5 ms·
> Why should any of these people be considered "unemployed"? Because we're actually trying to count "people who would be employed, were there more jobs availab
by michaelt 6y ago
> Why should any of these people be considered "unemployed"?
Because we're actually trying to count "people who would be employed, were there more jobs available"
But as we can't read people's minds, we can't tell the person who's happily retired at 58 from someone the same age who'd rather be in work but can't find it, and has started drawing their pension out of necessity.
- refurb 6y agoBut that’s exactly how the survey works. They ask people if they are available to work and if they are actively seeking work, regardless of age. https://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm#unemployed https://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm#unemployed
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoYou can want a job, but not be looking for a job because your prior attempts to secure one have been unsuccessful. This is called discouraged unemployment and figures into the overall category of marginally-attached workers.
- nradov 6y agoWell it's a spectrum. Many of those who are happily retired would be willing to go back to work if someone offered them enough money. As wages rise the labor force participation rate also goes up.
- malandrew 6y ago> As wages rise the labor force participation rate also goes up. Wouldn't any such effect be temporary though? As wages rise, doesn't inflation rise as well, negating the benefit of a rising wage. Wouldn't it also be true that as certain goods deflate in price, labor force participation should go up as well since the same wage allows you to buy more stuff? This goes back to wealth isn't the money you have, it's what you can buy. Today most people, even those at the bottom, have access to many things today than even John D. Rockefeller didn't have access to when he was alive. Anyways, not asserting anything in particular here, but just raising that it seems far more complicated than just wages rising lead to greater labor force participating.
- pdonis 6y ago> As wages rise, doesn't inflation rise as well No. Inflation is primarily caused by the government printing money, not by rising wages. If wages rise but productivity does not increase, yes, that will cause inflation, but if productivity is not increasing wages cannot rise because there is nowhere for the increased wages to come from. If wages rise because productivity is increasing, there are more goods and services available, so supply keeps up with demand and prices don't rise. (In fact they will generally fall in the areas where productivity is increasing, if the money supply is not being messed with.) > Wouldn't it also be true that as certain goods deflate in price, labor force participation should go up as well since the same wage allows you to buy more stuff? There will probably be more people willing to work, yes. Whether that translates into more actual jobs will depend a lot on how easy it is to start new businesses, since that's where the new jobs will have to come from. Our current regulatory regime makes it much more difficult than it should be to start new businesses. > wealth isn't the money you have, it's what you can buy. Today most people, even those at the bottom, have access to many things today than even John D. Rockefeller didn't have access to when he was alive. This is a very good point, which I wish more people would recognize.
- malandrew 6y agoIntuitively, printing money can't be the only cause at least at a non-macro level. If all the wealth currently currently squirreled away in places that banks can't trivially lend out (art, real estate, etc.) were instead cash in the hands of the lower and middle classes, I would expect a lot more money to be chasing those goods and services against which we measure inflation. This demand-pull inflation against the goods and services we use to measure inflation would cause the measure of inflation to rise and everything that indexes against this measure would adjust. A change in the savings ratio could also cause demand-pull inflation without an increase in printing money. As could a change in reserve requirements. There are also cost-push inflation from things like oil supply shocks, poor farm yields or changes in exchange rates. I would also expect changes in the aggregate balance of payments between a country and all its trading partners to impact inflation experienced by people in that country.
- mickeypi 6y agoThat’s like saying your house is for sale because if someone offered you enough money you’d sell it. Therefore all houses are for sale? Opportunistically earning some extra cash is a lot different than having to work for a living.
- nradov 6y agoYes all houses are for sale. What's your point?
- pdonis 6y ago> we can't read people's minds Exactly. Which means you can't count what you say you're trying to count. What you're trying to count requires telepathy. That's why economists look at revealed preference--what people actually do, not what you guess they might be thinking. So the correct way to see if there are people who would be employed if there were more jobs available, is...to let private individuals start new businesses and see if the increased number of jobs increases the number of people who are employed. But that would require the government to stop trying to micromanage everything, which is why the obvious solution of making it easier to run businesses so that more people will start them in order to create more jobs is a nonstarter politically.
- dalbasal 6y agoThis is how economics goes astray. Being easily and consistently measurable is one virtue. It's nice that "unemployment" can be measured this way monthly without too much measurement controversy. Useful for charting trends with high resolution. That doesn't change the fact that it is not an estimate of "unemployment," defined in a way that we care about more. If you ignore the involuntarily retired 58 year old because measurement is subjective then you are undercounting by a lot. You're not undercounting evenly, especially over time, geo or in extreme circumstances (like recession). It's an issue if the primary unemployment measure does not even estimate "unemployment" harmonious with a common sense definition