13 ms·
Social mobility without money looks like the dustbowl, or Californian migrant farm workers. Social mobility with money looks like second homes becoming first,
by ggm 6y ago
Social mobility without money looks like the dustbowl, or Californian migrant farm workers.
Social mobility with money looks like second homes becoming first, with huge investments and then questions around socialised cost of roads, infrastructure in general.
If you do the local taxes right, it evens out, but the price of land and housing rises for the non-mobile locals and it makes for some awesome "you're not from around here" issues.
The write-ups of westerners working from Bali goes into a bit of this. Yes, it adds to the local economy. No, not always in constructive ways. Feeding young egos desire for european beer and fixing their skateboard falls costs time feeding local kids in schools and providing primary health care in a stretched local economy which is 10x lower down the scale.
- seibelj 6y agoHave you ever been to the Midwest? They aren’t running out of land. Las Vegas could expand into the desert for an extremely long time. There won’t be the same struggles that you have in coastal cities or exotic expat hot spots.
- foota 6y agoThey are running out of water though.
- devmunchies 6y agoPlenty of water. The problem is its being used to grow food for export.
- dwhit 6y agoI don’t want to starve
- devmunchies 6y agoThen we should grow food in more places.
- dragonwriter 6y agoWhere is there even marginally arable land and not food production? Well, I mean, except when there is suburban sprawl sitting on it, instead, which seems to be what you are proposing, rather ironically?
- 3131s 6y agoWe should be smarter about what foods we "produce". No more meat subsidies, or better yet no more meat at all.
- webmaven 6y agol> We should be smarter about what foods we "produce". No more meat subsidies, or better yet no more meat at all. I'm with you on subsidies, but it's worth noting that historically, cattle, sheep, etc. were often raised and grazed on land that wasn't (and mostly still isn't) suitable for growing crops, usually because of some combination of elevation, slope[0], soil, or lack of rainfall. Animals are mobile, so you can move them around on a larger area with relatively sparse vegetation that humans don't consider palatable[1], or even migrate them seasonally on an even larger territory. So, within some limits, animal husbandry in areas otherwise marginal for agriculture can convert poor ground cover to high quality protein (and other animal products). As long as overgrazing is avoided, this seems to me to be a decent and sustainable arrangement. [0] Terraces can deal with slopes to an extent and slows erosion, but don't always conveniently lend themselves to large scale mechanized agriculture. Solutions to the other challenges also don't work everywhere. [1] It's worth noting that the domesticated animal least picky about what plants they'll eat is the goat, many varieties of which, when not moved frequently enough, can completely denude an area by eating plants and bushes down to the ground, climb trees to eat all the leaves they can reach and even stripping the bark, which kills the tree. Which makes goatherding a likely driver of desertification in already stressed ecosystems.
- Barrin92 6y agogrowing food in fertile areas and then exporting it to places that need more food seems like a better use of resources than using it for the English gardens of suburban zoom tech workers
- devmunchies 6y agoSo... it sounds like other places have a fertility problem. And no, the soil is being depleted of all minerals and life. It’s better to spread farming out.
- Barrin92 6y agoyes indeed which is why markets have allocated resources in such a way that the regions that are very fertile make a lot of food and then sell it to places that aren't, rather than filling them with more terrible low density housing of which the US has already too much
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWe could do a lot to make water usage more sustainable. Most places in the US get at least ten inches of precipitation annually. Very few get less than that. With that much rainfall, a lot of homes can be self supporting with catchment systems, grey water reuse, etc. Edit: Anyone interested in some best practices should look at what Fresno County is doing. They get an average of 11 inches of rain annually and they were basically desert before a canal system was built in the late 1800s. In some years, their ground levels have risen because of their water policies and practices. In contrast, much of the rest of California and the Midwest are experiencing subsidence as water tables permanently and steadily fall.
- sharkmerry 6y agoThey self-admittedly have a unique set of resources. Natural Resources Fresno County is unique among California counties in the range of natural resources (forests, riverways, and wildlife habitats) that encompass its vast terrain.... Two major rivers, the Kings and San Joaquin, flow through this rich landscape, providing the County with its most prized resource, water.[0] [0] -https://www.co.fresno.ca.us/departments/public-works-planning/divisions-of-public-works-and-planning/water-and-natural-resources-division https://www.co.fresno.ca.us/departments/public-works-plannin...
- tfigment 6y agoWater tends to be the real constraint not land in the west. Is there enough water to feed that boom? Does the colorado river flow to the ocean?
- laurencerowe 6y agoMost of that water usage is agricultural though, 68% in Arizona and 86% in Colorado.
- pixl97 6y agoYes, hence it's already in use by Ag
- laurencerowe 6y agoPresumably towns could easily afford to buy those water rights from farmers if needed. Many farmers use inefficient flood irrigation because water rights are so cheap it's not worth them investing in drip irrigation.
- barry-cotter 6y agoYes. People can pay more for water than cows or corn. If water supply is a problem raise prices. Keep on raising them until it isn’t a problem. If some farmers go out of business that’s capitalism. No one owes farmers a livelihood any more than they owe factory workers one. Selling natural resources at below market prices is just a subsidy to the favored industry at the expense of everyone else.
- ianai 6y agoSo LV particularly recycles their water. The dryness is awful and it’s why I moved. But anything that can be reclaimed and reused is. The only waste is the stuff people pour into the yards and thus let evaporate instead of staying in the system. It’s also got the Hoover Dam and Colorado river piped straight to it. (Unfortunately much of that water is sent out to California, but that’s another problem.) Yes, water’s a huge issue in the southwest. It’s also managed differently in different places. But from what I saw in LV, I think it can be a solved problem. It is not a constraint. Edit-But let’s assume water is a constraint. Then why don’t we add to the needed infrastructure projects a project to pump water in from the coast? I’m sure there’s a feasible and affordable way to do it since we already have the highway systems. Just run some pipes alongside it - powered by solar? Doesn’t need to be running 24/7.
