3 ms·
How is stoicism lost when people talk about it on hackers news like every day. Also, sometimes people are actually victims of s something, even if small injust
by watwut 6y ago
How is stoicism lost when people talk about it on hackers news like every day.
Also, sometimes people are actually victims of s something, even if small injustice. And from experience, trying to act like it is no issue never solves it.
- waihtis 6y agoThings happen and time can only move in one direction. What use does it serve to wallow in victimhood and self-pity VS adopting a stoic attitude to events?
- watwut 6y agoCause people who adopt stoic attitude to evens do not make change. They don't get what they were supposed to, they don't make world better. They are passive. They easily turn into enablers. They end up tempted to claim injustice does not happen further gasslighting victims trying to fight. Speaking as someone who used to think stoic attitude is superior.
- waihtis 6y agoSounds like you’ve misunderstood stoicism as a concept, but curious how you approach life post-stoicism?
- watwut 6y agoThe person i responded to is misunderstanding it the same way when he is building taboo around word victim. As for what after, it would be complicated to answer. I am changing attitudes toward more activity, more willing to show up anger or other emotions when not showing them is the passivity road.
- waihtis 6y agoFYI I'm the same person, and I'm not building a taboo around the word victim. Stoicism doesn't advocate for you to be less active. Again, you're misunderstanding the base definition of stoicism. This is much of the same argument I hear about buddhism over here where people somehow think it's a religion of nihilism. Be a victim or more angry or whatever you like, but it's not going to provide solace, meaningful help or generally better outcomes to you in any situation, plus other people will respond less effectively to it.
- andreilys 6y agoThis is a pretty unfair characterization of stoicism. I suggest you read some primary texts rather than a few blog posts on the internet. Stoicism does not advocate for passivity at all. Just look at Marcus Aurelius, one of Rome’s greatest emperors.
- pessimizer 6y agoIt's a response to a pretty unfair characterization of people who recognize themselves as victims. The reason some are irritated with people who claim to be victims is because of their activity and action, not because of their wallowing and passivity. When people are wallowing in victimhood rather than speaking up about it, the people who have a problem with that are the compassionate, not the comfortable and resentful. Wallowing in victimhood is depression.
- stanrivers 6y agoThe idea is not that you should act like it is no issue... you should act that it is an issue that you can do something about. Being stoic is not giving up on the world altogether; it is understanding what you can control. You can control how you handle a situation if you do not view yourself as a victim. The moment you start thinking that you are a victim, you lose control of the situation. Some people truly ARE VICTIMS - but it is rare that thinking that you have some power over the situation and there is something that you can do about it is a bad idea. Something like this: https://butwhatfor.substack.com/p/takeaway-tuesday-facing-adversity https://butwhatfor.substack.com/p/takeaway-tuesday-facing-ad...
- watwut 6y agoIf someone steals from you, you are victim of robbery. If someone rapes you, you are victim of rape. If your collegues assume you are not skilled cause something about your look, you are victim of bias. If your partner is verbaly abusing you, you are victim of that. Thinking you are victim in those situations is using right words instead of building taboos. The moment you admit yourself you was victim of something, you can act on it. If you don't, you end up like one of those victims that will ratilnalize their abusers behavior. There is no shortage of women who instead of admitting they are victims and admitting partner is abuser, just don't want to be those girls. And they will excuse and rationalize and keep appearances.
- stanrivers 6y agoSo, first and foremost - apologies. I had read two replies and put them together in my head when replying to you. So, yes, I agree with what you are saying here. The idea that I was trying to get at is that you can accept that you were a victim and do something about it. We are saying the same thing - but you are saying it better, so sorry for the confusion. Additionally, some people are victims of situations - so say, poor family background, a minority race that is looked down upon by the majority, having a chronic illness - and you can accept that is true but mentally decide that you are going to take steps to make it better, however you can. You don't want to land in "I have no control and am a victim" when you are being victimized. That is what you are getting at too. As a society, we don't want to create a society where anyone being abused feels like continuing to be abused is actually better than looking for help / making a change. That's not the victim's fault... that's someone choosing what they see as the best of two not attractive outcomes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]