3 ms·
It's hard to be loved when one wants to take money away from other people and their projects. A more promising line of action would be building another communit
by pmontra 6y ago
It's hard to be loved when one wants to take money away from other people and their projects. A more promising line of action would be building another community of particle physicists with different goals than building a bigger collider, possibly aligned with Hossenfelder's suggestions. In this way they'll have something to gain and will fight for the budget that otherwise would go into the collider.
- jrumbut 6y agoI'm not sure we're improving anything when we discover some public good is flawed, mediocre, or maybe even a little corrupt and respond by tearing it down and replacing it with nothing. I think we've done enough of that. At this point I'm really only interested in positive proposals, what new stuff can we do? If we have a wave of new successes any old failures will fade out on their own.
- pmontra 6y agoHossenfelder proposes the stuff at point 18 of http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/03/nonsense-arguments-for-building-bigger.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/03/nonsense-arguments-... I have no idea of they are something particle scientists do or if they belong to another branch of physics.
- jrumbut 6y agoSure the base is covered, but I'm calling for "20 arguments for quantum gravity experiments" and #18 is "we've tried bigger and bigger particle colliders and the results are disappointing" Everything's disappointing, I am (ironically given my tone here) only interested in hearing from those leading with solutions.
- btilly 6y agoThen read http://nautil.us/issue/45/power/what-quantum-gravity-needs-is-more-experiments http://nautil.us/issue/45/power/what-quantum-gravity-needs-i... linked to from point 18. In summary, the reason for quantum gravity experiments is that investigating contradictions in our theory has always been the best source of progress in science, and experiment has to lead theory. We know that QM and GR contradict each other, and therefore we should research that. She gives a variety of experiments that can research that. The equipment for which is of use in a variety of other sciences. (Particularly astronomy.)
- andi999 6y agoI am not conviced. I mean, you wouldnt want/know what to do with 5 Billion (just looked up the LHC value, I am not sure what the amount of the new proposed accelerators would be) for these kinds of experiments, probably 100 Million would be plenty. If you think that Iter is 15 Billion then 5 Billion doesnt sound so much. (Also in the grand Scheme of things like 50 Billion is not much)
- beezle 6y agoYou mean like RHIC and JLAB? They had to compete mightily over comparative trump change for an upgrade to an electron-ion collider? (RHIC won but JLAB will contribute) There are plenty of other areas of real research that are still nominally 'particle' physics that are actually able to put to paper real goals for what they expect to achieve. There are also facilities like NSLS II that are heavily subscribed and doing research that is both very real world and pie in the sky. Keep this in mind too - the Tevatron at FNAL would have had the Higgs discovery if they could have run another 3-5 years - they already had data order 3 sigma IIRC. Likewise, they would have had a lot more data on the top, something LHC has been gathering since the confirmation of the Higgs. This would have come at a fraction of the cost of the Higgs. Beyond that, has Higgs done anything more than add to the already known to be narrow avenues left for SUSY? She is absolutely correct that the particle physics community needs their feet held to the fire to justify such an enormous single outlay and being a jobs program for a few thousand physicists is not one of them.
- lumost 6y agoThis Collider projects were much more interesting to a public who had remembered the sea change of reactors and the bomb. While I love the LHC, from a productivity standpoint there are other projects which have been bearing more fruit for ~50 billion.