3 ms·
Funny to see an odd quirk from my hometown pop up here. We visited the current tree (Son of...) as school kids and heard the story. Imho, it's persisted in Ath
by ethbr0 6y ago
Funny to see an odd quirk from my hometown pop up here. We visited the current tree (Son of...) as school kids and heard the story.
Imho, it's persisted in Athens, GA lore because of the idea's memetic virality rather than legal validity.
In other words, people find the idea of a beloved tree that owns itself just and right, and so do what they can legally and simply play along when legal possibilities are insufficient. Effectively, the tree wins a cultural victory.
The idea also resonates with two major themes in southern heritage and culture, now that I'm looking at this from an older pespective: quasi-religious responsibility to the land and an ethical struggle with slavery of intelligent beings.
The first is fairly self explanatory, in the Teddy Roosevelt-esque mold of being stewards of nature, while using its bounty.
The latter... post-Reconstruction southern culture has a complicated relationship with the idea of slavery in broader form, for obvious reasons, and manifesting in myriad ways (healthy and unhealthy).
So the idea of a living being (undeniably) beloved by its owner (undeniably) being granted freedom from ownership on the owner's death... is about the only just and moral tale you can tell with respect to a tradition of slavery (leaving aside the inconvenient "it took until the owner's death" timing). Note the legend sourcing back to ~40 years pre-Civil War (1820s), although obviously maintained post- as well.
I'm not one to pull current hot button topics into tortured historical analogies, but here I think it's apt.
The concrete idea of a tree owning itself is dumb.
And yet, the people of Athens, GA and visitors want to believe in a world where that's possible. And for ~200 years have acted to support that belief.
As a child, it instilled a belief in me that the legal system existed to codify our desires, not limit them, regardless of how odd they may be. Which probably wasn't the worst lesson for a young child to take away.
- m463 6y ago> The concrete idea of a tree owning itself is dumb. What about a corporation being a person?
- amelius 6y agoGiven time, that person usually turns into a jerk.
- jimktrains2 6y agoI'm curious what your alternative is for corporations to sign contracts and for the speech of a collective of people to be as unrestricted as it is for an individual person.
- ethbr0 6y ago>> The concrete idea of a tree owning itself is dumb. > What about a corporation being a person? What about a group of trees being a corporation? The difference is that humans can articulate their preferences in ways that other humans can understand. Trees cannot (nor are we equiped to listen to what they can say). Although the idea of a tree-owned corporation is pretty enticing.