4 ms·
ManBearPig is the perfect example of something everyone really needs to know: if someone appears to be a galactic asshole, who makes a mean-spirited TV show whe
by jeffbee 6y ago
ManBearPig is the perfect example of something everyone really needs to know: if someone appears to be a galactic asshole, who makes a mean-spirited TV show where everyone behaves like a jerk, then it's quite likely that they are in fact an asshole. These entertainments are not edgy, insightful cultural artifacts. They're just assholes on TV.
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agowould you say the same of john oliver?
- theplague42 6y agoDo you sincerely think Last Week Tonight is on the same level as South Park?
- jeltz 6y agoYes, I do. His stuff is often poorly researched and presented for maximum entertainment value rather than for accuracy. I may be pretty close to him politically but his stuff is mostly just entertainment.
- theplague42 6y agoCan you point to a specific instance of him valuing entertainment over accuracy?
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agoReally? Any example? I rely pretty hard on his show.
- disown 6y agoIt's worse. It's literally foreign propaganda. I know oliver became a citizen and he loves the mets.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoKinda? South Park is more obscene, but I’ve seen quite a few Last Week Tonight clips where the takeaway is clearly meant to be “haha, those people are such dummies!” I really do get it, and I personally enjoy both shows, but the genre of political humor tends to inevitably involve cheap shots at political opponents.
- theplague42 6y agoThey aren't even remotely the same type of show! I don't know how you could possibly try to compare them. You wouldn't try to compare the Super Bowl against Downton Abbey, would you?
- jansan 6y agoLast Week Tonight and a similar German show heute Show are the worst, because the make fun of people from an assumed moral high ground, which they do not have. They really want to show their viewers; "Ha, look how stupid other people are. It's alright to laugh about them, because they are so dumb. Good thing we the good ones!". It is absolutely despicable. South Park never does this. They just make fun of people or current trends in society, without evaluating them morally. They are more drastic, but never claim moral superiority.
- CerealFounder 6y agoThe irony of the guy who angrily groups all satire as"galatic'ally asshole'ish"should be rewarded with upvotes. Also, entertainment is both plural and singular jb. Like sheep.
- jeffbee 6y ago> entertainment is both plural and singular In this regard you are opposed to David Foster Wallace and therefore, obviously, wrong.
- tomc1985 6y ago> These entertainments are not edgy, insightful cultural artifacts. They're just assholes on TV. 20+ years of cultural commentators, the Oscars, and show ratings suggest that you're wrong. Stone + Parker may be assholes, but they are insightful assholes, performing the much-needed task of holding our noses to the shit we left behind
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Stone + Parker may be assholes, but they are insightful assholes "Insightful" about how people respond to messages in the same sense that a successful demagogue is, except that they are playing on "easy mode" where they don't have to produce results of their own to be judged by -- or even, in classic demagogic fashion, to distract from by attacking some other target -- sure, they are definitely that kind of insightful. Insightful beyond that...well, none of the evidence you point to is explained any better by adding that additional assumption. They don't hold peoples noses to the shit left behind, they are just masters of the clever juxtaposition of the cheap, easy, shallow (mostly recycled, but for the juxtapositions) attacks. They are also good at crafting amusing stories, and welding the shallow attacks into the stories as a delivery vehicle. So I'm not saying that they aren't talented, just that the talent has nothing to do with any substantive insight regarding the substance of their targets. Actually, I think they'd be a lot less successful at what they do if they didn't have an absolute and total lack of interest in substance, which would be a distraction from the cheap, easy bomb-throwing. EDIT: Rereading that, it sounds more hostile than I would like. I mean, South Park is great entertainment, there's certainly value to periodic, momentary escape into the kind of cheerful,shallow nihilism it wallows in. My wife and I had Stan and Wendy figurines on our wedding cake. I'm not anti-Stone/Parker, just against the idea that their work is insightful social commentary. Not only is it not, and not only is that central to its success, but, to the extent it is (personally, to me, and arguably socially) valuable, that's also central to its value. Its not intellectually stimulating, enlightening, or insightful, its an escape from being intellectually "on" at all.
- jariel 6y agoI think the word you are looking for is 'satire' and it's cutting and intelligent not because of the depth of their understanding of some issue, but their willingness to offer characters and comedy around simple ideas and perspectives others dare not broach. Charlie Chaplin was didn't exactly delve into ideology. 'PC Principal' is a brilliant satirization. They skewered the sometimes insufferable Tom Cruise because everyone else has to 'fall in line' to the inside censorship and only they had the courage to just 'have a go'. The bubble they've created for themselves where they can now get away with just about everything is otherwise non-existent in the industry.
- jariel 6y agoTrey Stone and Matt Parker are geniuses. True satirists in a world where satire of certain forms is not allowed (i.e. you cannot satire Hollywood or SJ issues in entertainment) and they've taken on considerable risk by doing that (i.e. mocking the Hollywood entertainment system). They are literally one of the only entities in the US to point-blank take on Chinese censorship. They are comedians, not Scientists, they're allowed to step out of bounds and be 'wrong' that's the point - it's not even about 'right or wrong' for gosh sakes. Anyone taking literal social cues from an antagonizing cartoon is going to be led astray. The 'Assault on Reason' is coming from a lot of angles these days.
- theplague42 6y agoYes the considerable risk of producing a wildly popular television show on Comedy Central. So brave and risky.
- jariel 6y ago? The 'risk' is to their own creations - they have been threatened with cancellation time and time again, probably more so than any show in history. Do you wonder why people on talk shows, on the news in interviews, never say anything bad about anyone, never have an opinion, never critique - unless it's political? - because they risk being ignored, losing out on the next deal, upsetting a director/producer/exec/casting agent on the creative side, or advertisers (very powerful) on the business side. Count how many people will mock Tom Cruise, Scientology, China, Hollywood - or more poignantly almost corporate brand etc. - none really - it's to expensive to one's career. How often has SNL mocked Google, Apple, Tesla, Ford or any major corporations (or their products) in an edgy, satirical way? Never. It doesn't happen because it's censored for obvious business reasons. How many SNL or other comedy skits have you seen over all the massive rape allegations concerning Hollywood figures? Nobody is going to touch that because they're all in the 'same industry' - it's socially toxic. There are zero shows on Television today which aggressively take risks for the sake of 'comedy' - it's almost sad that it's getting kind of old and there's nobody to hand the torch too. Parker and Stone have carved out for themselves an amazing 'safe bubble' years ago - they basically took a stand and said 'we will say anything' and didn't care which bridges they burned. Weirdly it became 'accepted' for them to court controversy within the walls of their show. Sacha Cohen does some really outrageous stuff, but it's politically very safe. South Park as a vehicle is stale, it was 10 years ago, but that it's legit satire, and one of the only sources of it, is why it's still around.