3 ms·
People like to work themselves up about things like this, but the non-repairability of modern electronics is a simple matter of physics and economics. The phys
by jiggawatts 6y ago
People like to work themselves up about things like this, but the non-repairability of modern electronics is a simple matter of physics and economics.
The physics aspect is that the most straightforward way of assembling such tiny and lightweight devices and have them be at least somewhat waterproof is to glue them together.
The economics aspect is more important.
I just had my AirPods break last week. I took them to an Apple store and they were replaced under warranty for $0. This still felt expensive, because it took half of my Saturday to drive to an Apple store, sit around while they tested the device, and then drive home. Simply having my free time wasted is -- to me -- a comparable opportunity cost to simply paying for a pair of replacement AirPods.
In general, everything breaks, and eventually is simply not worthwhile repairing because replacement with a newer model with more features is a more attractive proposition. Making things repairable is more expensive, so there's a tipping point where it is counterproductive for manufacturers to design their products for longevity.
This tipping point changes with the wealth of nations over time. As people's time becomes more and more expensive, bothering to repair cheap gadgets becomes less worthwhile. Paying for someone to repair them becomes increasingly expensive.
Repair is a service, electronic gadgets are products.
As the cost of services increases relative to manufacturing, the tipping point moves.
Of course, there's always going to be the complainers bemoaning the changing times.
These complaints are literally stating: "I don't like manufactured products getting so cheap that they can be simply thrown away! I prefer the good old days of relative poverty where people had to resort to expensive services to repair even more expensive products! I miss those times!"
Don't listen to the Luddites, embrace the increased wealth of nations made possible through manufacturing automation.
- snazz 6y agoI think it's possible to bemoan the environmental impact without being a Luddite who would prefer "the good old days of relative poverty". Your other points are valid and it's certainly clear why manufactured electronics are the way they are, but it's unclear how the goalposts could be shifted to encourage environmental responsibility.
- jiggawatts 6y agoIn their recent iPhone 12 presentation, Apple made it very clear that they are one of the more environmentally friendly electronics manufacturing companies in the world. They have a net zero carbon footprint, they recycle as much material as it is feasible to do so, and they've even worked hard to source rare earth metals responsibly. Meanwhile people are frothing at the mouth because the tiniest, most compact device they make isn't modular. That's just asinine.
- amelius 6y agoRepairable electronics are always preferable to non-repairable electronics, all else being equal. If Samsung can make pods with replaceable batteries, then power to them.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoHave a look at process to replace those batteries. I doubt that even 1% of them gonna get new batteries. https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Samsung+Galaxy+Buds+Battery+Replacement/127556 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Samsung+Galaxy+Buds+Battery+Rep...
- amelius 6y agoEvery aspect of technology requires time to perfect. This means they are already 1 iteration ahead of Apple.
- klodolph 6y ago> Repair is a service, electronic gadgets are products. There’s a name for this effect—Baumol’s cost disease. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease
- pessimizer 6y agoAll of this is rationalization. It's just planned obsolescence. Nobody on goddamn Hacker News is a Luddite. The Luddites weren't even Luddites the way you're using it, which is just a slur for an imagined cranky old man as afraid of technology as Phil Hartman's Frankenstein's monster is afraid of fire. The economics are that you want products that you sell to be rendered useless as soon as possible, barring the possibility that the customer becomes so resentful that they switch products. So you claim that features that will eventually destroy a product are necessary to make it appealing, you hide the costs of replacing the product through purchase schemes and equivocations about the environmental impact, and you denigrate older models as horrifically, irresponsibly dangerous. > Of course, there's always going to be the complainers bemoaning the changing times. This is a vapid argument that can be used to defend anything from New Coke to the Holocaust.
- opnitro 6y agoEnjoy the wealth of nations until the seas rise at least...
- arcticbull 6y agoYour apologism really rubs me the wrong way to be honest, and you've made such a strange, strongly-worded conclusion not at all supported by evidence. Laptops with batteries, for instance, aren't "luddite" technology. Plenty of companies still make them. There's other ways of connecting a battery to chassis even in a small form factor like AirPods. For instance, a threaded base that screws in. It's not rocket science. What you're saying is that Apple, the great innovator, can't find a way to make replaceable battery in a clean and elegant form factor for a small device, and that's the reason that nations are wealthier now than they used to be? C'mon now, that's hard to make with a straight face isn't it? Failure is now success. Private profiteering at the expense of the environment is technophilia. Feels a lot like Owellian doublespeak to me. tl;dr: Apple spends $16B per year on R&D. They can figure out how to screw a battery into an AirPod, and no, that's not why we're all wealthy now. It's why Apple is wealthier now.
- amluto 6y agoA non-replaceable battery in an AirPod makes perfect sense to me — AirPods are tiny. Laptops are a different story entirely.
