20 ms·
This doesn’t seem as crazy as it appears on the surface. Quibi was streaming video targeted at people on the bus/train or sitting behind a register with nobody
by jandrese 6y ago
This doesn’t seem as crazy as it appears on the surface. Quibi was streaming video targeted at people on the bus/train or sitting behind a register with nobody in line. It had no interest in serving people stuck at home.
- nostromo 6y agoTikTok is in the same niche (short form, mobile-first video content) and hasn't been hurt by the pandemic.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoSocial media is pretty different.
- fumar 6y agoHow is it different from a consumer perspective? As a consumer I have the ability to choose when and what media I interact with. Wouldn’t Quibi be a fun distraction at home for 10-15 minutes?
- awinter-py 6y agotiktok has infinitely more content and pays infinitely less for it tiktok has more viral hits per day than quibi generated in its whole lifetime tiktok is expert at recommendation, quibi doesn't have enough content to have a recommender quibi doesn't have anything share-driven
- eric_h 6y ago> quibi doesn't have anything share-driven and that right there is why quibi failed - the only quibi clip I've seen was taken by someone using another phone to record it and post it to twitter. By not allowing viral hits to be easily shared on any platform they shot themselves in the foot.
- awinter-py 6y agoyeah the 'no screenshots' rule was a thinker
- eric_h 6y agoThere are so many ways they could have allowed sharing of clips/photos without giving copies of all their content to other services (which I imagine was the motivation for making it effectively impossible to share anything on other networks). Seems like such an obvious miss.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- schnable 6y agoTikTok is free.
- ehsankia 6y agoI would definitely put TikTok much closer to Quibi/Youtube than to Twitter/Facebook. Maybe Instagram, but most people go to TikTok to consume media, not to conversations.
- pm90 6y agoThe vast majority of twitter/Facebook users are consumers and not conversationists. Besides, I would say tiktok has the same amount of conversations as twitter.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoThere is a difference between watching 6 second meme videos and full length content.
- drusepth 6y agoTo be fair, I wouldn't be surprised if a large % of TikTok users watch are on the app for durations equivalent to full length content. I see two, three, even four hours/day spent in the app surprisingly frequently. It's built to be addictive and keep you scrolling.
- ulfw 6y ago...where content is produced for free instead of bought in for billions of dollars. How does this compare?
- SilasX 6y agoIt compares in that it's the same thing but a more sustainable sourcing model.
- ulfw 6y agoThen it's not the same thing! I'm sorry. Youtube and netflix aren't the same thing either. One has to pay for hosting costs, the other has to pay for hosting AND sourcing/production costs. (*I am simplifying here. I am aware Youtube is more than that)
- SilasX 6y agoThat’s a really strange concept of “same”. You’re saying that if one business makes a stupid decision (overpays for an input, in this case, content), while the other one doesn’t, then they can’t be compared, merely on account of one having made the stupid decision and thus you can’t really say it was stupid?
- ulfw 6y agoI don't understand how you possible cannot realise there is a difference between hosting other people's content (UGC, in your example tik tok) and producing/sourcing/paying for content (in your example Quibi). There is a difference between being a librarian who sells 1000 books and being a librarian AND author who sells AND writes 1000 books
- SilasX 6y agoOf course there's a difference! Any time you have two things with different identities, you can point to a difference. The important question is whether they have a difference that is applicable to the defense/failure explanation that was offered. My point was that Katzenberg does not. Katzenberg claimed that "gosh, you just can't make money on a short-form video content service right now, there's covid and the lingering effects of 9/11 blah blah blah." Oops, major counterexample: Tik-Tok. YouTube. Instagram/FB stories. Dubious defense: "Oh, those aren't remotely comparable, because they paid less for their content. Obviously, the world turns upside down and the two become incomparable once you fill that service with content you paid too much for. You can't go with the much simpler explanation that we were just much worse at finding content people would be willing to view at a price sufficient to cover our costs." >There is a difference between being a librarian who sells 1000 books and being a librarian AND author who sells AND writes 1000 books Okay, if you want to go that route, the analogy would be: Pointy-haired boss: "I'm going to make a fortune creating and hosting books." PHB: <fails> PHB: "Well, gosh, you know, people just aren't really reading that kind of content now, so of course it's going to be unprofitable." Creators: "What? We make plenty providing content." Bookstores and conventional libraries: "What? We make plenty of money buying and hosting content." PHB: "No, you can't compare that, because I try to do both!" Quibi is just the same, except that you can also add: YouTube/TikTok: "Huh? We make money hosting free content where we share a cut of the advertising with the providers." At what point do you say, "No, dude, the market is there, you're just bad at it"?
- filmgirlcw 6y agoTikTok isn’t $4.99 a month. Now, I would argue that even if it were, it would be more successful than Quibi, but free versus subscription (and the subscription still included ads) are very different things.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y ago> and the subscription still included ads sigh Who thought that would be a good idea.
