4 ms·
> Look at your local DMV. This is IMO the only part of your response I disagree with. In most of the OECD, DMVs are wonderful, or at least, functional and exp
by arcticbull 6y ago
> Look at your local DMV.
This is IMO the only part of your response I disagree with.
In most of the OECD, DMVs are wonderful, or at least, functional and expedient. In most developed countries, government work is considered a public service job, and respected, appreciated and well paid. 30% of Norway, Sweden, Denmark and 25% of Finland is employed by the government.
The DMV being the most utterly soul sucking place on earth has little to do with being a monopoly, but rather, Americans belief that the government is worthless, manifest. People - and services - tend to behave the way you expect them to, and this is no exception. While not a uniquely American phenomenon, it's not a function of being a monopoly.
As you'll see virtually all Ontario DMV equivalents (ServiceOntario, broader in scope than the DMV, handling health card issuance, birth certificates, and a many other government services [2]) have wait times under 20 minutes [1]. They also do manage complaints quite effectively via the Ombudsman program [3], and as a last resort, fold neatly under media pressure.
[1] https://data.ontario.ca/dataset/serviceontario-wait-times-in-person https://data.ontario.ca/dataset/serviceontario-wait-times-in...
[2] https://www.ontario.ca/page/serviceontario https://www.ontario.ca/page/serviceontario
[3] https://www.ombudsman.on.ca/contact-us https://www.ombudsman.on.ca/contact-us
- Sevii 6y agoFunnily enough, the DMV is quite nice in some parts of the US.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoThis matches my experience as well. I suspect a big factor is that most civil-service jobs don't allow a person to be penalized or rewarded based on their general level of friendliness when dealing with the public / customers / constituents. Some people in those positions are friendly despite the lack of extrinsic motivation, but not everyone is wired / conditioned to be like that.
- asdfman123 6y agoI was shocked how efficient the DMV was in Seattle after coming from Houston. It was actually a pleasant experience.
- TwoBit 6y agoMy experience with American DMVs is that your experience varies depending on location. The DMVs in densely populated low socioeconomic areas are overcrowded and take hours of waiting and have hostile representatives. Opposite of DMVs in less dense high economic areas. The former have to deal with much more difficult customers, and 5x the number of them.
- busterarm 6y agoI remember when I flew in to buy a car in Elyria, OH and got my temporary tag from the DMV in and out in 10 minutes and was on my way. Even in suburban SC the DMV there was very painless.
- kempbellt 6y agoI wish I could agree, but after waiting in line for an hour just to be rudely dismissed in 5 seconds for not having the "right form", I feel like OP's perspective is pretty accurate. At least here - WA State, USA. I literally got a, "This isn't the right form. Next" type response... Unfortunately, glaring angrily in annoyance at the staff and not saying a word until they extended even an ounce of courtesy by getting the right form for me, was the only way to get through the bureaucratic BS in this situation. A lot of DMV workers, for reasons beyond me, have a sort of "Oh, you forgot to dot one 'i' on this 300 page form. Go back to the drawing board, get in line again, and see me when you are done" type of attitude. Sure, they don't have the time to walk every single person through filling out forms, but a lot of times this lack of enthusiasm to help at all is pushed to an extreme. The DMV here has a very strong "You need US more than we need you" attitude to it. It's one of the reasons I've spent more time driving on expired licenses or with expired car registration than I would care to admit. "Oh, $50 fine? Eh.. Beats waiting in line for the DMV and hating my life for a couple days afterwards."
- Supermancho 6y agoThe Renton, WA DMV is lovely, albeit small. The Kent one is larger, but it's in Kent.
- jonny_eh 6y agoI think everyone here agrees that American DMVs are awful. The point was that it's not necessary that government (or monopoly) services end up that way. As someone that has experienced California DMVs and the equivalent in Ontario, I can confirm the quality in Canada is much higher.
- mikestew 6y agoI think everyone here agrees that American DMVs are awful. I don't, see my sibling reply. I'm perfect content with the WA state DMV and the service I receive. I'm a little peeved that they recently tack on 3% if you use a credit card, but I can understand why. Indiana and North Carolina, OTOH, only contribute to the poor reputation of DMVs in the U. S. and can go suck a bag of dicks.
- SilasX 6y agoWhether the job is respected/well paid, or whether the wait times are long, is orthogonal to whether they’re a painful experience. Every comment I’ve heard about European government offices is that, yes, they’re functional, but you have to be very organized, great at following directions, and super deferential, or they’ll send you down a bureaucratic hellhole.
- OJFord 6y agoAs I understand it from the UK, a 'DMV' is the equivalent of the DVLA, handling 'licence plates' and driver licensing? (And then 'your local' because states.) So, what do you even need to do so frequently that you care how wonderful/expedient/slow/in/efficient your local DMV is? (Nevermind it being a 'soul-sucking place', that you actually go to?!) It sounds to me like ours is better/faster simply by doing less, some red tape that we either don't have or have automated. My first and last interaction with the DVLA was when I passed my test. ..ok maybe I filled out a web form for change of address since.
- bluGill 6y agoI need to get my every 4 years license picture during lunch break (In theory this is flexible, but meetings often give me just an hour), which includes eating and travel there and back. I also prefer to transfer titles for private sales directly at the DMV as this way I know everything was done correctly. None of this happens often, maybe every other year. Still enough that I notice how bad some are. Of course my first job I often ate lunch next door to a very helpful, fast, and friendly DMV office and that started some habits...
- nhooyr 6y agoIf you've ever been to a DMV in Ontario, it's not good. They're horrible in my experience. Interesting to see the data suggests otherwise but just google Ontario dmv experience, everyone here hates them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sjg007 6y agoThe only way to use the DMV is to make an appointment online. If you aren't doing that you will have a bad time.