- arcticbull 6y agoI just don't see why that's the case though, regardless of size, why fill dumps with perfectly functional technology because a consumable part is glued instead of screwed in? There's no justification, especially at the $300 price point. I guess my question is, why are you championing e-waste? What benefit do you get from losing the ability to replace a battery?
- jiggawatts 6y agoYou're thinking emotionally, not looking at the actual numbers. A laptop is a physically large device, typically in the $1000 range, and the "overhead" of a screw is negligible. Did you watch the video? AirPods are a marvel of modern engineering! They're incredibly, astonishingly packed full of fantastically miniaturised parts. This is absolute bleeding edge stuff. A screw, no matter how tiny, would absolutely be a problem. You'd also have to make the battery "loose" and not glued in, add a connector for it -- but not one that could work loose from normal shaking. This is a borderline physically impossible problem that's just not worth it to solve. What volume do you think all the AirPods in the world take up in rubbish tips? No, seriously. Let us sit down and compute this: At least one site is claiming that Apple sold 60 million AirPods in one year. The charging case is 44.3 x 21.3 x 53.5 mm and together with the two AirPods weighs 44 grams. That's 2,640 tons annually: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44+grams+*+60+million https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44+grams+*+60+million ... or about 20% of the trash produced by New York daily, And in terms of volume, it is a little more than the volume of an Olympic swimming pool: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44.3+mm+*+21.3+mm+*+53.5+mm+*+60+million https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44.3+mm+*+21.3+mm+*+53... You'd also have to factor in that adding a screw doesn't mean that 100% of all AirPods are recycled in perpetuity, but that more like 20% might have their lifespan extended one or two years at most before the owners lost or broke them. Now keep in mind that Apple sells over half of all wireless headsets globally, so the sum total annual e-waste is double those numbers above, roughly speaking. Not exactly the end of the world. Or to put it another way, I own a set of AirPod+case that weigh 44 grams. I bought them a year ago. The 4g airpods got replaced after 1 years, generating 4g of e-waste in the first year of ownership. I intend to keep these for at least one more year, generating twenty-something grams of waste in annualised terms. I just took out the family garbage today, it was several kilograms. I have a small family.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> This still felt expensive, because it took half of my Saturday to drive to an Apple store, sit around while they tested the device, and then drive home. But that's exactly why you want repairable products. It takes less time to fix something yourself with a standard screw driver and inexpensive commodity parts than to travel to the manufacturer's facility and prove to their satisfaction that it's broken so they'll replace the entire product. What you really want is products that work like legos, so that no individual piece costs more than $25 and anybody can replace what's broken in five seconds without expert knowledge or specialized tools. To minimize labor costs.
- wrs 6y agoIt’ll be interesting to see your design for AirPods based on inexpensive commodity parts. :)
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoPart one, battery; part two, Bluetooth radio; part three, speakers; part four, chassis; part five, etc. This is not arcana.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoBut you're missing part zero: Fit all these objects in your ears, comfortably, without them weighing too much or sacrificing on sound quality. I think it is arcana, because there's no real competition to the AirPods, all other similar products are huge and ugly, or have terrible battery life, or terrible bluetooth, or some combination.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's hard to design a good Bluetooth radio, or a good battery etc. It's not hard to screw them together. But Apple makes the individual parts themselves and won't sell them to anybody else.
- zxcmx 6y agoOk, so I don't think airpod waste is a big deal in the grand scheme of things. But I also don't think I'm a luddite re: disposable electronics. I think I'm the opposite. I agree that as integration and product complexity increase, it makes more sense to make a new thing from feedstock than repair an old thing. But what we can do is recover the resources used in manufacture. Critically, the product needs to be made in a way that supports this. I want manufacturing to be so advanced that "full circle" resource recovery is incorporated into the design. The glues have corresponding (low toxicity) solvents for disassembly, the plastic can be cheaply digested back to clean monomers, the metals easily separable. No "retrofit" processes with show pony robots, but full "reverse manufacturing" facilities built with the same care and attention as the ones that make the product. The thing I want is more automation, and more advanced design.
- XorNot 6y agoThe thing is, this is repairability and Apple don't want to see it. If you can reverse the glue, then it means there's going to be some guy who gets really good at this and sets up a mall shop where he does it for you for like 10% the price of replacement and throws in a warranty because he can. Boom goes your profit margin.
- bluquark 6y agoThere's another economics aspect relevant here, which is that environmental costs are unpriced externalities (unless the government intervenes). The economic logic of non-circular economy is sound only for the parties with a direct, short-term economic stake in it (you, Apple, and its suppliers). The system compensates you for your time wasted driving to the Apple store, but does it sufficiently compensate people whose children grow up in the midst of pollution from mining or landfills?