- mypalmike 6y agoHulu somehow manages to get people to pay and still view ads.
- blueblisters 6y agoBecause the product is not Hulu but the TV shows that you can stream exclusively on Hulu. Clearly very few people were convinced Quibi had content that they needed to watch.
- save_ferris 6y agoIt is crazy that they doubled down on the mobile-only strategy instead of trying harder to iterate, the pandemic has been going on for months. You're telling me they raised all of that money and couldn't stand up a basic web client just to see what would happen? The leadership says quite a bit about it IMO. Meg Whitman has had a legendary career, but even she doesn't appear to have experience founding a tech company. She started at P&G and then went to eBay when it had 30 employees and $4M in revenue[0]. And the founder came from Hollywood, neither of them had real founder experience. I would love to read an insiders account of what happened between the company's formation in August 2018 to April 2020, when the product launched. It looks like they got tons of media deals lined up before the app launched, I wonder how much product development and discovery they were doing during that time. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meg_Whitman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meg_Whitman
- smegger001 6y agolegendary? she drove HP into the ground, to the point wear Bloomberg named her the most underachieving ceo at ebay she purchased skype for 4 billion then turned around and sold it for 2.
- axaxs 6y agoDon't forget that it sold for 4x that a short time later. It sounds like something from a sitcom.
- save_ferris 6y agoI'm not saying that everything she touched turned to gold, but I am saying that she's one of the most high-profile executives in America. Princeton undergrad, Harvard MBA, SVP at Bain, CEO at eBay, HP, primary candidate in a gubernatorial race. That's absolutely a stellar career that most people can only dream of.
- simonsarris 6y agoI think most people's idea of a stellar career is not a collection of titles but a collection of accomplishments.
- majormajor 6y agoContent services have thrived or not based on their content library. So flying directly in the face of that and assuming you could carve out a niche based on a "time of day"/"behavior" thing alone seems very daring, especially when you're still spending an unimaginable amount of $$ on content that you'll need to pay back soon. The swing and a miss on the consumption model crippled the ability of the content to stand on its own and give them any other chance...
- tshaddox 6y agoThat’s how they explained it, and yet what they were actually trying to build was something that, like it or not, would compete primarily with short-form mobile content in YouTube, Facebook, tiktok, etc. And I’m pretty sure people sit around on the couch scrolling through that content for hours.
- seppin 6y agoYeah that's Youtube.
- raverbashing 6y ago> Quibi was streaming video targeted at people on the bus/train or sitting behind a register with nobody in line. Sorry that seems to be the most pointless niche I think someone tried to focus on
- culturestate 6y agoIf you reframe it from "people on the bus/train or sitting behind a register with nobody in line" to "bored people looking for small bursts of entertainment who only have access to a smartphone" it looks a lot less niche.
- BelleOfTheBall 6y agoExcept those people will most often prefer to go watch a minute-long video on YouTube or an even shorter TikTok clip or just scroll mindlessly through their social media of choice even if nothing new shows up. What Quibi failed to understand is that bored people on phones aren't lacking entertainment, they're just in the exact type of boredom that makes them want to do pretty much nothing.
- thirtythree 6y agoI think you have a misunderstanding. The product would work for some of the same people who watch tiktoks.
- ridaj 6y agoEven consumption of video formats intended for snacking blew up during the pandemic. Their content just sucked.
- croon 6y agoIt is exactly as crazy as it appears on the surface. Why target people on the bus/train EXCLUSIVELY when you can get money from everyone else too? The engineering cost isn't that much higher. They actively chose to paint themselves into a corner. I actually wanted to watch the Reno 911 stuff and the Ron Funches show.... on my TV, where I watch stuff. They played stupid games and didn't win any prizes.
- patd 6y agoThey could have pivoted to people that had 5 minutes between meetings and wanted some entertainment while making a new cup of coffee. I’m pretty sure there are millions of us now.
- bambax 6y ago> It had no interest in serving people stuck at home. Why not? Esp. when everybody's at home!? This sounds ridiculous.
- duhi88 6y agoPeople still poop. Let's be honest, "being at home" is not the reason it failed.
- cwkoss 6y agoPooTube would have been a better name than Quibi
- SilasX 6y agoI don't know if you were agreeing with that mentality, but that is a deeply confused business strategy. There's a huge difference between "we [originally] wanted to target market segment X" vs "we will turn down easy money from market segment Y", and Quibi was doing the latter, which is not defensible. That's especially bad when X vanishes and Y increases. (Here, X = people watching on phones, Y = people watching at home.) To be "not interested" in Y is to be not interested in money. Now, to pre-empt an obvious reply: yes, sometimes you do want to turn down easy money from a segment Y. But that's primarily when you're promoting a niche luxury product, where usage by Y will hurt your branding long-term. It's not applicable to a product that deliberately attempts (and needs) to be mass-market, especially when it's targeting transit users and people who have to idly wait.