4 ms·
> The difference is that light travels through space, but not time This is a common pop science statement, but it's not correct. A correct statement is that th
by pdonis 6y ago
> The difference is that light travels through space, but not time
This is a common pop science statement, but it's not correct. A correct statement is that the concept of "speed through spacetime", which is what has to be split into "speed through space" and "speed through time" in the pop science statement, does not apply to a light ray.
In more technical language, the tangent vector to the light ray's worldline is not a unit vector, it's a null vector, and the concept of "speed through spacetime" only makes sense for a worldline whose tangent vector is a unit vector.
- CamperBob2 6y agoI wouldn't say it's incorrect at all. From the point of view of a photon, no time elapses between its the origin and destination endpoints.
- pdonis 6y ago> From the point of view of a photon, no time elapses between its the origin and destination endpoints. No, this is not correct. The correct statement is that the concept of "elapsed time" does not apply to a photon; it only applies to timelike worldlines, not null worldlines. To put it another way, if your statement were true, it would mean that the origin and destination events were the same point in spacetime. But they're not; they're distinct points in spacetime. Which means that, since the spacetime interval along the worldline is zero, you can't use the interval to distinguish points on the photon's worldline. And the concept of "elapsed time" requires that you be able to do that. So the concept of "elapsed time" can't be used for a photon.
- umvi 6y agoIt's impossible for an object with mass to go the speed of light. But you can observe what happens as you approach it: Let's say I put you in a spaceship and accelerate you to 50% the speed of light toward the sun. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at half the speed of light and it takes you ~16 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took ~14 minutes to crash into the sun[0]. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .99c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took ~1 minute to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 20 seconds to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .9999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 6 seconds to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .99999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 2 seconds to crash into the sun. See what's happening? As you approach the speed of light, the amount of time that elapses until you reach your destination approaches zero. So from an inertial observer's point of view, time has completely frozen for travelers approaching light speed. [0] Using time dilation formula from this page: https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html
- pdonis 6y ago> you can observe what happens as you approach it Yes, but you cannot extrapolate from this to say that the time lapse for a photon would be zero. A photon is not the limit of objects with mass going closer and closer to the speed of light, because "closer and closer to the speed of light" is frame-dependent, but a photon's speed being c is not. I can find an inertial frame in which each of your objects is at rest, and in that frame, you are the one who is "close to c" (in the opposite direction). But that doesn't mean your elapsed time approaches zero. By contrast, it is impossible to find any frame in which a photon is at rest. The two types of objects are fundamentally different. In more technical language, the action of Lorentz transformations on photons is fundamentally different from their action on timelike objects. So it is simply not valid to view photons as some sort of limit "as speed approaches c" of timelike objects.
- lopmotr 6y agoBut is there any physical way to distinguish these fundamentally different situations? If not, then perhaps the fundamentalness of it is just an artifact of the formulation. I'm thinking of solar neutrinos which, for a while, we weren't sure if they were massless or not. We had to observe them experiencing a duration of time to conclude they were massive. If we didn't find that, maybe it was just an even shorter duration, not the absence of one and we would never be able to tell the difference.
- pdonis 6y ago> is there any physical way to distinguish these fundamentally different situations? Are you asking if there is a way to distinguish a timelike object from a lightlike object? Of course there is. The fact that, for something that has a very, very small invariant mass, it might be practically difficult does not change the fundamental principle. Also note that the reason it was difficult, for example, to tell whether neutrinos have mass or not is that we can't just do the obvious and straightforward thing and find an inertial frame in which they are at rest (by, for example, taking a rocket and accelerating it in the direction of a neutrino to see if we can bring it to rest relative to the rocket). So we have to resort to indirect methods. But, again, that's a practical limitation that doesn't change the fundamental principle.
- CamperBob2 6y ago(Shrug) You can go argue with Neil deGrasse Tyson, it's over my pay grade. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ELA3ReWQJY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ELA3ReWQJY
- pdonis 6y ago> You can go argue with Neil deGrasse Tyson Show me an actual textbook or peer-reviewed paper Tyson has written where he makes this claim. Pop science videos don't count. (Tyson is by no means the only one; Brian Greene is notorious for the same thing.) You won't be able to because there aren't any. No scientist who talks about a photon "experiencing zero time" in informal contexts will try it in a textbook or paper. That's because they know that if they did, other scientists would call them out on it, so they confine such claims to contexts where there are no other experts so there's nobody to call bullshit. Another point is that if this concept were actually scientifically useful, somebody would be using it in a textbook or peer-reviewed paper. The fact that nobody is is a huge clue that the concept is not scientifically useful. It's only useful for selling pop science books or getting views of pop science videos, where, again, there are no other experts around.
- CamperBob2 6y agoDude, this is basic theory at the high school level. Here's how it works: spacetime is 4-dimensional, and a vector in spacetime is always c units long. You can restrict your travel solely to X, Y, Z, or time if you like. If you do that, the other three components are going to be zero. Photons put it all into the X, Y, and Z components, leaving nothing for the t component. They experience a change of position in space, but not in time. What's so hard to grasp about this? Another point is that if this concept were actually scientifically useful, somebody would be using it in a textbook or peer-reviewed paper. Seems that a fellow named Maxwell got a lot of mileage out of the concept, even if he didn't know what was really going on.
- pdonis 6y ago> Dude, this is basic theory at the high school level. No, Tyson's claim is not "basic theory at the high school level". It is a particular interpretation of a theory (Special Relativity) that does not work, for the reasons I gave. > Photons put it all into the X, Y, and Z components, leaving nothing for the t component. Wrong. The spacetime vector that describes a photon's trajectory does have a t component. > Seems that a fellow named Maxwell got a lot of mileage out of the concept Dude, if you think the concept Tyson described is the same as the concept that Maxwell got a lot of mileage out of, then you are the one who needs to learn more about "how it works".
- phizy 6y agoThere is no "point of view of a photon." Photons do not have frames of reference. So you are completely incorrect insofar as what you are saying is physically nonsense.
- CamperBob2 6y agoAgain, take it up with Tyson and others with doctoral-level credentials who've made a career out of explaining these subjects to the unwashed laity. I'm not one of those people. Nobody posting on Hacker News is, as far as can be discerned. If you and others in the thread feel that these popular authorities are spreading misinformation or using inappropriate analogies, doesn't it behoove you to raise an objection with them directly? Or perhaps with the appropriate faculty committees at their institutions?
- pdonis 6y ago> If you and others in the thread feel that these popular authorities are spreading misinformation or using inappropriate analogies, doesn't it behoove you to raise an objection with them directly? If they want to make money by getting "the unwashed laity" to buy their books, why should I stop them? I simply don't buy them myself. If other people want to get told comforting nonsense, that's their problem. Caveat lector. > Or perhaps with the appropriate faculty committees at their institutions? Which would be pointless and absurd, since, as I have already said, the claims in question are not being made in textbooks and peer-reviewed papers. I suspect you are trolling.
- phizy 6y agoSo you take no responsibility for spreading misinformation if the prior source is not corrected? Sounds like you're acting in bad faith then. You can win an internet argument anywhere, but if that's all you want to achieve here, then maybe stop trying to debate physics.