5 ms·
Accounting firms and their partnership structure confuses me. Seems very archaic relative to corporate structures. Makes it hard to figure out who’s calling the
by Scoundreller 6y ago
Accounting firms and their partnership structure confuses me. Seems very archaic relative to corporate structures. Makes it hard to figure out who’s calling the shots.
When I go to the Canadian E&Y website, it says:
> EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients.
PwC refers me to a separate website for their structure: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/about/corporate-governance/network-structure.html https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/about/corporate-governance/network...
KPMG has been mixing it up, per wikipedia:
> KPMG International changed its legal structure from a Swiss Verein to a co-operative under Swiss law in 2003[25] and to a limited company in 2020.[4]
Are they basically franchises? Is there some uber-partner at the global hq collecting massive commissions?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrlala 6y agoWell it's mostly because partnerships are extremely flexible flow-through structures. If it were a corporate structure, there is corporate tax, so you have more of an incentive to spend as much as you can as opposed to tight spending and paying people as little as you can so you get as much profits as you can (partnership flows directly to the individuals, so there is no form of double taxation). Also with a partnership you just rewrite your agreement which you keep 100% internally and do whatever you want. Corporate structure has a lot more overhead, you have requirements that should be met and so forth. There are good reasons.. most of them the same old bs taking advantage of the system in one way or another.
- gamblor956 6y agoThey're partnerships because they're usually legally required to be partnerships as a matter of liability concerns. (Most countries now allow professional firms to be professional LPs, LLPs, or PCs, limiting the financial liability of partners for the debts of other partners but not those resulting from their own malpractice.)
- mdifrgechd 6y agoThis is how I understood it was well. Big four partnership structure is optimized to comply with the legal requirements for auditors. That is why e.g. accenture (which has no auditing arm) can be publicly traded but the rest cannot.
- gamblor956 6y agoThey are global collectives of individual country-level partnerships (though in some countries they are allowed to be corporate entities rather than partnership entities). Each country-level partnership is its own independent firm, and can generally choose to re-affiliate with another multinational "firm" as it desires. This actually happens quite frequently. Generally, the member firms cross-bill each other at discounted rates. They make up for it through increased volume of work and/or more lucrative work.
- genericresponse 6y agoYou'll see similar models in law firms. IMHO it's driven by two key elements in the business: An apprenticeship-like, up-or-out model for developing talent and a vested owner-operator class at the "partner" level. These firms effectively operate as a collective for the benefit of the partner class. New partners must invest capital, ongoing partners get returns, and older partners retire with a terminal payout. Some partners may take on expanded leadership roles and get higher annual payouts. The overarching legal structure is a sort of "modularization" to limit the liability of lawsuits and enable flexible operation. There is a usually a global partnership council that dictates universal operating norms and practices. Again, fundamentally, it operates as a collective and international units support each other for collective benefit.
- zeveb 6y agoI would be really interested to see this model applied to software. I am unaware of any firm that has done it this way so far — which is odd, because it really does seem tailor-made to suit our sort of work, no? Or maybe I am missing something.
- namdnay 6y agoI'm not sure it's what you'd describe as "software", but consultancy firms like Deloitte have an identical structure, and they do a lot of IT projects
- scottjg 6y agoi think the reason consultancies (legal firms, accounting firms, etc) do it, and not traditional software companies, is because the worker hours translate directly into billable hours. Partners are incentivized to bring in more business, which the associates (and the partner him/herself) can bill against. I think partners are usually expected to bring in a certain amount of business to justify their profit share. In a traditional software company, like a SaaS business, I don't know how it would translate. A developer fixing bugs might be important for the business, but ultimately is hard to translate to the bottom line. It's not like hiring a high level executive will have a guaranteed ROI in the same way.
- tidepod12 6y ago>Are they basically franchises? Is there some uber-partner at the global hq collecting massive commissions? Yes and no. In practice, each "country firm" (such as the PwC US firm) operate as individual companies with their own leadership team that, while they don't have the typical CxO titles, they have the same roles. Tim Ryan is basically the CEO of PwC US, for example, and PwC UK is a different company with a different CEO. Internationally there is also an umbrella organization that helps coordinate really high level stuff like branding (since all the country organizations share the same branding), internal IT strategy (such as getting everyone to use the same productivity tools to make it easier for cross-firm collaboration), etc. The individual companies reap benefits from this coordination because of the singular, strengthened brand, culture, methodology etc. So in that way it sort of is like a franchise. But that international organization doesn't have much to do with the day-to-day in-country operations or decisions about specific audits/projects. That would be the responsibility of the local partners/leadership team.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> Makes it hard to figure out who’s calling the shots. Making it very hard to hold someone, well, accountable. Almost as if not an accident.
- tidepod12 6y agoNah, the reality is that it's very easy to figure out who's accountable for any specific project. While it may not be clear who is in charge of a firm as a whole, that is not the case at the project level. Every project/audit must be signed off on by a partner, and that partner is the responsible party for any and all firm activity that happens on that project/audit. The water gets muddied because that partner may not actually be involved in the project very much, and in controversial situations they may try to blame someone else (such as a lower level firm employee who was involved) for any mistakes, but at the end of the day the partner who signed their name to the contract is the person held accountable.
- hyperdimension 6y agoIs this a similar type of standard Professional Engineers are held to? I'm sure they don't, e.g. design every member of a bridge and do the stress calculations by themselves, but when it comes time to certify the design, the PE (and the PE alone, if I understand the way it works correctly, regardless of how many people worked on the drafts) is the one upon whom the entirety of the blame lies should the bridge collapse.
- tidepod12 6y agoAFAIK, yes. Other people on the project/audit can be held responsible too if they contributed negligently, but the partner who oversaw the project is ultimately accountable for the work. That partner is also who the PCAOB/SEC would fine and/or suspend their accounting certification.
- FuckButtons 6y agoThis is correct, the firm will usually have internal fines for partners with inspection failures / comments. There is significant individual liability for an audit partner.
- drieddust 6y agoThey also provide project management services and run PMO in multi vendor scenario. At least according to my personal experience they field in rookie armed with powerpoint and excel templates and zero brain. Perhaps they Re asked not to use brains. There is no need to say what kind of mess they end of creating.