3 ms·
It's an interesting idea and hopefully it works out; but there are so many ways this can go wrong. Losing a power grid is an emergency of a pretty high order of
by roenxi 6y ago
It's an interesting idea and hopefully it works out; but there are so many ways this can go wrong. Losing a power grid is an emergency of a pretty high order of magnitude - a long period of time without power and society basically collapses. Limited refrigeration, limited communications, transport might look vulnerable too looking over the long term where it is likely we have to phase out gasoline and replace it with ... maybe electricity from the grid. This would need to be highly redundant and that is not going to be cheap.
I'll opine that it should totally unacceptable for a city to be relying on distant foreign climes for their electricity. Mega-grids to help stabilise the thing over an hour or two, sure. But if I couldn't drive to a big, 24/7 electrical plant in a few hours I'd be feeling very nervous.
OPEC is quite bad enough, there is an enormous strategic problem with sourcing so much oil non-locally. We'd be much better off with decentralised local generation, and the world would be much more peaceful.
- krageon 6y agoThis is isolationist fear-mongering, which would be one thing if you put forth clear arguments for why this is a good idea. Sadly all that is here to find is how bad the consequences are if something would go wrong and something about OPEC.
- ourlordcaffeine 6y agoOutages are not really more likely under this model of many grids connected with DC interconnectors unless a government plans really badly and ends up relying on them. It will always be assumed that interconnectors could go down, thus countries will make sure they have enough reserve generation.
- vagrantJin 6y ago>...long period of time without power and society basically collapses. Im hoping this is a joke. I live in a country that had terrible electricity issues. Much to say there are no riots on the streets and society has not even come close to collapse. (Everyone from the president to schoolkids makes fun of the utility on Twitter) People just make fun of the fact that they have to BBQ more often than not and change diets slightly to account for the lack of constant refrigeration. More people have invested in solar solutions for creature comforts like lights and such. Moral of the story is, people have just become a wee bit less reliant on the energy grid. Renewable sector is booming too. So I'll just stop right here. Because some humans have clearly forgotten the human race has existed for millenia without electricity.
- mabbo 6y ago> some humans have clearly forgotten the human race has existed for millenia without electricity. And some humans have never lived in a place that falls below freezing in the winter. I lived through a 3-week ice storm in '98 in eastern Ontario [0]. That wasn't even a large outage, just constant failures all over because the ice weighed down and broke power lines. 34 people died, a huge number of farm animals died, and that was with the military being called in to try to help everyone. You take out all electricity to a major city like Toronto in the dead of winter for a week, thousands would die from the cold. Take your "liveable climate privilege" outta here, lol. [0]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_1998_North_American_ice_storm https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_1998_North_American_...
- vagrantJin 6y agoHaha. Freak events happen everywhere but I doubt the dessert dweller wants to hear stories of your floods. A couple thousand dead people, bless their souls, does not constitute a break down in society. And considering we have people in remote regions shrugging these things off without electricity but basic tools and fire - Id be concerned about the lack of thinking and foresight among the population rather than the weather.
- roenxi 6y ago> society has not even come close to collapse > change diets slightly to account for the lack of constant refrigeration Maybe I have unreasonably high expectations of civilised society compared to you. What country, and what is the longest (contiguous) period your area has gone without power? I'm just doing rough estimates, but after ~72 hours any food that needs refrigeration is at risk, mobile phone networks are gone and electronic transactions are gone. That is a pretty crippling level of stress on a modern first world nation.