9 ms·
Strange. Business owner friends of mine have taken the opposite approach over the years. Taxes low? Start up something new, get it going. Taxes go up again? Se
by zdragnar 6y ago
Strange. Business owner friends of mine have taken the opposite approach over the years.
Taxes low? Start up something new, get it going. Taxes go up again? Sell it off (if they haven't already) and go back to early retirement doing whatever.
Maybe it is largely the type of business that behavior changes. Their last venture was starting up an aquaponics farm in a borderline urban / suburban area, though I haven't kept in touch and it appears to have been sold off to another family.
- PrinceKropotkin 6y agoFederal taxes have been going down my whole life (born 1990 in the US). What era/region are you referring to where taxes go up?
- zdragnar 6y agoThink state and local taxes. Depending on where you live and the type of business you run, they can add up quickly. Also, the people I am speaking about were most definitely born before the 90's. More like 50's or 60's.
- PrinceKropotkin 6y agoWhere are you living where state taxes are remotely comparable to federal taxes? State taxes are chump change compared to federal, and federal is what generally pays the bills you actually rely on. Capitalists need to stop crying and find decent businesses to build. The benefit of being in a capitalist society is that nobody deserves any fucking tears when things fall apart.
- brewdad 6y agoState and local taxes have been going up in many places. Often in response to decreased federal support.
- PrinceKropotkin 6y agoWhere are state/local taxes remotely comparable to federal taxes? This reeks of crocodile tears. If this is your attitude.... cry more, bitch, we're coming for your cash that you stole from us.
- nostrademons 6y agoI think the OP is talking about investing within the business. The business is a separate legal entity with its own income, expenditures, and assets that is under the control of its owner. Assuming that you want to continue owning the business as a going concern, it makes sense to maximize expenditures (by investing in the future) and minimize profits when tax rates are high. But if you're happy entering and exiting the business as a whole, it makes sense to sell it (transferring money equal to its value to your personal balance sheet) when taxes are low and about to go up, and then just not work while taxes are high. Inflation can put a bit of a wrinkle in this, since if you get $20M for your business and then you find that that's worth the equivalent of $2M in 5-10 years it can crimp your early retirement.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoExactly. Corporate taxes are an incentive for businesses investing in themselves but, as I understand it, an disincentive for investors to invest in businesses. I'm mostly just bothered by how simplistic the debate is and how most people don't even understand this detail.
- nostrademons 6y agoInteresting. This also implies a shift from financial capital (VCs, hedge funds, private equity) to production capital (reinvested profits) when corporate tax rates go up. In the Carlota Perez model, this is the shift from the "frenzy" phase (of huge valuations, founders entering and exiting startups, bubble mentality) to the "deployment" phase (where the technology diffuses through the economy and is adopted as part of the fabric of many companies). I never thought of tax policy as helping drive that, but it seems to correspond pretty well. My other big question is how this interacts with monetary policy. Inflation tends to preference financial capital by a.) lowering the real cost of outside credit and b.) causing dislocations within the economy that create opportunities for new startups. That could offset higher corporate taxes to some extent, while if combined with low corporate taxes it could spark a mania.
- didibus 6y ago> but, as I understand it, an disincentive for investors to invest in businesses I don't see this holding true. Can you explain how? Like, yes as a personal investor you now have less to invest, because you are taxed more on your income. But of the money you have left after tax, investment is still investment. There's no other way to make money of your money then to invest it. So as long as you don't spend all the money immediately, the incentive to invest it is there. Also, the companies you invest in will be incentivized to reinvest in themselves, thus their stock growth potential will be higher, so a good time to invest in them. Finally, the biggest investors arn't individuals, but investment firms, and because they themselves are a company, they themselves are like all others more incentivized to reinvest into their business, thus they are more likely to want to take their profit and invest it some more, instead of cashing it out as revenue.
- throwaway2048 6y agoWhen have taxes been "going up again" exactly.
- zdragnar 6y agoState and local taxes mostly.
- Dylan16807 6y agoIf it's easy to sell the business off then there must be plenty of buyers. Which sounds to me like a good indicator that their response isn't a strong majority.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThere is always going to be someone who will buy your business so they can sell your trucks and equipment and real estate.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI'm assuming they got a reasonable price, because they could easily do that themselves!
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut that's work, and might be done more efficiently by someone in the business of doing that, who has contacts with potential buyers or is selling off the properties of multiple different companies etc.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> Taxes low? Start up something new, get it going. Taxes go up again? Sell it off (if they haven't already) and go back to early retirement doing whatever. Sure — if you're already wealthy enough to get by without any income, that might make sense. But for most business owners the alternative is "work for someone else", not "return to early retirement".
- nickff 6y agoWell, you have to remember that taxes affect the expected outcome, as they reduce the upside of a positive outcome. Taxes do not mitigate the losses from a failure, and most people do not have the resources to sustain failures (without severe negative consequences). By reducing the expected outcome of a new venture, taxes discourage marginal entrepreneurs from starting businesses.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoOP's point is that corporate taxes don't work like that. As a business owner, you can avoid taxes by reinvesting in your business, capturing the positive outcome by way of valuation. If corporate taxes are lower, owners are incentivized to extract profits rather than reinvesting them.
- nickff 6y agoWell, OP is very bad at finance, and his points only apply to certain investments. For instance, most jurisdictions treat capital equipment as retained earnings (it gets more complicated when you get to devaluation and re-sale, but those only matter if the business survives).
- bilbo0s 6y agoThat must be business specific. At first blush, selling when taxes go up sounds like a good way to maximize your losses. But I'm in the tech industry. So aquaponics must be significantly different.
- dumbfoundded 6y agoI don't understand the logic. If corporate taxes are high but capital gains are low, that may make sense. In a general sense, you spend money to avoid showing profit.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danvoell 6y agoDisagree. Agree with 100% with OP. Taxes are high, reinvest in your company. Taxes are low, transfer wealth to yourself. As an aside, just to make some peoples blood flow perk up. In 2020, if you have paid any taxes in the last 5 years, you can expense up the wazoo, and carryback taxes. See cares act. In theory this nets out 5 years of no actual company taxes being paid.
- vkou 6y ago> Taxes low? Start up something new, get it going. Taxes go up again? Sell it off (if they haven't already) and go back to early retirement doing whatever. Sure, they may feel that way. But the person who bought the business off them is still incentivized to behave in the way that the GP post describes.
- majormajor 6y agoWhere have taxes been oscillating so much that you've seen multiple cycles of this?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- question000 6y agoYeah citation needed, other then tariffs taxes have only gone down in the past 30 years...
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoFederal receipts as a percentage of GDP haven't meaningfully changed since WWII. (Which means that they've only gone up in real dollars per capita, because GDP per capita has increased.)
- question000 6y agoYeah so taxes have gone down. If you measure taxes with real metrics they've gone down to their lowest level ever.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat are you talking about? As a percentage of GDP, federal taxes have been the same since the 1940s. But real GDP per capita has increased, so real taxes per capita have increased. And before the 1940s, federal taxes were dramatically lower.