- msla 6y agoLas Vegas is the desert Southwest, not the Midwest. Water concerns are real, as is the sheer emptiness. I know some people think Ohio is empty (probably the same ones who think Nevada is Midwestern) but rural Nevada is nuclear test range empty. It's an entirely different order of being.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoColorado isn't exactly land starved. Ask anyone there who isn't making their money directly off of California money how the influx of California money is working out for them and they won't paint a rosy picture.
- 55555 6y ago> The write-ups of westerners working from Bali goes into a bit of this. Yes, it adds to the local economy. No, not always in constructive ways. Feeding young egos desire for european beer and fixing their skateboard falls costs time feeding local kids in schools and providing primary health care in a stretched local economy which is 10x lower down the scale. Fake news. It pours foreign currency into a local economy that was already 80% based on tourism and which has a depreciating currency. Does selling tourists plastic trinkets and taking them on boat trips cost young local children plastic toys or prevent their fishermen dad from having his own longboat? Ofcourse not. Pre-COVID, money was being shoved as fast as it could possibly be shoved into a tiny island where people have tight-knit yet large family structures. All the locals on Bali are richer and better educated than they otherwise would be. I think the worst thing about it may be that it's basically a classic case of the Resource Curse, except instead of oil they have beautiful beaches/etc. Lastly, there isn't really a shortage of land. The island is 5,780 km². I've driven between all 4 coasts and 90% of the time you are seeing nothing but empty nature. https://mapfight.appspot.com/us.ct-vs-bali/connecticut-us-bali-island-indonesia-size-comparison https://mapfight.appspot.com/us.ct-vs-bali/connecticut-us-ba...
- senorjazz 6y ago> All the locals on Bali are richer and better educated than they otherwise would be. Not necessarily. In the early days, perhaps, when businesses were run by locals and the type of tourist who would go, would use local services. Now as a place develops, outside money / developers / owners move in, providing higher quality accommodation, fine dining and the once local business owners are employed as cleaners for a pittance. It is a pattern repeated since the 60s and 70s with the hippy trail when large amounts of people started to visit these places. Once pristine paradise locations are now over developed concrete monstrosities catering to the higher end - out pricing the travellers who first went to the place and the profits all exported to other places
- pc86 6y agoLocals are more than capable of "providing higher quality accommodation."
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>If you do the local taxes right, it evens out, but the price of land and housing rises for the non-mobile locals and it makes for some awesome "you're not from around here" issues. >The write-ups of westerners working from Bali goes into a bit of this. Yes, it adds to the local economy. No, not always in constructive ways. Feeding young egos desire for european beer and fixing their skateboard falls costs time feeding local kids in schools and providing primary health care in a stretched local economy which is 10x lower down the scale. You're being far too nice by choosing the example of a digital nomad living in Bali. A much closer to home and harder to ignore example is what SV money has done to places like Denver, Boulder and is doing to Boise. I don't know what it is. I don't know how to fix it. But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when richer people move in. It shouldn't be that way. And before any east-coasters or Mid-westerners start laughing, NYC money is doing a very good job destroying upstate, PA and VT. Masshole money is crapping all over NH and ME. Chicago is slowly eating more and more of Wisconsin and Michigan. This is a relatively universal problem at least in the US.
- ckdarby 6y ago> I don't know what it is. I don't know how to fix it. But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when richer people move in. It shouldn't be that way. Can you go into more details? I feel like this is a dangerous kind of statement because it is hard to draw a line for people to say what shouldn't and should be. Here is why the statement feels dangerous, it doesn't make arguments directly related to the group and can easily be expanded to: "But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when [people of color, poor people, lacking education, etc] move in. It shouldn't be that way." Perspective is always valuable even applied to what would be the unpopular opinions.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Here is why the statement feels dangerous, it doesn't make arguments directly related to the group and can easily be expanded to: "But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when [people of color, poor people, lacking education, etc] move in. It shouldn't be that way." When poor people move in they don't have the resources to tell everyone else what to do and they don't tend to pick fights with whoever is there first. When rich people move in they get the government to cater to them and local laws change, often to the point where what was previously normal behavior (burning brush, discharging guns within city limits) is no longer even legal. They often pick fights with the local businesses ("I don't like how that second generation pig farm I knowingly bought property adjacent to smells" or they complain about the environmental impact of some third generation junkyard not because it's not folowing the law but because they find it unsighl). Furthermore they co-opt locals with their money. People who genuinely hate all the other changes they bring bury their heads in the sand because the newcomers are spending more money at their business (or whatever) until it finally negatively affects them personally. I would much, much, much rather have poor people move in than the white collar crowd because the former has bigger problems than me and the people around me Doing It Wrong(TM).
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago>If you do the local taxes right How do you do this?
- ggm 6y agoGood question. Prevent digital nomads opting out of anything (typically they do,except purchase tax which is almost impossible to avoid), require them to fund health cover, increase the cost of the visa? As a resident in the NL I had a day of compliance registration to get a local bank account and be a legal tenant more than 1 month and cover the PREMIS health payment. My landlord was pissed off we registered the tenancy because he was not paying rental income taxes. This is the kind of thing which in the west with higher tax compliance we come to understand how many westerners in Bali aside from traders and bar owners do you think paperwork up?