5 ms·
I don't think it's as hard to keep a site from sliding as one might think from the examples of previous sites where things went downhill as they got more popula
by pg 18y ago
I don't think it's as hard to keep a site from sliding as one might think from the examples of previous sites where things went downhill as they got more popular. Slashdot, Digg, and Reddit were all companies. They wanted to grow. Whereas News.YC is a side project. We don't care about growth. It's much easier to do things to keep up the quality when you're willing to sacrifice growth.
- deepster 18y agoAs long as the desire for excellent content outweighs the desire for growth and the users vote down irrelevant stories, then we are good to go.
- Hexstream 18y agoWe can't downvote stories here...
- jmatt 18y agoYou can when you get a high enough karma.
- PieSquared 18y agoReally? What's the number?
- jmatt 18y agoI'm not sure. But I have enough karma at 85. I think the number has changed over time, but I'm not sure. Maybe PG will share it with us or someone has recently hit the magic number?
- rms 18y agoYou sure you don't mean comments?
- jmatt 18y agoYeah my bad, I'm talking about comments.
- iamelgringo 18y agoMy karma's 4700 and I can't downvote stories.
- Hexstream 18y agoI have 867 karma and can't downvote stories. At some point there were talks of letting the top X downvote stories but I don't think it's been done.
- jmatt 18y agoYeah it's calculated. I thought you were talking about comments. Or it was last time news.arc was released by PG (= gravity* 1.4 timebase* 120 front-threshold* 1) (def frontpage-rank (s (o gravity gravity*)) (/ (- (realscore s) 1) (expt (/ (+ (item-age s) timebase*) 60) gravity))) http://github.com/nex3/arc/tree/master/news.arc http://github.com/nex3/arc/tree/master/news.arc
- froo 18y agoAs a relative newcomer here, I sincerely hope lolcats are a bannable offense.
- henning 18y agoEventually you will grow and you will need to start making things bannable. What you also need to have is a probation system where you can't post for anywhere from 4 hours to a month depending on what you do. That acts as a warning. Get put on probation too many times and you're banned. That's how it works at Something Awful, and they still have pretty good quality after almost 10 years. And they are for-profit. Also, it might be desirable to extra strict during certain times when people are likely to go berzerk and act really stupid (the SA moderators call this the "banhammer" and make a sticky thread notifying users when it is in effect -- what would normally be a warning becomes a ban).
- queensnake 18y agoNo, S.A. is a pay site, it's some trouble to get yourself a new credit card, but on free sites you just make a new alias.
- EliAndrewC 18y agoAlthough that's true, the new account won't have any karma, which actually matters on Hacker News, since it affects whether you can downvote, etc. So while banning certainly won't have the same effect as on S.A., it can be useful despite how easy it is to create new accounts.
- gwc 18y agoIs it sufficient to simply not target growth as a goal? HN, if I'm not mistaken, has kept a general upward trend in number of users; presumably, this is accompanied by an ever-increasing variance in quality of those users and what they consider to be interesting news and good etiquette. Don't get me wrong; I certainly agree that it is easier to make changes with an eye towards quality when you're not concerned about growth. However, I do wonder if there it a point where the dark side of network effects, which are primarily sociological in nature, will simply overwhelm any technological aspects or other moves on the part of a community's stewards / leaders.
- stcredzero 18y ago"Is it sufficient to simply not target growth as a goal?" Growth is a big part of the problem. It's much the same for movies. You can either appeal to a more discriminating audience, which is inherently smaller, or go lowest common denominator. Actually, the pattern is to start out appealing to the discriminating crowd to get a "cool" cachet, then expand and go mass-market. Another big problem is the monkey-see-monkey-do nature of Homo Sapiens. Over time, you will see more noise in the form of attempts at imitating signal instead of true signal.
- william-newman 18y agoIt is not sufficient simply not to target growth. But not targeting growth removes what is otherwise one helluva tough design constraint for a filter system. Imagine writing a spam filter when you're being paid by beancounters whose bottom line is maximizing the number of messages. Even, sometimes, beancounters who face strong temptation to maximize the number of bytes of email this quarter and worry about the longer-than-a-month-term consequences later. Also, some kinds of filtering (and related things, like informal community norms) don't scale, so if the community hasn't grown too much, the problem might tend to be easier. Hacker-oriented mailing lists with 100 posters don't seem to be too hard to moderate, but I'm not eager to try 10,000 posters.
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoMetafilter simply turned off new user registration for a long time when they didn't like where things were going.
- zppx 18y agoIn one word: focus.
- rthomas6 18y agoThat excites me. I am also a newcomer from Reddit. I believe I'll stick around now, since, being a student majoring in computer engineering, this interests me. Feel free to ban me if my comments become too low quality. :)
- Neoryder 18y agoI think this has always been the key. Its like the mom/pop store versus the Walmart super stores. They need (digg/reddit) to be popular to be a viable acquisition target or business whereas hacker news is just a place where we try to find like minded people trying to share information and grow learn together.
- HansF 18y agoActually, slashdot manages pretty well. Considering the number of users they have. Their moderation system has matured over time. And the typical WTF, 'funny pics' and youtube crap that ruins other sites is isolated on http://idle.slashdot.org/ http://idle.slashdot.org/ where it can harm no-one. I think it starts with comment moderation ( http://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml http://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml ). It's hard to get karma on /. by just fooling around, and you have to be a dedicated user to even get to moderate other comments. Contrary to digg where a sensible comment about X can be downmodded into oblivion by an army of 13 year old fanboys.