of extra training, above and beyond what college and life experience have already taught them. At least for the employees destined for promotion to senior positions.
- JamesBarney 6y agoWhile I'm sure there are complicated issues around race and gender that training can give you the tools to solve these examples seems pretty easy to fix. > Or evaluating every interview candidate's communication skills and cultural fit based on a conversation about rock climbing and craft beer. I feel like any cultural fit test is going to be inherently sexist/racist/classist. Better to just throw them out. Also why waste time talking about anything not relevant to the job to judge communication skills when you could be having job related discussions. > If you get performance complaints about an otherwise-good employee who is fasting during Ramadan, what's the right way to address that while respecting privacy and being fair to the complainant, complainee and the company? Is the complaint this person isn't doing their job? Then it should be treated like every other complaint. Is the complaint is "They aren't eating lunch" then it should be treated very differently.
- michaelt 6y ago> Is the complaint this person isn't doing their job? Then it should be treated like every other complaint. Sure, but how is that? Different performance problems call for different solutions. Do you treat it like the newly hired dyslexic person? Like the person who's going through a difficult divorce? Like the person who likes to party and sometimes comes in tired or hung over? Like the person with gaps in their education and training? Like the parent who sometimes gets called for child-related emergencies? Like the person who disagrees with the policies, but can be convinced with better explanation? Like the person who finds the work too boring to be able to concentrate on? Like the person who doesn't like the job, but hasn't found another yet? A competent manager will have half a dozen different tools in their toolbox - and it takes some forethought to be able to reach for the correct one first time on receipt of a complaint.
- JamesBarney 6y agoLike any other performance issue limited to a month each year. If it's mild and they're otherwise a great employee probably just ignore it. If it's large drop in performance that is having a material impact on the team, document the performance impact, take any steps necessary to mitigate the impact of the drop in performance and ask if there is anything you can do to help them improve their performance.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThese are all valuable things to address, but in my experience they're not what corporate diversity programs do. I'm scrolling through my company's diversity page right now, and the front page from top to bottom contains: * An affirmation that we stand with the black community. * A list of political organizations we should donate to in support of the black community. * TED talks on how news, policing, etc. are sometimes implicitly racist. (We as a company aren't involved in news or policing.) * A reimbursement offer for up to $1,000 per person on anti-racism materials. * Recommended articles, books, etc. There's a lot of other stuff in tabs and menus and such. But if I didn't know how to handle an employee with poor performance during the Ramadan fast, none of the information I see would help me figure it out, and it's my understanding that this is typical.
- coldtea 6y ago>Is there any real proof that these diversity sessions actually help people work in diverse environments? I'd say no for the most part. It's mostly hypocrisy and everyone knows is theater, which creates boredom at best, and bad blood at worst. Diversity is built organically, not through sessions. It's like those bogus "we're a big family" pep sessions -- and then the company screws you over.
- username90 6y agoNo. But the goal isn't for it to work, the goal of the advocates is to bill a lot of money and the goal of the company is to virtue signal. https://hbr.org/2012/03/diversity-training-doesnt-work https://hbr.org/2012/03/diversity-training-doesnt-work
- monoideism 6y ago> he goal of the advocates is to bill a lot of money and the goal of the company is to virtue signal. You miss the biggest goal: for departments of diversity, inclusion, etc to gain more power and hires.
- shadowgovt 6y agoMy observation at past employers has been that D&I teams are consistently under-staffed and overwhelmed.
- remarkEon 6y agoI've long wondered if this is the reason large, established companies (tech or non-tech) pour money into these seminars. It acts as a barrier to entry for smaller competitors who don't have giant piles of cash to spend on things like this, but now they have to because, well, they don't want to be the "racist startup".
- beaconstudios 6y agoMy understanding is that it's to placate activist employees (or, if management are activists, to play out their beliefs).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>Is there any real proof that these diversity sessions actually help people work in diverse environments? I read a study a while back, which I can't find right now, that concluded that these sessions do more harm than good in the workplace. One study I could find, which might be of relevant interest, is that diverse workplaces are far less likely to come together and organize in terms of unions or worker rights[0], which might go some way to back up the suspicion this whole shitshow we've been submerged into is merely a big-money attempt to turn normal people against one another by provoking racial tensions to prevent them from becoming class conscious and instigating a movement like Occupy Wall Street again. >How exactly does this help? It doesn't. The entire purpose of it is ritual humiliation. [0]https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0019793915602253 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0019793915602253
- snowwrestler 6y agoNot yet, but these are still pretty new to corporate environments. I've been in "harassment prevention" training sessions for years, but only within the last year sat through my first "diversity, equity, and inclusion" (DEI) training. (It was not an inquisition; quite helpful in the opinion of this middle aged white guy.) There is research that shows that companies with diverse leadership and staff financially outperform the average. See for example: https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/diversity-and-inclusion/diversity-wins-how-inclusion-matters# https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/diversity-and-inc... The problem is, no one knows for sure how to take an existing corporate culture with low diversity, and transform it to one with higher diversity and higher performance. Cultures can be extremely resistant to change. DEI trainings are just the latest attempt to find something that works. It will take a few years to see if they do.
- Udik 6y ago> There is research that shows that companies with diverse leadership and staff financially outperform the average Ah, that looks like a nice bit of marketing from McKinsey. Huge companies that work on global markets with clearly recognizable brands are naturally more diverse (sourcing people from all over the world) and also care about their public image enough to increase their diversity in management positions. Of course this doesn't mean at all that by increasing diversity your performance will improve, the causal arrow goes in the opposite direction.
- JamesBarney 6y agoI'm super suspicious of research like that for a couple of reasons. One it would it be impossible to publish research that came to the opposite conclusion. Imagine seeing a headline that said "replacing female and black executive leadership with old white dudes increases profit" by McKinsey. Second the magnitude of the impact seems insane. This seems larger than the difference most studies find between good leadership and average leadership. And while I wouldn't be surprised if diverse leadership is marginally better than non-diverse leadership I would be surprised if it's larger than the difference between average and good. Three they're pulling from many different countries which could potentially create huge confounds. In general "research" that comes out of a place like McKinsey and Bane is pretty suspect but something like this is even more. Even if none of the other problems are real they still don't establish causation. It could easily be the case that diverse candidates are harder to find, so more competitive/better firms are able to better attract them. I think diversity is great and there are lots of great reasons to increase it but I doubt the impact on profitability would be anything beyond marginal.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoYes I suspect some one suggesting to HR that one of the ways to increase diversity and combat institutionalised racism would to be a transparent pay survey might be in trouble.
- ljm 6y agoIt sounds like someone took Alcoholics Anonymous, kept the bit where you admit you're an alcoholic, and then dropped the rest of it. Not that having the rest of it would be any better, but the whole thing sounds utterly regressive.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThey do sometimes cause Googlers to out themselves as a hostile work environment hazard and get fired. So, benefit there. ;)
- DontTellAnyone 6y agoThe goal isn't really to "help people work in diverse environments". That's just a euphemism. What it really is, is a power grab to push white men out and people of color and ironically also white women in (who can always fall back on their gender to acclaim victim status and oppression).