3 ms·
> you can observe what happens as you approach it Yes, but you cannot extrapolate from this to say that the time lapse for a photon would be zero. A photon is
by pdonis 6y ago
> you can observe what happens as you approach it
Yes, but you cannot extrapolate from this to say that the time lapse for a photon would be zero. A photon is not the limit of objects with mass going closer and closer to the speed of light, because "closer and closer to the speed of light" is frame-dependent, but a photon's speed being c is not. I can find an inertial frame in which each of your objects is at rest, and in that frame, you are the one who is "close to c" (in the opposite direction). But that doesn't mean your elapsed time approaches zero. By contrast, it is impossible to find any frame in which a photon is at rest. The two types of objects are fundamentally different.
In more technical language, the action of Lorentz transformations on photons is fundamentally different from their action on timelike objects. So it is simply not valid to view photons as some sort of limit "as speed approaches c" of timelike objects.
- lopmotr 6y agoBut is there any physical way to distinguish these fundamentally different situations? If not, then perhaps the fundamentalness of it is just an artifact of the formulation. I'm thinking of solar neutrinos which, for a while, we weren't sure if they were massless or not. We had to observe them experiencing a duration of time to conclude they were massive. If we didn't find that, maybe it was just an even shorter duration, not the absence of one and we would never be able to tell the difference.
- pdonis 6y ago> is there any physical way to distinguish these fundamentally different situations? Are you asking if there is a way to distinguish a timelike object from a lightlike object? Of course there is. The fact that, for something that has a very, very small invariant mass, it might be practically difficult does not change the fundamental principle. Also note that the reason it was difficult, for example, to tell whether neutrinos have mass or not is that we can't just do the obvious and straightforward thing and find an inertial frame in which they are at rest (by, for example, taking a rocket and accelerating it in the direction of a neutrino to see if we can bring it to rest relative to the rocket). So we have to resort to indirect methods. But, again, that's a practical limitation that doesn't change the fundamental principle.
- lopmotr 6y agoIt still doesn't sound physically distinct any more than distinguishing any continuous quantity as being zero or nonzero. If we measure something that looks like 0, we can't be sure if it's just below the sensitivity of our instruments. For neutrinos, even if we accelerated an rocket and somehow checked if a neutrino was at rest relative to it, we might find that it's not. That means we won't know if we need more speed or if it's impossible. I suppose it's a bit easier than that because we only have to accelerate the rocket fast enough that the neutrino's speed becomes measurably less than c, rather than 0. But still, what if we can't even get it to go fast enough for that? No way to prove that it's travelling at c, it seems. I'd like to add that even photons have a nonzero upper bound to their possible rest mass. At least they used to. Is there any way, in principle, to show that it's exactly zero, and thus falls into this distinct category?
- ymolodtsov 6y agoWith neutrinos we might find that it's not but it'd be impossible to catch a photon as it would always have the same speed of c in our reference frame. > I'd like to add that even photons have a nonzero upper bound to their possible rest mass. At least they used to. Not sure what you're talking about, their momentum? No object with mass can reach the speed of light and we know they're travelling at that exact speed.
- lopmotr 6y agoHow do we know they're travelling at exactly c? That's my concern. Last I heard, a couple of decades ago, physicists would occasionally measure a new maximum possible rest-mass for photons. It would be very tiny, of course, but they couldn't say it's exactly zero.
- pdonis 6y ago> How do we know they're travelling at exactly c? That's my concern. We don't, strictly speaking. The measurements you refer to aren't even measuring the speed of photons. They're measuring their rest mass. > physicists would occasionally measure a new maximum possible rest-mass for photons. It would be very tiny, of course, but they couldn't say it's exactly zero. Based on just those measurements, no. The most they can say is that the photon rest mass is zero to within some error bar, and the size of the error bar keeps getting smaller. (The current error bar, IIRC, is 10^-52 grams, or about 24 orders of magnitude smaller than the electron mass.) However, we have a ton of indirect evidence that photons are massless; the most extensive body of such evidence is all the evidence for the gauge invariance of electromagnetism. If photons had a nonzero rest mass, that would break electromagnetic gauge invariance. So photons having a nonzero rest mass would be a huge issue for our current theories, in the way that neutrinos having a nonzero rest mass would not; there is no important symmetry coresponding to electromagnetic gauge invariance that is broken by neutrinos having a nonzero rest mass.
- phkahler 6y ago>> In more technical language, the action of Lorentz transformations on photons is fundamentally different from their action on timelike objects. I don't believe that, and have never heard it before. There are many ways in which light actually behaves just like particles with mass traveling at speed c. It has to or conservation of momentum is violated.