5 ms·
Not sure that's 100% true. Many places may indeed skip over someone like that, but there's no law I've ever read that says "if someone sends in a picture, you
by mgkimsal 16y ago
Not sure that's 100% true. Many places may indeed skip over someone like that, but there's no law I've ever read that says "if someone sends in a picture, you can not consider them for a position". Perhaps if you know of such a law, you could post it here?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- lean 16y agoIt's in the spirit of compliance with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Any HR dept in the US will have a strict policy on this.
- mgkimsal 16y agoSee my point above on phone calls. I understand the 'spirit', but not everyone interprets that 'spirit' the same way, and some companies still have the guts to not ignore people simply because of what's on their resume - photos included. If I see someone lists attendance at an historically black college, or has a traditionally feminine name, I can already deduce their race or gender without a photo, and I can do whatever discriminating I want to do using that information. Company policies that throw out applicants because they've attached included any sort of photo at least as damaging (because of the loss to the company of potential talent) than lawsuits over Title VII violations, but it's much harder to quantify that. It's going to get harder and harder to even guard against this stuff as email clients merge social media information in while reviewing applicants. Oh, unless you just buy and use crappy web-based application software that requires 14 screens that only works in IE6 - then you'll be 100% safe from any chance of getting interested and qualified applicants (and lawsuits too).
- lean 16y agoI'm not arguing the logic of it, simply stating that, to my knowledge, it's a blanket practice. Discussion, and counter-examples are welcome.
- mgkimsal 16y agoCounter example: No companies I've worked at had an explicit policy of rejecting a resume with a picture/photo. Whether it was done by some people in practice - unsure.
- lean 16y agoAll of the companies I've worked for _did_ have such an explicit policy, but both of our examples are anecdotal.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoThe company I work at doesn't have that policy and neither has any other I've worked at.
- mgkimsal 16y agoBut @lotusleaf1987, that's just anecdotal :)
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoThat's totally my point, it's all anecdotal until someone does actual research and a poll.
- mgkimsal 16y agoThe :) was meant to indicate a bit of sarcasm ;)
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoSorry sometimes sarcasm on the internet is hard to grasp. I may also be a bit socially under-developed. ;)
- 16y ago
- eli 16y agoYou are using a very extreme interpretation of the law. It's illegal to discriminate against someone on the basis of race and other protected classes. So by extension, it's best practice to avoid asking applicants for their race or asking them for a photo, lest you give the appearance that it's a factor in the hiring decision. But I've never heard of rejecting someone outright for sending an unsolicited photo. That's just crazy. Would you also reject an applicant who had "President of African-American Student Union" on their resume because it belies their race?
- thingicantsay 16y agoWould you also reject an applicant who had "President of African-American Student Union" on their resume because it belies their race? Well, likely he wouldn't, but we can be sure that he would reject someone outright for having "President of the European-American Student Union", can't we? Charitably, this is because there is essentially no chance anyone would ever file a lawsuit for rejection of the second candidate. I'm sure you can draw the uncharitable version yourself. :)
- eli 16y agoI'm not really sure what you're saying, but it sounds mildly offensive. It's both wrong and illegal to reject a candidate based on their race, regardless of what race that is. And I am pretty sure the OP was not implying otherwise. Further, I assure you that white people file discrimination lawsuits too.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>I assure you that white people file discrimination lawsuits too. // Out of interest have you a reference to a white person winning a race discrimination case, preferably with regard to being hired? Also why should "an applicant who had 'President of African-American Student Union' on their resume because it belies their race?"? Surely a person of any race can be president of the African-American SU, or are they allowed to be racists?
- rhizome 16y agoMy sense is that it's always a bad idea to ask for a picture and chances are that sending one won't help. The resume is in French, though, so this is likely different in Europe.
- city41 16y agoMy resume doesn't include a picture, but it does have links to my StackOverflow profile, blog and github account. All three contain a picture of me. I've never had it be an issue while job hunting.